Worst experience ever. We ordered food at 5pm to be delivered at 7pm. We didn't receive the food until 820pm. We never received a call or notification. Instead we call once 740pm. We were told it was going to be 15min fast forward another 30min we call again. The food is almost at our house. Just to be delivered lukewarm/cold food and undercooked breadsticks. I literally have to reheat the food in the oven. Not to mention the pizza is damn near ripping through the box. I'm a local business owner and blown away at how poor the service is. I will never give this place another chance. Completely unacceptable for $90. We are disputing this charge.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kevin L.
Good pizza, with a great deal. 2 slices of pizza and soda specials. The bread was ok, a bit doughy for a thin crust pizza even though it's color was good sounds strange, but there it is. The cheese was great, which was the polar opposite of the sauce, that was a bit sour. Toppings were good, nice place to take a load off.
DIAN WUSTHOF
Their sauce is the best; fresh garlic big tomato flavor; crispy flavorful crust; and plenty of toppings; such great pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Joe's Special
T N.
Finally got to try this place after passing it numerous times. Really wanted to like it but every single piece of pizza we grabbed the cheese and toppings just slid right off the pizza; very disappointing! Didn't find the pizza to be particularly special or different. Rated 2 stars for the decent taste and friendly staff!
Peggy K.
We stopped in here for lunch for the first time today and absolutely loved the pizza. The crust was delicious, crispy on the bottom yet fluffy and perfect on top. This pizza didn't get soggy on the bottom as it cooled as is often the case with pizza. Employees were friendly and welcoming which enhanced our experience. Great food + friendly atmosphere = a real winner with us! We will definitely be back.
Cassandra S.
We needed something to eat quickly and thought we'd come to a local while we are in town for the week. Unfortunately, it left us wanting more. Their pizza was okay, the lunch deal is the best bang for your buck. The pizza was extremely oily, and coming from a New Yorker, usually this isn't an issue. The pepperoni pizza was just falling apart everywhere, so it wasn't really a flat crust or regular pizza. It needed to be eaten with a fork. Portions were okay. Service was friendly, door was open though so there were a ton of flies. Maybe we caught them on an off day.
Bob H.
Great pizza, but a little pricey. Joe's combo is one of the best local pizzas around.
Len G.
Excellent pizza,friendly and helpful employees. First class service. Great choice of beer.
S. W.
Wow, suprised by the change!! My last visit on 7/15/23 resulted in a 2 star rating. Surprisingly my visit on 12/1/23 was a night and day change. The pizza crust was back to normal and very well cooked. Mama J's now differentiates themselves from all others by the large volume of toppings they now put on their pies. (Very appreicated) The toppings were generous and of good quality. While a little slow by only using 1 oven, well worth the wait. Excellent turn around by the owners!!
Cynthia L.
This pizzeria immediately became a favorite. The pizza was delicious and the atmosphere is cozy! The menu offered a diverse range of pizza options. I opted for their Joe's Specialty pizza, loaded with a generous assortment of toppings. The crust was not overly crisped and the heart of the pizza was savory. The amount of ingredients used were well- balanced. Each bite bursted with so much flavor. Not only was the food exceptional, but the ambiance was also charming. The cozy interior and dim lighting created a relaxed atmosphere, perfect for a casual dinner or a gathering with friends. The staff were attentive and friendly. The pricing was reasonable for the quality and quantity of food served. They deliver locally also. They have their own delivery vehicle. If you can go in person, It's worth it.
Last night placed a delivery order because I just couldn’t make it out the house and I was so pleased with how hot and warm my pizza was when it came! I also was a little far out of their delivery range and they still came!!! I felt so bad I had no cash in hand so will definitely have to tip extra next week!! We love mama J’s!!!A hidden gem! Came here for the first time with my family, we ordered take out and from the moment they answered everyone was so nice and very welcoming! The place is so clean and smells so good and they have a great menu selection with a ton of good options! definitely will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie J.
My husband & I have been coming here for a while when in the mood for pizza. We dinned in tonight & even though they were busy with take out & deliveries, the service was outstanding. The young lady who helped us even came over to apologize for the wait & told us our pizza was coming up. The young lady who brought us the pizza apologized to us as well. We honestly didn't wait that long. Plenty of time to eat our salad & relax. Maybe 20 minutes total. The pizza was great tonight. Perfect sauce, cheese & toppings on a tasty crust, not burnt, not soggy. The waitress checked on us a couple times, which I was impressed with. Great staff!!!
Richard Shepard
You ever have pizza so good you can’t swallow fast enough? That was my experience today at Mama J’s Pizza! I ordered the PAPA MIMO'S SUPREMO on cauliflower crust. Amazingly tangy sweet red sauce, perfect amount of high quality ingredients and not only did the crust not suck, cuz GF crust usually does, but it was tasty with just the right amount of chewy and crunchy! Love love love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dale EZ Forbis
Delicious sauce, amazing dough and fresh quality ingredients. Having been raised in Chicago, I am kind of a pizza snob. So when I say this is the best pizza I've had in my 30 yrs in Sonoma County, you should take notice. Brava!!
Paul Wilkinson
The quack quack oink pizza was fantastic.Prompt friendly
Worst experience ever. We ordered food at 5pm to be delivered at 7pm. We didn't receive the food until 820pm. We never received a call or notification. Instead we call once 740pm. We were told it was going to be 15min fast forward another 30min we call again. The food is almost at our house. Just to be delivered lukewarm/cold food and undercooked breadsticks. I literally have to reheat the food in the oven. Not to mention the pizza is damn near ripping through the box. I'm a local business owner and blown away at how poor the service is. I will never give this place another chance. Completely unacceptable for $90. We are disputing this charge.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Good pizza, with a great deal. 2 slices of pizza and soda specials. The bread was ok, a bit doughy for a thin crust pizza even though it's color was good sounds strange, but there it is. The cheese was great, which was the polar opposite of the sauce, that was a bit sour. Toppings were good, nice place to take a load off.
Their sauce is the best; fresh garlic big tomato flavor; crispy flavorful crust; and plenty of toppings; such great pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Joe's Special
Finally got to try this place after passing it numerous times. Really wanted to like it but every single piece of pizza we grabbed the cheese and toppings just slid right off the pizza; very disappointing! Didn't find the pizza to be particularly special or different. Rated 2 stars for the decent taste and friendly staff!
We stopped in here for lunch for the first time today and absolutely loved the pizza. The crust was delicious, crispy on the bottom yet fluffy and perfect on top. This pizza didn't get soggy on the bottom as it cooled as is often the case with pizza. Employees were friendly and welcoming which enhanced our experience. Great food + friendly atmosphere = a real winner with us! We will definitely be back.
We needed something to eat quickly and thought we'd come to a local while we are in town for the week. Unfortunately, it left us wanting more. Their pizza was okay, the lunch deal is the best bang for your buck. The pizza was extremely oily, and coming from a New Yorker, usually this isn't an issue. The pepperoni pizza was just falling apart everywhere, so it wasn't really a flat crust or regular pizza. It needed to be eaten with a fork. Portions were okay. Service was friendly, door was open though so there were a ton of flies. Maybe we caught them on an off day.
Great pizza, but a little pricey. Joe's combo is one of the best local pizzas around.
Excellent pizza,friendly and helpful employees. First class service. Great choice of beer.
Wow, suprised by the change!! My last visit on 7/15/23 resulted in a 2 star rating. Surprisingly my visit on 12/1/23 was a night and day change. The pizza crust was back to normal and very well cooked. Mama J's now differentiates themselves from all others by the large volume of toppings they now put on their pies. (Very appreicated) The toppings were generous and of good quality. While a little slow by only using 1 oven, well worth the wait. Excellent turn around by the owners!!
This pizzeria immediately became a favorite. The pizza was delicious and the atmosphere is cozy! The menu offered a diverse range of pizza options. I opted for their Joe's Specialty pizza, loaded with a generous assortment of toppings. The crust was not overly crisped and the heart of the pizza was savory. The amount of ingredients used were well- balanced. Each bite bursted with so much flavor. Not only was the food exceptional, but the ambiance was also charming. The cozy interior and dim lighting created a relaxed atmosphere, perfect for a casual dinner or a gathering with friends. The staff were attentive and friendly. The pricing was reasonable for the quality and quantity of food served. They deliver locally also. They have their own delivery vehicle. If you can go in person, It's worth it.
Restaurantji Recommends
Last night placed a delivery order because I just couldn’t make it out the house and I was so pleased with how hot and warm my pizza was when it came! I also was a little far out of their delivery range and they still came!!! I felt so bad I had no cash in hand so will definitely have to tip extra next week!! We love mama J’s!!!A hidden gem! Came here for the first time with my family, we ordered take out and from the moment they answered everyone was so nice and very welcoming! The place is so clean and smells so good and they have a great menu selection with a ton of good options! definitely will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband & I have been coming here for a while when in the mood for pizza. We dinned in tonight & even though they were busy with take out & deliveries, the service was outstanding. The young lady who helped us even came over to apologize for the wait & told us our pizza was coming up. The young lady who brought us the pizza apologized to us as well. We honestly didn't wait that long. Plenty of time to eat our salad & relax. Maybe 20 minutes total. The pizza was great tonight. Perfect sauce, cheese & toppings on a tasty crust, not burnt, not soggy. The waitress checked on us a couple times, which I was impressed with. Great staff!!!
You ever have pizza so good you can’t swallow fast enough? That was my experience today at Mama J’s Pizza! I ordered the PAPA MIMO'S SUPREMO on cauliflower crust. Amazingly tangy sweet red sauce, perfect amount of high quality ingredients and not only did the crust not suck, cuz GF crust usually does, but it was tasty with just the right amount of chewy and crunchy! Love love love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious sauce, amazing dough and fresh quality ingredients. Having been raised in Chicago, I am kind of a pizza snob. So when I say this is the best pizza I've had in my 30 yrs in Sonoma County, you should take notice. Brava!!
The quack quack oink pizza was fantastic.Prompt friendly
Food: 5
Service: 5