Delicious gelato, right in the water. I got an affogato with vanilla and we sat in the dome next door, a beautiful view at sunset to enjoy a gelato and watch the boats go by. Service was quick and their portions are giant! My affogato was the size of a medium soft drink - and it was the kids size!
Jeff H.
Portside Coffee & Gelato is more than just a café; it's a haven for coffee aficionados and gelato enthusiasts alike. Located at 2614 Shelter Island Drive, this cozy establishment offers a delightful blend of freshly brewed coffee and delectable gelato. Let's dive into the details: The Setting and Location: Shelter Island provides the perfect backdrop for this hidden gem. Imagine strolling along the marina, with the salty breeze in your hair, as you make your way to Portside. If you were staying at Humphreys, it was a mere 10-minute walk down to this delightful spot. The convenience alone makes it a must-visit. The Gelato Experience: You opted for the Salted Caramel flavor, and while it was undeniably good, there was a twist. It seems they might have mislabeled it because it packed a strong coffee taste. A delightful surprise, wouldn't you say? Gelato lovers will appreciate the variety of flavors available here. From classic favorites to inventive combinations, Portside caters to all taste buds. The Coffee Corner: Portside takes its coffee seriously. Locally roasted beans from Café Moto form the foundation of their exceptional brews. Whether you're sipping on an iced vanilla cold brew or enjoying a cappuccino, the quality shines through. And yes, even the drip coffee here is a winner! Atmosphere and Vibe: The café exudes a cozy, inviting ambiance. Picture yourself sitting by the window, gazing out at the harbor, or perhaps catching up with friends at one of the tables. It's a place where time slows down, and conversations flow freely. Why Portside Stands Out: Amidst the island's limited options, Portside Coffee & Gelato shines as one of the very few places to grab a treat. Whether you're a local or a visitor, this spot offers a delightful respite from the hustle and bustle.
Trinity C.
Update: Decided to come back and order from their breakfast menu! I got a sausage roll and an almond croissant. Both were very decently priced and delicious! The service was excellent and the food came out quick. Once again, love the views and location as well! Just wish they had a bit more seating outdoors to enjoy the view!
Dionna R.
Everyone here is so sweet and their gelato was so good! I had their latte the next day and it was smooth and delicious. Great little spot :)
Tinamarie Giovanni
Great cold brew coffee, walking distance from the docks.Service a bit faster than the California standard of dither dathering.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Misha M.
Absolutely outstanding and delicious. The girls at the counter made this the best experience ever! Gisele (like Tom Brady's wife) was so funny and helpful. She wanted us to try as many samples as we wanted and couldn't have been more kind to people from out of town. She should know she can do anything in life because with such a great attitude I think she will go far! Every gelato we had was super tasty and I honestly felt like we were getting our money's worth. We were not disappointed. This is the perfect place to end up on a hot day. We literally came back the next day to see her again. We would come here again and again if we didn't have to leave town. This is the kind of place we would go out of our way to stop by on our way back to San Diego.
Jess Coulson-Colbert Colbert
Fabulous low key but bougie gellato joint. Upper crust marina types mingle with funky vacay San Diego beach vibes. The coconut milk cold brew coffee was to die for and the pistachio affangado too. With real pistachios. Go ! And then chill at the nearby shelter island beach
Really good gelato and coffee! Staff is very kind also. Right off the water. Awesome spot to go for date or hang out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adeline Hoffer
Brown curly haired girl rudely asked us to leave because it was “after hours” there was no signage and doors were wide open giving off the impression open and welcoming. There was a lively line and people being happy with gelato, which we will not get. This unfortunately was the last opportunity to get to enjoy this delicious gelato since we are moving tomorrow. Did not kindly ask us to leave they just said they were not going to take us after the girls infront of us, did not give an explanation as to why. Very disappointed.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Elizabeth O.
I love this coffee spot. Not only do they have the best customer service but their coffee and pastries are delicious. I like that I can order decaf lattes! The iced mocha is my favorite I get it every time. The salted caramel chocolate chip cookie was so good too. Really good breakfast sandwiches also. Outdoor seating and good hours. In a great area. Come here and take a walk on the island, you won't regret it!
The coffee is ok, but the gelato, now that is some good stuff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Welsh Ab (M)
This sandwich was the best thing I ate the whole trip omg ? the best ever breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had ??? my new favorite ? breakfast spot I am in love great coffee ☕️ and frozen
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Bailey B.
Coffee is good enough, by the breakfast items are very underwhelming and over priced. My lox "bagel " was probably the worst Iv ever had unfortunately. The bagel itself was just a hard slice of bread, the lox tasted off and there wasn't enough cream cheese for everything. It was also missing capers and onions which it's supposed to come with. Iv paid less for more so this was disappointing to say the least
Adam D.
This little coffee shop is in the perfect location after you finish your walk or run around Shelter Island. They set it up in a repurposed metal storage container. Fun little atmosphere, fast and friendly customer service, and top notch lattes and fresh gelato.
Ritchie Taylor
Quick service, good cinnamon roll, and really good coffee!~ ??
Delicious gelato, right in the water. I got an affogato with vanilla and we sat in the dome next door, a beautiful view at sunset to enjoy a gelato and watch the boats go by. Service was quick and their portions are giant! My affogato was the size of a medium soft drink - and it was the kids size!
Portside Coffee & Gelato is more than just a café; it's a haven for coffee aficionados and gelato enthusiasts alike. Located at 2614 Shelter Island Drive, this cozy establishment offers a delightful blend of freshly brewed coffee and delectable gelato. Let's dive into the details: The Setting and Location: Shelter Island provides the perfect backdrop for this hidden gem. Imagine strolling along the marina, with the salty breeze in your hair, as you make your way to Portside. If you were staying at Humphreys, it was a mere 10-minute walk down to this delightful spot. The convenience alone makes it a must-visit. The Gelato Experience: You opted for the Salted Caramel flavor, and while it was undeniably good, there was a twist. It seems they might have mislabeled it because it packed a strong coffee taste. A delightful surprise, wouldn't you say? Gelato lovers will appreciate the variety of flavors available here. From classic favorites to inventive combinations, Portside caters to all taste buds. The Coffee Corner: Portside takes its coffee seriously. Locally roasted beans from Café Moto form the foundation of their exceptional brews. Whether you're sipping on an iced vanilla cold brew or enjoying a cappuccino, the quality shines through. And yes, even the drip coffee here is a winner! Atmosphere and Vibe: The café exudes a cozy, inviting ambiance. Picture yourself sitting by the window, gazing out at the harbor, or perhaps catching up with friends at one of the tables. It's a place where time slows down, and conversations flow freely. Why Portside Stands Out: Amidst the island's limited options, Portside Coffee & Gelato shines as one of the very few places to grab a treat. Whether you're a local or a visitor, this spot offers a delightful respite from the hustle and bustle.
Update: Decided to come back and order from their breakfast menu! I got a sausage roll and an almond croissant. Both were very decently priced and delicious! The service was excellent and the food came out quick. Once again, love the views and location as well! Just wish they had a bit more seating outdoors to enjoy the view!
Everyone here is so sweet and their gelato was so good! I had their latte the next day and it was smooth and delicious. Great little spot :)
Great cold brew coffee, walking distance from the docks.Service a bit faster than the California standard of dither dathering.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Absolutely outstanding and delicious. The girls at the counter made this the best experience ever! Gisele (like Tom Brady's wife) was so funny and helpful. She wanted us to try as many samples as we wanted and couldn't have been more kind to people from out of town. She should know she can do anything in life because with such a great attitude I think she will go far! Every gelato we had was super tasty and I honestly felt like we were getting our money's worth. We were not disappointed. This is the perfect place to end up on a hot day. We literally came back the next day to see her again. We would come here again and again if we didn't have to leave town. This is the kind of place we would go out of our way to stop by on our way back to San Diego.
Fabulous low key but bougie gellato joint. Upper crust marina types mingle with funky vacay San Diego beach vibes. The coconut milk cold brew coffee was to die for and the pistachio affangado too. With real pistachios. Go ! And then chill at the nearby shelter island beach
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Milk Substitutions, Nitro, Coconut
Really good gelato and coffee! Staff is very kind also. Right off the water. Awesome spot to go for date or hang out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brown curly haired girl rudely asked us to leave because it was “after hours” there was no signage and doors were wide open giving off the impression open and welcoming. There was a lively line and people being happy with gelato, which we will not get. This unfortunately was the last opportunity to get to enjoy this delicious gelato since we are moving tomorrow. Did not kindly ask us to leave they just said they were not going to take us after the girls infront of us, did not give an explanation as to why. Very disappointed.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
I love this coffee spot. Not only do they have the best customer service but their coffee and pastries are delicious. I like that I can order decaf lattes! The iced mocha is my favorite I get it every time. The salted caramel chocolate chip cookie was so good too. Really good breakfast sandwiches also. Outdoor seating and good hours. In a great area. Come here and take a walk on the island, you won't regret it!
Restaurantji Recommends
The coffee is ok, but the gelato, now that is some good stuff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
This sandwich was the best thing I ate the whole trip omg ? the best ever breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had ??? my new favorite ? breakfast spot I am in love great coffee ☕️ and frozen
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Coffee is good enough, by the breakfast items are very underwhelming and over priced. My lox "bagel " was probably the worst Iv ever had unfortunately. The bagel itself was just a hard slice of bread, the lox tasted off and there wasn't enough cream cheese for everything. It was also missing capers and onions which it's supposed to come with. Iv paid less for more so this was disappointing to say the least
This little coffee shop is in the perfect location after you finish your walk or run around Shelter Island. They set it up in a repurposed metal storage container. Fun little atmosphere, fast and friendly customer service, and top notch lattes and fresh gelato.
Quick service, good cinnamon roll, and really good coffee!~ ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5