Barone's Restaurant

475 St John St, Pleasanton
(925) 426-0987

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bob Liu

Ordered fish and chips. Salads had strange taste. Virtually no service at all - they even don’t refill your water.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jesus Alonso

??????

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jaime Paniagua

It's a good place ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrew Cain (Andrew C)

Updating this review.Since their reopening they have a far more limited menu making it hard to come here to eat a meal now. This is not the Barones of the past!The restaurant was dead when we arrived and dead when we left. Seems like the community has spoken! Hopefully the owners recognize this and change it up again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Motorsports Euro

Was looking for a place with live music and dinner for a special date night. Everything started off great, music started at 7 place was fairly empty, ordered food and drink. Food was ok. Music was good also. All of a sudden a huge corporate holiday party takes over the room and it’s so crowded you can’t even stand and definitely can’t hear the music. We literally had to push people out of our way to get out. Thanks for ruining my date by being selfish and advertising live music, then booking a large party while pretending it’s still open to the public. This is greedy and inconsiderate. It’s also unfair to the waitstaff. No one told us when we walked in that the outdoor tent would be used for a function and happily took my money for dinner. Don’t bother going there, they ruined my night but you can still save yours by going somewhere else.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 4

James Levinson

All I had was fish tacos. This review is only for the fish tacos and that is all. I would remove the fish tacos from your menu. They are not good. For $20, I expected much better fish tacos. These fish tacos were heavily breaded and had no flavor, with some kind of unknown bland sauce and they ended up in your mouth like a lump of oily mush. Like I said, I would remove the fish tacos from your menu - after all, it's an Italian restaurant, right?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Craig Jones

Such a fun and vibrant restaurant. The outdoor seating is amazing and the live music was top tier. If you’re lucky enough to have Mario as your server you’re in for a great night. Perfect date night spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karnsiri Tiangteratam

What an amazing restaurant!We went there to celebrate my dad 76 birthday and they were very accommodating.It’s a very beautiful restaurant. It looks like it was a house converted into a restaurant.Excellent service and excellent food.We ordered a couple bottles of delicious Malbec and an unflavored mai tai.I had the chicken Parm, which was good. My dad had Seabass, which he said was very good.The shrimp, calamari and chicken wings appetizers were amazing.The most impressive part is that they allowed me to bring in a cake. They kept it refrigerated and when it was time to sing my dad happy birthday they brought it out with lite candles, which totally shocked me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Russ Hamilton

Yes its closed

Frank Gomez

Maureen and I will miss our times at Barone's, but we will always have the memories of our wedding reception, special events and dinners on the patio.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Braised Short Ribs, Filet Mignon and Lobster

Elisa Hermance

Christmas party was fabulous food excellent and service outstanding. Great place. E

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

LaurieH

Long time locals, first time diners here. The food was excellent and our server, Carlos was outstanding. We are so sorry to hear that Barones will be closing soon.

LouisR

Outstanding. They are scheduled to close in a week. OpenTable should request they stay open.

Marylu

Loved everything but the noise level! Horribly loud couldn't hear the waiter or each other. ;(

Cheryl B

Over charged. As we waited an unusually long time for the waiter to return with our card I received 3 text notifications from the credit card company with three different charge amounts for this restaurant. When the waiter came back I confronted him and he said the owner was having problems running the card but that the incorrect charges should disappear by Monday (this was Saturday). The followed Wednesday I checked the account and there were 2 charges that went through and another that was pending. They were all different amounts, only 1 was the amount I signed for. Called credit card company and found out the correct charge was made using the chip reader and the other 2 were processed as online transactions. Credit card company treating as fraud attempt. Be careful of the payment card you use if you eat here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Loading...