The Pantry Pizza & More

222 Madison St, Oakland
(510) 625-8401

Recent Reviews

Kristian Hanelt

So happy to see that this place has reopened! My family and I used to go there all the time when they originally opened 6 years or so ago. They have the best pizza ingredients, the best crust and just generally the best pizza ever! It was a bummer when they closed and we were so happy to see they have reopened! Have already signed them up to cater my 6 year old's birthday this month.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Cheese Pizza

Austin Truong

Solid cheese pizza and garlic oil crust. The crust had a nice chew factor and crunch at the same time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Mario Herrera

Great pizza good wine!

B Williams

First post ever. Try niche places on all my travels. I love bread. Had a whole write up on this crust and ingredients...just try it. Warm up of already made pizza..i was skeptical. Tried both on display. I'd lean toward veggy. cheeses and meats gets a little salty for me. If you have better near you...your blessed.

Elizabeth Ann Ennis Green

We got the Saturday Meat Pizza and greens side salad. It was perfect. The crust is amazing and the toppings are an awesome combo.

Jennifer T.

SO sad you are no longer open. Hope you will consider putting out a cookbook - your pizzas were simply incredible. Please contact me if I can purchase the recipe to my favorite hot soppressata pizza. Miss you guys-

Topher Lubaway

Nice people and amazing pizza. You should eat their pizza, you won't regret it. (Saturday meat pizza is our favorite :)

Topher Lubaway

Nice people and amazing pizza. You should eat their pizza, you won't regret it. (Saturday meat pizza is our favorite

Yazmin N.

I can't agree any more with charles j. This is the most delicious neighborhood joint. Actually, it's the best pizza and the best service I've ever had (I used to stop by and get a slice every Thursday after getting home from work). I tried calling and I got no answers, so I hope they are ok as well. My friends and I love their pizzas which are super veggie and non-veggie friendly. I hope they come back soon!

charles j.

No no no no no!! Where did you guys go?!! You're the best pizza I've ever tasted!! Omg please be okay and God bless.

Ben Williams

First post ever. Try niche places on all my travels. I love bread. Had a whole write up on this crust and ingredients...just try it. Warm up of already made pizza..i was skeptical. Tried both on display. I'd lean toward veggy. cheeses and meats gets a little salty for me. If you have better near you...your blessed.

M Herrera

Great pizza good wine!

Melynda L.

Love the fresh pizza and salad! Really friendly good people here! I heard the lasagna was amazing but I always get sidetracked by the pizza! A friend of mine orders it to go for dinner! Also, cold beer and wine are available!

Shashwat Rajvaidya

Amazing hidden gem. The best pizza I've had.

Gabrielle T.

Two stars for custie dedication, which was non-existent until I turned to leave and the staff suddenly realized they're here to make the bucks, not the friends. One star for the subpar, flat slice that ended up in the trash just as hastily as the purchase was made; regrettable given the level of food waste in our society! This brings us to an average of one and a half stars (I know, it's hard to believe I didn't pursue that career as a mathematician with this kind of aptitude), which I'm gonna round down on account of being hung up on when I called to ask about their vegetarian special of the day. I'm sure that there's something, somewhere, somehow at this place that is digestible but I haven't found it and I'm pretty much cool off the idea of searching and scheming to get there. Do better, folks.

Load More