New York New York Giant Pizza (Best Authentic New York Style Pizza In San Diego)

12624 Poway Rd, Poway
(858) 513-0500

Recent Reviews

Jimelle B.

The service and pizza are outstanding! The cozy dining area reminds me of pizza parlors from my youth. We had an awesome family birthday party there. I love that you can customize your pie. They even offer gluten free and non-dairy options. I love this place!

Babak Hooshmand

My first time here, the pizza was so delicious, all fresh ingredients and the crust was out of this planet. Very clean and neat place. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Luisa C.

Great service. The pizza is delicious, made with fresh ingredients and the pizza crust was crispy thin perfect! We enjoyed a great dinner!

Bob H.

My first time here and the pizza was awesome, the crust was so crunchy and all the ingredients were fresh and delicious. I loved it.

Katie B.

My husband and I were impressed with how great the food and service was here. Tony was kind and attentive when serving us. I had the islands pie (pictured) about $4.50 and my husband got the combo with a soda, slice of pepperoni with a side salad for $7.99. The cannolis were about $2 a piece, an absolute great price for such quality food. It was our first time coming after living in San Diego for our whole lives, we will be coming back for sure. Thank you, Tony!!

Shanae Villarreal Barlow

We are a family of four and came in here for pizza by the slice. Service was excellent and even kind and accommodating to my 2 young ones. The pizza is really good. We are looking forward to going back again soon.Kid-friendliness: Not much to keep the kids busy with while waiting but friendly enough to accommodate to an accidental spill. Plus, the kids just eat up the pizza here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza, Cheese Pizza

Alayah H.

Came here for the first time today and Tony was so kind! This place is very welcoming and the service is great! I just got a slice and he had it out so quick too. It was perfect from the fresh basil I tasted in the sauce to the crunch of the crust, I truly enjoyed each bite. 10/10 recommend. When I am craving pizza this is exactly what comes to mind. I will be coming back!

A P

We ordered the 2nd to large pizza andbit was very very good. Very well made with good quality topings and cheese. Joe the owner was very charming and ensured we got the very best. I thoroughly enjoyed the pizza and thoroughly recommend this place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric A.

This 28" beef pepperoni pizza was crispy and delicious and a great value for the price you pay for this pizza. It can easily feed 12 people

Eric Ireri

I went in and ordered a GYRO sandwich that was advertised for $7.99. The guy at the counter charged my card $13.33. When I inquired about the discrepancy, he asked if I know the wholesale price of lamb meat? Who cares about that? The only thing that matters is price your menu says.I can't comment on whether the food was good or bad, because I cancelled the order. It's impossible to recommend this place, not if they are engaging in fraud. If your prices are variable, post a menu without prices and then say what it is, don't advertise one price and proceed to charge another.

David Strobel

As a native New Yorker and common visitor to Wooster street in New Haven. I can say Tony makes the best New York style slice I’ve had west of New Jersey.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Blaine F

New to the area it was hard finding good pizza in Poway until I found this place. The staff is super welcoming to new customers and super nice. The pizza here in my honest opinion is amazing. Crust is perfect and the pizza itself all together is amazing. Usually do all basil half pepperoni and it always tastes amazing. Highly recommend this pizza spot

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Mark M.

Of all the Giant New York Pizza joints (and there's a lot of them) this is the skimpiest and most expensive of them all.

George D.

Support local! It's a small place, a couple tables for some inside dining and a walk up order counter. (Lots of to go deliveries and pickup and take out orders). If I do my grocery shopping g a little later than usual I often pick this place for a giant slice, salad and drink for $7.99 in which it holds me over until I can make some dinner later on. The owner is always here and always has a friendly attitude. Again, support local.

joseph toscano

This is a highlight of a place. Good food and terrific person .Mungia.ciao........Been back several times still the top pizza and food around. I travel 30 miles just to dine Bravo chat and dine , perfect. Ten star rating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza, Side of Salad and Bread

Load More

New York New York Giant Pizza (Best Authentic New York Style Pizza In San Diego)

12624 Poway Rd, Poway, CA 92064
(858) 513-0500