As others have said this is not New York style pizza. It's not Little Caesars bad but maybe CiCi's Pizza or hometown buffet pizza or similar quality pizza you would find at a buffet. For me roundtable / mountain mikes is a higher quality pizza where to me this sits on the same level as dominos unfortunately. Didn't want to not like it, but it was not very good. Luckily the price seemed like a good deal but sadly the dough and overall experience left me feeling unsatisfied. Sadly I will not be coming back. The strip mall it's located in while not unsafe does feel unpleasant. Let's not even get into the long wait time although the worker seemed fine in terms of customer service. The xl with 3 toppings is enough for 2 meals for 19.99 They do have a 1 topping large for 9.99 from 12pm- 4pm which is a good alternative to take home bake pizza / frozen
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Sam
Lackluster generic pizza with the cheapest ingredients. New owner. The new owner is very cheap and argumentative. If you use a coupon he takes it personally and begrudgingly.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Isabel Barraza
Literally BEST pizza in Rancho Cordova! The chicken wings and garlic cheesy bread was just as AMAZING! Worth every penny and i definitely recommend coming here!
Also - the owners are the sweetest!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Molly Wanless-Smith
Called in an office lunch order as a surprise for the staff and New York Pizza checked all the boxes! Owner confirmed the order before hanging up, had it ready on time, and it was piping hot. Generous and well-spread toppings.
The team was very happy! We’ll definitely order from New York Pizza again.
Pictured are the garlic cheese sticks, the New York veggie and the New York pepperoni.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
E Romero
Great pizza, terrible customer service . Rude employees.
Carlos Donis-Gonzalez
10$ large pizza 12 to 4pm
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maria Perez
I was genuinely impressed and super happy to have finally found a really, really good pizza place in Sacramento.
I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza and a large Hawaiian pizza for my mom and my brother. Both had generous amounts of toppings, and the sauce was not overly sweet like some pizza places. The pepperoni wasn't very peppery either. Both were really good tasting pizzas.
I ordered my food online, and the order was ready within 20 minutes.
I'm definitely going back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scot Ray
Worst customer service.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Rochelle Gauthier
I just heard about New York Pizza in my location and I decided to try it. I am so glad that I did! Their pizza was off the hook. I love their crust and their sauce wasn’t sweet like so many others, and they were generous with their toppings. I used to order my pizza for Mountain Mike’s but now it is definitely New York Pizza all the way!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joshua Schwarzenbach
I was shocked how good this pizza was! The inside is nothing to write home about, and honestly it looked like it was under remodel or closing, but the pizza was absolutely awesome.
Great pizza excellent pizza would highly recommend 😁
Woody S
Combination pizza with extra cheese. The best of the best in the Sacramento area. It was so cheesy, I honestly thought the owner tripped and spilled an entire bucket of cheese on it. Thanks bro. (From the couple who visited 20 minutes ago)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ThanhTN Nguyen
i love how my pizza came out. crunchy and alot topping
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sashim Gardner
Almost all reviews on this page are for the previous restaurant at this location, Pizza Millenari. Pizza Millenari had amazing pizza. “New York Pizza” is a different restaurant that opened at this location a few months ago. Different owner and different recipes. I was already at the restaurant when I found out it had changed, so I decided to try their pizza but it was very mediocre, I won’t be back. They should’ve bought the recipes from the last restaurant. Somehow this new business was able to take ownership of this page and claim the reviews as their own. The ethical thing to do is create their own page, but I’ll bet they won’t.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Wallace Smith
Pizzas were delivered burnt. Manager called the owner and they both said this is normal. I told them that it tastes like char and won't ever go back there again.
As others have said this is not New York style pizza. It's not Little Caesars bad but maybe CiCi's Pizza or hometown buffet pizza or similar quality pizza you would find at a buffet. For me roundtable / mountain mikes is a higher quality pizza where to me this sits on the same level as dominos unfortunately. Didn't want to not like it, but it was not very good. Luckily the price seemed like a good deal but sadly the dough and overall experience left me feeling unsatisfied. Sadly I will not be coming back. The strip mall it's located in while not unsafe does feel unpleasant. Let's not even get into the long wait time although the worker seemed fine in terms of customer service.
The xl with 3 toppings is enough for 2 meals for 19.99
They do have a 1 topping large for 9.99 from 12pm- 4pm which is a good alternative to take home bake pizza / frozen
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Lackluster generic pizza with the cheapest ingredients. New owner. The new owner is very cheap and argumentative. If you use a coupon he takes it personally and begrudgingly.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Literally BEST pizza in Rancho Cordova! The chicken wings and garlic cheesy bread was just as AMAZING! Worth every penny and i definitely recommend coming here!
Also - the owners are the sweetest!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Called in an office lunch order as a surprise for the staff and New York Pizza checked all the boxes! Owner confirmed the order before hanging up, had it ready on time, and it was piping hot. Generous and well-spread toppings.
The team was very happy! We’ll definitely order from New York Pizza again.
Pictured are the garlic cheese sticks, the New York veggie and the New York pepperoni.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, terrible customer service . Rude employees.
10$ large pizza 12 to 4pm
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was genuinely impressed and super happy to have finally found a really, really good pizza place in Sacramento.
I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza and a large Hawaiian pizza for my mom and my brother. Both had generous amounts of toppings, and the sauce was not overly sweet like some pizza places. The pepperoni wasn't very peppery either. Both were really good tasting pizzas.
I ordered my food online, and the order was ready within 20 minutes.
I'm definitely going back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Worst customer service.
Food: 3
Service: 1
I just heard about New York Pizza in my location and I decided to try it. I am so glad that I did! Their pizza was off the hook. I love their crust and their sauce wasn’t sweet like so many others, and they were generous with their toppings. I used to order my pizza for Mountain Mike’s but now it is definitely New York Pizza all the way!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was shocked how good this pizza was! The inside is nothing to write home about, and honestly it looked like it was under remodel or closing, but the pizza was absolutely awesome.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza excellent pizza would highly recommend 😁
Combination pizza with extra cheese. The best of the best in the Sacramento area. It was so cheesy, I honestly thought the owner tripped and spilled an entire bucket of cheese on it. Thanks bro. (From the couple who visited 20 minutes ago)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
i love how my pizza came out. crunchy and alot topping
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Almost all reviews on this page are for the previous restaurant at this location, Pizza Millenari. Pizza Millenari had amazing pizza. “New York Pizza” is a different restaurant that opened at this location a few months ago. Different owner and different recipes. I was already at the restaurant when I found out it had changed, so I decided to try their pizza but it was very mediocre, I won’t be back. They should’ve bought the recipes from the last restaurant. Somehow this new business was able to take ownership of this page and claim the reviews as their own. The ethical thing to do is create their own page, but I’ll bet they won’t.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Pizzas were delivered burnt. Manager called the owner and they both said this is normal. I told them that it tastes like char and won't ever go back there again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...