Great pizza place, place is warm and inviting. Pizza and appetizers were delicious and fresh and the service was friendly and quick. Plus it’s in Newcastle downtown , very cute location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hileila Eisenbeis
As my attached photo shows - what I ordered and what I got are not the same. And when I called about it I experienced the worst customer service. Had I been told upon ordering that the Stella 2.0 comes with a dry bag of arugula on the side and no lemon juice/olive oil/sea salt then I wouldn’t have paid more to have the “2.0” version. I called just confused and trying to inquire about having the dry bag of arugula on the side and the lady immediately is offended and says “I’m going to have you talk to the head chef to explain” and I can hear her say to him “can you talk to this customer? I’m about to freak out on her cuz she’s talking about the Stella 2.0 coming with a dry bag of arugula on the side!” The poor guy is interrupted from his job, I let him know I could totally hear her and that due to that: they just lost a customer. I’m disappointed I chose them over the 10+ other options in the area. Moving forward I’ll be taking my business elsewhere and letting everyone else know my experience. Maybe have a option for the paying customer to decide if they want arugula on the side/dry in a bag or risk it being soggy with the lemon juice/olive oil/ sea salt - or just have it as only in person option, not to go order. Either way/ it’s very misleading and I’m disappointed with how the pizza came out, it’s not what I thought I was ordering and then the customer service after totally ruined my appetite. Hopefully nobody else experiences this; so I’m sharing what happened.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ted Wolfe
Those wings. Omg. Yummy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alyssa Austin
Great consistent pizza but idk why you changed your bruschetta but it was horrible. Go back to the old way.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Travis Pointer
Lived in Penryn for 9 years now and just discovered New Castle Pizzeria. What a treat, some really high end pizza going on here! We had the Meatball appetizer, Michigander salad and If you must pizza (combo). They were all excellent, fresh ingredients, great wood fired crust and the meatball sauce was great for dipping the pizza crust! Highly recommend this place. One of the better pizza places we have found in the area. Restaurant also has a cool vibe!
Pizza scale rating: 8 - Very good, would get again. FINAL Rating 8.5
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gregory Ajaji
Great pizza and beer what more can you ask for
Bo Luhellier
Great food, quick service, and friendly wait staff! Inside is small and a little stuffy, but not over crowded.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ron Alvarez
Went with my fiance and mother-in-law. We got the Stella 2.0 pizza & the Aloha pizza. Both were great. Great services & great food. The place opens up around dinner time. Show up early. The place fills up fast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian and Diana Long
My family and I had the most wonderful experience here for dinner. The pizza is made with high quality ingredients, the service is amazing and the wine and local beer selection went perfectly with our food. It's in an old building in Newcastle that makes for a charming departure from all of the chain and strip mall restaurants down the road. Looking forward to trying more pizzas soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Isaac Monroe
Such a sweet family friendly place. We have two littles and this place just makes you feel at home and at ease. Love this place.
Pizza is usually good, last time we dined in it was a bit greasier for my taste. But I just tried calling in for takeout 30 min before close and I was told kitchen was closed. I understand wanting to go home quickly, but as someone who has been in the food service industry for 15 years I will not be dining here anymore due to the fact my money isn't good enough to work during operating hours. I won't support lazy business when they aim to serve me the consumer when it's convenient. Unfortunate...
Kyle Schuck
Not only is this food great but the service is even better. Truman is a true gem! Dude deserves a raise if he doesn’t already own the place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brad Thomas
Great pies. Try the meatballs while you're at it. And they have one of the best salads you'll ever eat.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tina Molander
This is a great local spot for delicious and unique pizza. We also love their wine selection, beer selection, and we don't ever leave that having a delicious Caesar salad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: International Pizza
Chris Suwyn
The pizza itself was really good but the portions are pretty small, which wouldn’t have been bad if when I ordered over the phone the guy would have told me as much, so I could have ordered more. Instead we ended up with way too little pizza for too many people.
Great pizza place, place is warm and inviting. Pizza and appetizers were delicious and fresh and the service was friendly and quick. Plus it’s in Newcastle downtown , very cute location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As my attached photo shows - what I ordered and what I got are not the same. And when I called about it I experienced the worst customer service. Had I been told upon ordering that the Stella 2.0 comes with a dry bag of arugula on the side and no lemon juice/olive oil/sea salt then I wouldn’t have paid more to have the “2.0” version. I called just confused and trying to inquire about having the dry bag of arugula on the side and the lady immediately is offended and says “I’m going to have you talk to the head chef to explain” and I can hear her say to him “can you talk to this customer? I’m about to freak out on her cuz she’s talking about the Stella 2.0 coming with a dry bag of arugula on the side!” The poor guy is interrupted from his job, I let him know I could totally hear her and that due to that: they just lost a customer. I’m disappointed I chose them over the 10+ other options in the area. Moving forward I’ll be taking my business elsewhere and letting everyone else know my experience. Maybe have a option for the paying customer to decide if they want arugula on the side/dry in a bag or risk it being soggy with the lemon juice/olive oil/ sea salt - or just have it as only in person option, not to go order. Either way/ it’s very misleading and I’m disappointed with how the pizza came out, it’s not what I thought I was ordering and then the customer service after totally ruined my appetite. Hopefully nobody else experiences this; so I’m sharing what happened.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Those wings. Omg. Yummy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great consistent pizza but idk why you changed your bruschetta but it was horrible. Go back to the old way.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Lived in Penryn for 9 years now and just discovered New Castle Pizzeria. What a treat, some really high end pizza going on here! We had the Meatball appetizer, Michigander salad and If you must pizza (combo). They were all excellent, fresh ingredients, great wood fired crust and the meatball sauce was great for dipping the pizza crust! Highly recommend this place. One of the better pizza places we have found in the area. Restaurant also has a cool vibe!
Pizza scale rating: 8 - Very good, would get again. FINAL Rating 8.5
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza and beer what more can you ask for
Great food, quick service, and friendly wait staff! Inside is small and a little stuffy, but not over crowded.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went with my fiance and mother-in-law. We got the Stella 2.0 pizza & the Aloha pizza. Both were great. Great services & great food. The place opens up around dinner time. Show up early. The place fills up fast.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family and I had the most wonderful experience here for dinner. The pizza is made with high quality ingredients, the service is amazing and the wine and local beer selection went perfectly with our food. It's in an old building in Newcastle that makes for a charming departure from all of the chain and strip mall restaurants down the road. Looking forward to trying more pizzas soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a sweet family friendly place. We have two littles and this place just makes you feel at home and at ease. Love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is usually good, last time we dined in it was a bit greasier for my taste. But I just tried calling in for takeout 30 min before close and I was told kitchen was closed. I understand wanting to go home quickly, but as someone who has been in the food service industry for 15 years I will not be dining here anymore due to the fact my money isn't good enough to work during operating hours. I won't support lazy business when they aim to serve me the consumer when it's convenient. Unfortunate...
Not only is this food great but the service is even better. Truman is a true gem! Dude deserves a raise if he doesn’t already own the place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pies. Try the meatballs while you're at it. And they have one of the best salads you'll ever eat.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
This is a great local spot for delicious and unique pizza. We also love their wine selection, beer selection, and we don't ever leave that having a delicious Caesar salad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: International Pizza
The pizza itself was really good but the portions are pretty small, which wouldn’t have been bad if when I ordered over the phone the guy would have told me as much, so I could have ordered more. Instead we ended up with way too little pizza for too many people.
Food: 5
Service: 3
Loading...