Critic's Choice Catering & Event Production

Critic's Choice catered our baby shower for 80+ people. They were very thoughtful. The food was delicious, the service was great, and they decorations were tailored to our theme. Maura helped set up our service and Deanna and Justo helped with the service. We will definitely hire them again for future events.

Prime Rib, Salmon , Hors d’oeuvre table for a group of 30. This is the first time using a caterer for this event. This is usually done by volunteers. The food was delicious, displayed beautifully and decorated with the theme of our event. They handled everything, from the timing of food being served, setting of table, water, cake etc. Maura and her crew made the event flawless and enjoyable. Will use again, Thank You Critics Choice.

Great staff and amazing service! they showed up on time and the whole day went super smoothly. I would use them again and highly recommend their Catering Services.

Critic's Choice Catering is 5 Star Exceptional.
Number One in the South Bay!
They go the extra mile
in every way: Service, Food, Decorations, and they have that Special Touch! Detail oriented. Top drawer!

My wife and I recently got married and Kaycie was our wedding planner. Talk about attention to detail… Kaycie was extremely communicative and supportive during the entire process. If you’ve ever gotten married you know how stressful the process can be - not with Critics! It was pretty much stress free, Kaycie was able to bring our wedding from Pinterest board to real life. We couldn’t be more happy! If you’ve ever gotten are looking for an all in 1 caterer/wedding planner then I HIGHLY recommend Critics choice and Kaycie

Lorraine handled the catering for our 50th anniversary party The food was 5 star and the service was stellar We couldn’t have been happier She made our event a truly special experience Our guests still compliment the occasion even 2 years later
Thank you Lorraine

Simply an amazing catering company. They handled the catering and serving for my husband’s 60th birthday party flawlessly. I am highly visual and was most concerned that the food not only taste good, but that things be presented beautifully. They understood the task and met the challenge. The food was fabulous and the passed hors d’oeuvres and. large appetizer table was beautifully presented. My guest were highly impressed. But most importantly, they were patient with me. I’ve never hired a caterer for a home event, and this party was for over 36 people right after the reopening of the world post COVID-19. I would highly recommend them to anyone and would not hesitate to use them again.

Kaycie and Lorraine took care of us both during and after Covid. We had an intimate 15 person wedding reception at our home during covid and a full scale event 18 months later. Both were fabulous in attention to detail, food and over site. I can't emphasize the over site aspect. When the event finally comes and all the planning and worry, the one thing you want to do is celebrate. Both Kaycie and Lorraine allowed us to fully enjoy each event knowing they were taking care of everything. Thanks again:)
P. S. I forgot to mention Stuart, a most excellent Chef who made due in our small kitchen. It was very cool watching him work. Cheers Stuart!:)

Maura and her team have been an absolute pleasure to work with. Their food, service, communication, and consistently upbeat attitude were all outstanding. They provided the support I needed for a multi-day, customer-facing event and truly wowed the crowd.

Thank you again for your hard work — cheers!

This company is hands down the best catering service I’ve experienced. From a guest’s perspective, the food was incredible. Behind the food was the incredible service. And behind the service were the best personalities.

If you’re looking for a dream team of professional bartenders, make sure to request Kofi and Mike. They were such an added highlight to the evening for all. No matter who you are, you’ll end up leaving the bar with a smile or a laugh, along with a delicious drink.

We had Critic's Choice cater our backyard rehearsal dinner and it was PERFECT! All of the food was delicious, the servers & chefs were friendly and accommodating, and Maura who helped us plan the event went above and beyond. We're so happy with how everything turned out - cannot recommend enough!!

Critic’s Choice was outstanding. The food was high quality and delicious. This is a professional 5 star caterer with seasoned workers who supplied the best bartenders. We received so many compliments about the food and the service. They were so accommodating and reliable. I highly recommend them.

Critics Choice Catering provided phenomenal gourmet quality food and impeccable service for our son’s wedding. Kaycie Fellows and her staff were polite and professional throughout the entire 10 hour cycle of the wedding ceremony and reception. They performed beyond our wildest expectations and I would have no hesitation in using them in the future.

Kaycie and her team catered an event for 40 non-profit volunteers made up of teenage boys and their Moms. Our food was fresh, delicious and beautiful. Critics Choice was easy to communicate with, on time, reliable and professional. We will use them again and appreciate the high-end service we received.

Critics Choice did such a fantastic job with our wedding and we have received so many compliments about how great their food was! I cannot thank Kaycie enough for all of her hard work leading up to and during our big day. She was really committed to making our dream a reality and did such an amazing job putting everything together!