Speederia Pizzeria

The only authentic New York crunch I've ever had from the west coast. I don't even want to write a review for this place cause I want to keep it a secret all to myself. Owner's hella friendly, too. An amalgamation of East Coast taste with west coast hospitality.

This is a slice shop with counter service and a couple tables. No frills takeout, and easily the best slices on the Peninsula. I love this place and stop in multiple times per week for a few slices. I really like the Brooklyn and the pesto slice, my kids love the cheese, which holds up, but I've had them all and they are all good. Crust has a perfect crunch. They also have Kern's drinks which are delicious and hard to find.

However, the prices are high and it's virtually impossible to get a whole pie - like, you need to order a month in advance and then they will still probably call and cancel your order. It's so bad it's laughable at this point, and I kind of think they want it that way. Can't tell you how many times I've tried to call in and there's either no answer, or they answer and say they're sold out, so I just end up going in and buying 8 slices. Forget ever ordering on Doordash, they really shouldn't even be on there. Literally every time I've placed an order they've cancelled it five minutes later with no explanation.

I HAVE NEVER BEEN ABLE TO ORDER A WHOLE PIZZA! NOT ONCE! NOT EVER!

I'm not sure if they are under staffed or need a bigger oven, but you'd think that a pizza place would want to sell more pizza, and figure out how to make that happen.

Great little slice house in Emerald Hills. Their slices are perfectly crispy and heated up fresh.

This is the best pizza. If you’re lucky grab a white stone or a tomato basil or really anything. Words cannot describe the authenticity and integrity of this pizza. The owner is a pizza master and I will be extremely saddened when or if it ever closes. If you stop by here do yourself a favor… and grab a slice!

Best pizza in the San Mateo County Great service

Hidden gem. After looking for that authentic NY slice at so many places in the Bay Area, I think I have finally found it.

Best kept secret on the west coast. Call ahead for pies b/c it's a small shop. No dining room, just one table by the door. Always some tasty slices on hand!

Best NY pizza without being in NY.

This is my favorite local pizza place! And my friend from Brooklyn said it's legit so its New Yorker certified.

Vegetarian options: Cheese, tomato basil, mushroom, whitestone

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Whitestone

I just moved to California from Queens NYC, I Grabbed a slice on my way back to work and I can honestly say that this slice made me miss home. The first place that has truly earned the title of New York style pizza. Will most definitely be bringing friends and family!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oh wow! Hidden gem! Thin crust. Ingredients flavor is balanced.

Owner told me it’s a NY recipe that’s 150 years old.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Indianapolis Pizza

Great pizza! Might I say the best pizza in the bay area, heck the whole state! All aspects of the delightful pies are great, from the dough, to the sauce, and ultimately the toppings. The place is small, though...with only a table inside and a bar like table and there are a couple of benches just outside it's doors. The staff are super nice and friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great service, clean restroom, delicious no frills thin pizza. I love the 2 for $12 deal plus the included drink selection is stellar. The chicken pesto pizza is a childhood staple.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Best pizza by the slice west of the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Huge part of my childhood. I cannot recommend this place enough. We miss you on Laurel!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5