Frequently excludes items paid for in UberEats delivery orders. I ordered cookies for my parents for their annual vacation in SF. My Dad loves the S'mores cookies and my Mom loves the lemon cookies. This is the 2nd or 3rd order where I've paid for multiple items and the bakery doesn't include them. Oh, but they took my money with no issue. Between Stirred and UberEats, there is no accountability for checking to ensure orders are packed correctly.
Sven Edward Olbash
Ordered through Uber Eats. Half the cookies had the name of a different shop on them, looked different from the other cookies, and didn’t taste like the last two times I ordered—and not in a good way.I don’t know if this was a fluke or what. If it’s just the new normal I wouldn’t order again.
Kristyn L.
ordered 4 cookies for dessert! I feel like they were delicious cookies at some point when they were fresh but the cookies we got were extremely stale. not over cooked or well done.. just stale old old cookies.. bummer :(
Bubbley Singh
We ordered through Doordash. This place is not good at all. Their cookies taste dry and have no taste.
Leah B.
Delicious!! We ordered 6 different flavors and each were scrumptious. Will absolutely order from here again. Tastes like Mom's kitchen.
Meghan S.
Ordered Doordash at 9pm on a Saturday because I got a major craving for cookies. Delivery was super quick! I ordered the walnut chocolate chip, salt chocolate chip, and peanut butter chocolate chip. These cookies were good but not as good as I was expecting after reading the great reviews. Definitely not better than Levain like someone mentioned below. I think the batter has too much sugar in it. These were super sweet (almost too sweet). They are a nice moist texture, but kinda fell apart while eating. I appreciate that they are decently sized.
Namrata Sahota
One of my favourite discoveries in San Francisco. Quality has surely dropped over two years, but they're still really good.They don't deliver all days - gotta keep a look out.Praying for a comeback!
Lauren G.
I am sorry to say that the $4 delivery-only cookie place that's open like six hours a week is EXTREMELY good.
Nora F.
Delicious. I ordered three cookies through DoorDash because why not - Oatmeal Walnut, Sea Salt Dark Chocolate, and Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip. I knew I'd love the chocolate ones because I'm a chocoholic. But Oatmeal Walnut was surprisingly my fave! Something about that warm, buttery, crunchy yet chewy comfort.
Amy N.
I've had a lot of cookies in my time and these are definitely in my top 5. My bf and I ordered: chocolate chip, double chocolate crackle, snickerdoodle, white chocolate chip, dark chocolate chip with sea salt, and M&M. We loved all of them. I discovered Stirred, Not Shaken on UberEats. I will definitely be back. And I can't wait.
We came upon this booth at TreasureFest. This was a delicious chocolate walnut cookie! Buttery soft, not too sweet, dash of salt.
Zoe J.
These are the cookies you've been looking for. Super soft and chewy on the inside. Sugary and crisp on the outside. The mixins are all well distributed throughout the cookies. The toppings are well covered. The cookies are big. They were made for milk dunks if you're into that type of thing, which I am. Really all the things I'm looking for from a cookie. Only downside is they're not open 24/7 so I have to wait for cookie greatness.
Taylor R.
These are the BEST COOKIES I've EVER had. They have such great fond memories associated with them and my friends and I talk about them fondly. We would always get the S'mores cookies and they rocked our world !!!!
Kara Green
Seriously delicious cookies! Loved the bacon cookies as well as the molasses.
Bk H.
Best cookies ever! Honestly. The cookies are heavenly and well balanced flavor. The cookies are generous size. They don't make you feel heavy and lethargic after eating. Not too sweet, great texture, no over-powering ingredients or funny after tastes like many others I've tried. My favorite is chocolate chip gluten-free. So soft and many chocolate chip chunks throughout cookie. Thanks
Frequently excludes items paid for in UberEats delivery orders. I ordered cookies for my parents for their annual vacation in SF. My Dad loves the S'mores cookies and my Mom loves the lemon cookies. This is the 2nd or 3rd order where I've paid for multiple items and the bakery doesn't include them. Oh, but they took my money with no issue. Between Stirred and UberEats, there is no accountability for checking to ensure orders are packed correctly.
Ordered through Uber Eats. Half the cookies had the name of a different shop on them, looked different from the other cookies, and didn’t taste like the last two times I ordered—and not in a good way.I don’t know if this was a fluke or what. If it’s just the new normal I wouldn’t order again.
ordered 4 cookies for dessert! I feel like they were delicious cookies at some point when they were fresh but the cookies we got were extremely stale. not over cooked or well done.. just stale old old cookies.. bummer :(
We ordered through Doordash. This place is not good at all. Their cookies taste dry and have no taste.
Delicious!! We ordered 6 different flavors and each were scrumptious. Will absolutely order from here again. Tastes like Mom's kitchen.
Ordered Doordash at 9pm on a Saturday because I got a major craving for cookies. Delivery was super quick! I ordered the walnut chocolate chip, salt chocolate chip, and peanut butter chocolate chip. These cookies were good but not as good as I was expecting after reading the great reviews. Definitely not better than Levain like someone mentioned below. I think the batter has too much sugar in it. These were super sweet (almost too sweet). They are a nice moist texture, but kinda fell apart while eating. I appreciate that they are decently sized.
One of my favourite discoveries in San Francisco. Quality has surely dropped over two years, but they're still really good.They don't deliver all days - gotta keep a look out.Praying for a comeback!
I am sorry to say that the $4 delivery-only cookie place that's open like six hours a week is EXTREMELY good.
Delicious. I ordered three cookies through DoorDash because why not - Oatmeal Walnut, Sea Salt Dark Chocolate, and Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip. I knew I'd love the chocolate ones because I'm a chocoholic. But Oatmeal Walnut was surprisingly my fave! Something about that warm, buttery, crunchy yet chewy comfort.
I've had a lot of cookies in my time and these are definitely in my top 5. My bf and I ordered: chocolate chip, double chocolate crackle, snickerdoodle, white chocolate chip, dark chocolate chip with sea salt, and M&M. We loved all of them. I discovered Stirred, Not Shaken on UberEats. I will definitely be back. And I can't wait.
Restaurantji Recommends
We came upon this booth at TreasureFest. This was a delicious chocolate walnut cookie! Buttery soft, not too sweet, dash of salt.
These are the cookies you've been looking for. Super soft and chewy on the inside. Sugary and crisp on the outside. The mixins are all well distributed throughout the cookies. The toppings are well covered. The cookies are big. They were made for milk dunks if you're into that type of thing, which I am. Really all the things I'm looking for from a cookie. Only downside is they're not open 24/7 so I have to wait for cookie greatness.
These are the BEST COOKIES I've EVER had. They have such great fond memories associated with them and my friends and I talk about them fondly. We would always get the S'mores cookies and they rocked our world !!!!
Seriously delicious cookies! Loved the bacon cookies as well as the molasses.
Best cookies ever! Honestly. The cookies are heavenly and well balanced flavor. The cookies are generous size. They don't make you feel heavy and lethargic after eating. Not too sweet, great texture, no over-powering ingredients or funny after tastes like many others I've tried. My favorite is chocolate chip gluten-free. So soft and many chocolate chip chunks throughout cookie. Thanks