Closed ??? Just saw them on the news this morning ???
Katrina M.
We tried this place on a Thursday night around 6pm we ordered to go. There was only one party dining in. The pizza we ordered was different because it had Mike's Hot Honey on it and made it for a messy transportation situation, the passenger holding the pizza got honey all over his pants. Other than the mess the pizza was good and the crust is amazing. Ranch is .25 for a 6oz cup on the side. There are arcade games to play while waiting for the pizza to be made. I would try this place again due to the fast service.
Linda L.
I love the pizza here! I'm not much of a fan of thick crust so I've only gotten the square serving once. But the crust of the full pizza is totally what I love. The half Notorious P.I.G./Canadian bacon & pineapple is my fav. We also got the Cali Tots and the portion size was good.
Time-laps, slo mo king
The pizzas crust is hard as a rock!
David Fields
Was looking for some kind of combo pizza, but all of the choices were ... Creative. Only one size of pizza for most.
MACTackleBox
Pizza was good. Sauce was very fresh and flavorful. It just feels like they haven't hide there stride yet. The dining area is small and cramped. The seats aren't very comfy either. Maybe the answer is to get it to go? Eating in or out, I think you'll enjoy their pizza.
Ali Waziri
Fantastic pizza, beer and vibe! What a gem in this neighborhood! Very cool spot to hang out or bring families.
Sharon Kropf
Enjoyed the pizza and especially loved the crust!
Blake F.
Really nice place that makes a great pie. More modern and generous amounts of toppings but a classic crust - chewy and airy without any heaviness. I think the dough is starter made - big thumbs up. Vegan friendly - you can order Miyoko's cheese on any pizza. Fair prices. Will be back!
Scott Stiewig
Toppings are different, interesting, and tasty. Usually crust is a forgetful necessity, but this crusty is flavorful, crisp and perfectly cooked. Definitely coming back soon!
First off, I'm going to start with the pizza is much improved from my first visit. Now they serve real pies. When they first opened, it was only focaccia style pizzas. Not bad, just not my favorite style of pizza. I've had the pepperoni and the cheese (circle pizza). The pizza is amazing. No fluff, no heavy oil, perfect crisp crust, just the perfect pizza. If you are a pizza geek like me, try this place! You won't be disappointed. 9.2/10.
Richard C.
Love the new round pizza. I order Avenue J with no basil or Parmesan so basically a plain cheese pizza. Great family atmosphere and free classic video games. As a native New Yorker take my word for it. It's delicious.
Alicia C.
We waited over an hour for our pizza. There just isn't any reason for it to take that long. Everyone around us was complaining about the wait, and one family asked for a refund after waiting for 30 minutes. All of the pizzas are the same size so the wait time just doesn't make sense. The pizza tastes great, but I'm just not willing to wait that long for it.
Jack P.
Totally changed. They are now serving overpriced, tiny round pizzas and only a couple of the focaccia slices, no whole trays. The owners also run The Federalist in Midtown which is GREAT!!! Why are they failing so miserably at this place making the same product? Also, please learn how to cook tots. Are they microwaved?
Stephanie B.
We went the first night they were open. Very relaxed, local atmosphere with fun 80s music. The pizza had great flavor and was filling. The style reminds us of the grandma slices when we lived in NYC: fluffy but crunchy crust. The wait was a little long but we will totally cut them slack for their grand opening. We are so glad to have a yummy pizza spot in the neighborhood - especially one that serves by the slice! Update: I took off a star because I've returned several times since our first visit and twice the dough on my pizza has been raw. Yikes.
Closed ??? Just saw them on the news this morning ???
We tried this place on a Thursday night around 6pm we ordered to go. There was only one party dining in. The pizza we ordered was different because it had Mike's Hot Honey on it and made it for a messy transportation situation, the passenger holding the pizza got honey all over his pants. Other than the mess the pizza was good and the crust is amazing. Ranch is .25 for a 6oz cup on the side. There are arcade games to play while waiting for the pizza to be made. I would try this place again due to the fast service.
I love the pizza here! I'm not much of a fan of thick crust so I've only gotten the square serving once. But the crust of the full pizza is totally what I love. The half Notorious P.I.G./Canadian bacon & pineapple is my fav. We also got the Cali Tots and the portion size was good.
The pizzas crust is hard as a rock!
Was looking for some kind of combo pizza, but all of the choices were ... Creative. Only one size of pizza for most.
Pizza was good. Sauce was very fresh and flavorful. It just feels like they haven't hide there stride yet. The dining area is small and cramped. The seats aren't very comfy either. Maybe the answer is to get it to go? Eating in or out, I think you'll enjoy their pizza.
Fantastic pizza, beer and vibe! What a gem in this neighborhood! Very cool spot to hang out or bring families.
Enjoyed the pizza and especially loved the crust!
Really nice place that makes a great pie. More modern and generous amounts of toppings but a classic crust - chewy and airy without any heaviness. I think the dough is starter made - big thumbs up. Vegan friendly - you can order Miyoko's cheese on any pizza. Fair prices. Will be back!
Toppings are different, interesting, and tasty. Usually crust is a forgetful necessity, but this crusty is flavorful, crisp and perfectly cooked. Definitely coming back soon!
Restaurantji Recommends
First off, I'm going to start with the pizza is much improved from my first visit. Now they serve real pies. When they first opened, it was only focaccia style pizzas. Not bad, just not my favorite style of pizza. I've had the pepperoni and the cheese (circle pizza). The pizza is amazing. No fluff, no heavy oil, perfect crisp crust, just the perfect pizza. If you are a pizza geek like me, try this place! You won't be disappointed. 9.2/10.
Love the new round pizza. I order Avenue J with no basil or Parmesan so basically a plain cheese pizza. Great family atmosphere and free classic video games. As a native New Yorker take my word for it. It's delicious.
We waited over an hour for our pizza. There just isn't any reason for it to take that long. Everyone around us was complaining about the wait, and one family asked for a refund after waiting for 30 minutes. All of the pizzas are the same size so the wait time just doesn't make sense. The pizza tastes great, but I'm just not willing to wait that long for it.
Totally changed. They are now serving overpriced, tiny round pizzas and only a couple of the focaccia slices, no whole trays. The owners also run The Federalist in Midtown which is GREAT!!! Why are they failing so miserably at this place making the same product? Also, please learn how to cook tots. Are they microwaved?
We went the first night they were open. Very relaxed, local atmosphere with fun 80s music. The pizza had great flavor and was filling. The style reminds us of the grandma slices when we lived in NYC: fluffy but crunchy crust. The wait was a little long but we will totally cut them slack for their grand opening. We are so glad to have a yummy pizza spot in the neighborhood - especially one that serves by the slice! Update: I took off a star because I've returned several times since our first visit and twice the dough on my pizza has been raw. Yikes.