Fresh Brothers Pizza Carmel Valley

5950 Village Way, San Diego
(858) 252-7000

Recent Reviews

Toby Mayfield

Amazing pizza and amazing customer service! Can't go wrong at all!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heming Diep

Good pizza and wings. Knotts needs a bit more flavor. The meatball sliders were decent.Parking: Big parking lot

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Wings, Meatball Sliders

S B Gi

The pizzas took a long time but overall it was very good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Bulbul Das

We ordered cheese pizza with olives and jalapenos and pineapple topping, kids loved the hot and fresh pizza right from the oven , the chicken bites and wings were good as well .

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Thin Crust Cheese Pizza, Wings and Chicken, Wings

Kal Masri

Excellent tasting Pizza, and that's what really matters. Ordered a vegetarian option and was surprised by the fresh taste of ingredients, subtly seasoned to achieve a natural taste that I found delicious. The crust was paper thin, which is to my liking as well, but it was soggy and wished it would have been a more on the crispy side (if at all technically possible). Overall, great pizza and highly recommended. By a 61 year old foodie.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marc Leibowitz

Got an email to pre-order food for Halloween. Ordered the day before and set time for delivery. No food at expected delivery time. Called 3 times over a 3 hour period and was told the food was delayed, then it was being cooked then it was out for delivery. Food never got here and finally called again to cancel - no apologies from the restaurant whatsoever. Ruined the halloween gathering that we were to provide food for. This is not a way to run a restaurant. Don't order from this place - horrible business practices.

Service: 1

Samuel dlC

First time trying out fresh brothers. You place your order first and then you find your seat if you're dining in (outdoor patio available with umbrellas). We ordered Caesar salad, baked wings, and a medium pizza. The Caesar salad was nice and fresh; a good start. The wings came out and man the size of these were not worth the purchase (see pictures). The highlight was the pizza that was very delicious; as mentioned that they use fresh high quality ingredients. They had 1 freestyle soda machine but it was very disappointing that "regular coca cola" was not available. On top of that a long line with kids trying to mix and match flavors. An okay first impression here. I'd come back for the pizza and pass on the wings.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Thin Crust Cheese Pizza

Praktical Adventures

High school lunch hangout around 12. Barely any walking room. Slow service. Pizza slice definitely not worth $5! Lesson learned...

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Kelly O.

Our pizza and sweet knots were made so well tonight! The sweet knots were big and and the pizza had so many toppings. The last few times we've been to this location have been top notch.

Food: 5

Service: 5

San D.

I do not like giving out bad reviews, but seeing some of the other such reviews for this particular branch of Fresh Bros., I can see that there is a trend. On a recent lunch time visit noticed that the two individuals at the counter were different from the last time I visited this place. Upon entering was not greeted by either of the two. One (the one making hte pizza) was busy speaking on the phone to a customer and did not even acknowledge me after finishing the call. The other deliberately ignored me being the next in line for service and instead serves a bunch of young teenagers. The pizza was okay, but the chicken tenders were atrocious. They were not even warm and had an off taste almost as if it was quickly microwaved. I never had any issues with this branch before but next time I would rather drive further out to the Fresh Bros. in Laguna Niguel.

Rose

my friend and i ordered a 6 piece fresh knots. it took about 40 minutes before i received my knots. once i opened the box i realized these knots were severely small and burnt. i know what these knots should look like, and was taken aback once i opened the box. the staff acted as if they didn’t know what i was talking about. once i got a new box of proper knots, they were still slightly burnt. below is a photo of the burnt and small knots compared to the regular knot. i was shocked how i was horribly scammed and manipulated.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Christopher Mouton

The food at Fresh Brothers is undoubtedly delicious, and the staff always greets you with a warm and friendly smile. However, there seems to be a significant issue when it comes to the management side of things. During my recent visit at lunchtime, the place was overwhelmed, clearly understaffed, and the owner was conspicuously absent. It's essential for the person at the helm to be present, especially during peak hours. Hoping for better management in future visits.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

shawn moore

Pizza was ok, the boneless chicken was nothing to write home about. Was ok but for me I will not search it out.

Jessica Leibowitz

terrible service he switched up our pizzas and took FOREVER to get them in a cooked. On the phone for 10 minutes. We spent a total of 45 minutes in there waiting for our food. Pizza was not correct only 4 pepperonis on it!! food was also super dry. The ground was disgusting.WAY OVER PRICED FOR WHAT WE GOT. unbelievable. Don’t go to this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Kid

Mikayla Rowland

Have had this pizza twice now and have found long hair pieces in my pizza… not sure why they aren’t using correct food safety precautions but they should be. I like the thing crust pizza a lot but not it only happening once but twice now is a little upsetting. Please use correct food safety measures so that people don’t waste money and lose their appetite.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Thin Crust Cheese Pizza

Load More

Fresh Brothers Pizza Carmel Valley

5950 Village Way, San Diego, CA 92130
(858) 252-7000