Mr. Pickles Sandwich Shop - Pleasanton, CA

Delicious! ?

But we did a pick up order and ordered through Uber eats, which had menu prices that were $3 more per sandwich. Lesson learned.

Highly recommend ordering via Mr Pickles' website instead of the third party services noted on their Google Maps listing.

(And it'd be great if whoever manages the store's profile would update the "Order Online" info to include a link to the website!)

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Reuben

Lots of different sandwiches and fixed up quickly

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

This place is awesome! Mr. Pickles sandwiches are universally good at every location I've been too and this one is no exception. The people that work here are also rock stars! I come here basically every day and they have no bad days. Any day of the week they will make you a sandwich that says "we care". And they do.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Before rating I actually tried this place three times this week.

My first sandwich this week was very good… the only issue was missing bacon and cookie. Considering bacon is not free to add on I am little upset that I paid for bacon and didnt get any.

2nd sandwich was missing garlic sauce and had onions after I said no onions. So it was unpleasant and I couldnt finish it. I also asked for extra lettice and that’s not what I got.

3rd sandwich was missing avocado and pepperchini again avocado isnt a free add on yet I paid for avocado that was suppose to be included in my sandwich.

The price of food isnt cheap and I paid for these sandwiches and expected what I paid for and did not get that.

Customer service… Was unimpressed with customer service. On their busiest time I can understand because I have worked in a sandwich shop but two of those times were empty and no one looked up to acknowledge me and no one greeted me. The only thing said was pick up?
One person had really long hair and I don’t particularly care about hair styles etc but every time he looked down his hair fell forward over his face and then he had to tilt back to get them out and I could only imagine looking up and down is common when making food .. no hair tie or hair net? No hair was in my food just a concern for future orders.
Bottom line everyone looked like they were over it, pissed off or tired and believe that the lack of quality in their service is representing in their food.

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Gluten free wraps

Restaurant looks nice. Professional staff. But seriously, a 1/2 sandwich costs $10 and is 4"?!? If it tasted remarkable, I might only reconsider based on price, but the chicken with hot sauce sandwich lacked any pop, was missing tomatoes, and had a rather sparing amount of chicken. The only positive was a free greasy cookie that was included, which I gobbled up after failing to find enough in that 4" offering. I will not repeat at a Mr. Pickle.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Always a winning choice going to Mr. Pickles! The whole was please with their food and despite having a larger party we served quickly and efficiently. Highly recommend the dutch crunch roll!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent and healthy tuna sub. Not fancy so don’t go there for high tea.

Small and quiet tucked away.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great sandwiches. Absolutely love the Italian and definitely recommend it. The pastrami is also quite good. I typically have some modifications to the sandwiches (e.g. hold the garlic sauce), and they have always gotten the order correct.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Mr Pickle, Sandwich

Best sandwiches in town. Friendly staff and always welcoming you with a smile. Ensure to include the “The Works”.

We live two blocks from the Livermore location, but choose to commute to Pleasanton every time we’re craving Mr. Pickles for the superior quality and service!

Great service, delicious sandwiches, and an upscale location for this Mr. Pickles sandwich shop. Glad we found it! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie

Delicious!!! And their pickles don't disappoint

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 5

My guilty-pleasure sandwich spot in Pleasanton! The Hot T is a little bit messy but the perfect mix of sweet, spicy, and savory. I would recommend the Dutch crunch bread for any sandwich