Wynston's Ice Cream Co.

250 N City Dr Suite 7, San Marcos
(858) 923-1411

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cookie N Cream and Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Mint Chocolate Chunk
On Blueberry Hills
Cookies in Cream

Menu

Most Popular
Cookies in Cream
Just like sitting down to eat a sleeve of these with a glass of milk, but beeeettttter! Some say this is the best cookies in cream in the world, we would never make such a claim, but some do. Contains: Milk, wheat, soybeans
THAT Cookie Dough
Everyone loves cookie dough, but it's what is hugging the cookie dough that makes it stand out. Hints of caramel and salt compliment the chunks of gooey chocolate chip cookie dough. This one is a literal hug. Contains: Milk, egg, wheat
There's a Turtle in My Brownie
All the decadence goes into this ice cream. Brownie batter ice cream, chunks of brownies, roasted and salted walnuts. Oh, and a caramel swirl of course. Contains: Milk, wheat, nuts
Perfect PBC
Is there a better combo than chocolate and peanut butter? A chocolate and peanut-butter base with chopped-up peanut butter cups. As a creator, you are not supposed to have favorites, but this one is our favorite. Contains: Milk, soy
Mint Chocolate Chunk
Chunka Chunka burning love!!! With natural mint, chunky rich chocolate chunks, and zero artificial coloring. You may even feel like you're standing on a mountain top with a crisp breeze hitting you in the face. Contains: Milk
FTW Chocolate (Award Winning)
Having lived in 4 countries and traveling often, chocolate is important to us. Like, REALLY important. This blue ribbon award winning flavor hits nostalgic with a depth of beautiful rich chocolate. Contains: Milk
Blue Moon
Our founder, Chris, grew up in Michigan, where Blue Moon can be found in every creamery in the state. Hints of vanilla and citrus bring an almost sherbert flavor into the rich, creaminess of the ice cream. Contains: Milk
Old Reliable (Award Winning)
Reliably the safest choice, but not easy to get right. We use pure Madagascar vanilla for the best flavor. We don't skimp on good ingredients because it's like love. You give the best and you will yield love in return. Contains: Milk, egg

Picked for you
THAT Cookie Dough
Everyone loves cookie dough, but it's what is hugging the cookie dough that makes it stand out. Hints of caramel and salt compliment the chunks of gooey chocolate chip cookie dough. This one is a literal hug. Contains: Milk, egg, wheat
Cookies in Cream
Just like sitting down to eat a sleeve of these with a glass of milk, but beeeettttter! Some say this is the best cookies in cream in the world, we would never make such a claim, but some do. Contains: Milk, wheat, soybeans
Perfect PBC
Is there a better combo than chocolate and peanut butter? A chocolate and peanut-butter base with chopped-up peanut butter cups. As a creator, you are not supposed to have favorites, but this one is our favorite. Contains: Milk, soy
Mint Chocolate Chunk
Chunka Chunka burning love!!! With natural mint, chunky rich chocolate chunks, and zero artificial coloring. You may even feel like you're standing on a mountain top with a crisp breeze hitting you in the face. Contains: Milk
There's a Turtle in My Brownie
All the decadence goes into this ice cream. Brownie batter ice cream, chunks of brownies, roasted and salted walnuts. Oh, and a caramel swirl of course. Contains: Milk, wheat, nuts

Always
Cookies in Cream
Just like sitting down to eat a sleeve of these with a glass of milk, but beeeettttter! Some say this is the best cookies in cream in the world, we would never make such a claim, but some do. Contains: Milk, wheat, soybeans
THAT Cookie Dough
Everyone loves cookie dough, but it's what is hugging the cookie dough that makes it stand out. Hints of caramel and salt compliment the chunks of gooey chocolate chip cookie dough. This one is a literal hug. Contains: Milk, egg, wheat
Perfect PBC
Is there a better combo than chocolate and peanut butter? A chocolate and peanut-butter base with chopped-up peanut butter cups. As a creator, you are not supposed to have favorites, but this one is our favorite. Contains: Milk, soy
Blue Moon
Our founder, Chris, grew up in Michigan, where Blue Moon can be found in every creamery in the state. Hints of vanilla and citrus bring an almost sherbert flavor into the rich, creaminess of the ice cream. Contains: Milk
FTW Chocolate (Award Winning)
Having lived in 4 countries and traveling often, chocolate is important to us. Like, REALLY important. This blue ribbon award winning flavor hits nostalgic with a depth of beautiful rich chocolate. Contains: Milk
Mint Chocolate Chunk
Chunka Chunka burning love!!! With natural mint, chunky rich chocolate chunks, and zero artificial coloring. You may even feel like you're standing on a mountain top with a crisp breeze hitting you in the face. Contains: Milk
Old Reliable (Award Winning)
Reliably the safest choice, but not easy to get right. We use pure Madagascar vanilla for the best flavor. We don't skimp on good ingredients because it's like love. You give the best and you will yield love in return. Contains: Milk, egg

Sometimes
Dark Chocolate Pistachio
Inspired by a wonderful desert. We made a much richer and darker chocolate than what we normally use and then add perfectly roasted and slightly salted pistachios to balance the bitterness of the dark chocolate. Contains: Milk, nuts
Johnboy
This flavor was created in honor of our owner Sarah's brother who lost his battle with cancer in 2022. John's favorite desert was chocolate covered bananas, so this is a chocolate and banana ice cream with a fudge swirl. Contains: Milk
There's a Turtle in My Brownie
All the decadence goes into this ice cream. Brownie batter ice cream, chunks of brownies, roasted and salted walnuts. Oh, and a caramel swirl of course. Contains: Milk, wheat, nuts
I'm Your Huckleberry
You may have encountered the huckleberry before. Similar to the blueberry, and equally tasty. We created a light huckleberry ice cream, mix in a fresh huckleberry swirl and then toss in chunks of pie crust. Contains: Milk, wheat
Cookies in Minty Cream
A twist on one of our most popular flavors, this cookies in cream adds in some natural creme de menthe to give you that mint plus chocolate combo that just seems like a match made in heaven. Contains: Milk, wheat, soy
Bourbon Vanilla Bean Truffle
Our best Madagascar vanilla, along with the delicious beans for a little extra vanilla. Add in a bit of bourbon to give just a bit of a kick on the aftertaste and then sea salt caramel truffles for the perfect compliment. Contains: Milk
Havana Cappuccino
Espresso latte in frozen form. A hint of cinnamon brings this delicious latte to maybe an even improved form. Contains: Milk
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
The darlings of the ball, Strawberries & Milk Chocolate Chunks, are now married and make the most beautiful scoops. Contains: Milk
Avo Nice Day!
Our owner, Sarah, spent her childhood in Brazil and this is a nod to her favorite memories in the Amazon. Smooth with small chunks of avocado is unbelievably delicious. You may have a tough time not putting it on repeat. Contains: Milk

Hold the Cow
Cookie Butter
Creamy coconut base combined with that delicious cookie butter, a hint of cinnamon and just a touch of vanilla. Your taste buds will start with the cookie butter and finish with coconut as they do their happy dance. Contains: Wheat, soy
Lemongrass Coconut
A surprisingly refreshing combination. Coconut base with a hint of lemongrass, incorporate some toasted coconut for a rich roasted finish.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+18 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+17 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Wynston’s never fails to disappoint and better yet it surpasses expectations. Their flavors are fantastic, bold, and there’s a wide range of options for every palate.

Creative flavors but also classics shine. The best vanilla and strawberry I’ve ever had! The strawberry with pound cake also delicious! Everything is SO good!
July 2025
Just not impressed. Ordered the cherry and tasted more like chalky cherry tums than anything. Giving three stars because I love that they offer a tiny kids cup at half price of regular. That makes me happy. Hopefully the other flavors are better, will reassess.
July 2025
Ohio transplant - literally the only ice cream I've had out here since 2017 that tastes like the ice cream I had growing up. Incredibly rich cream and quality ingredients. Will definitely be back ❤️🍦
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Maya's Cookies - 250 N City Dr #8
Bakery, Vegan
Newtopia Cyder - 250 N City Dr #10
Cideries, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
Buona Forchetta - San Marcos - 250 N City Dr Suite 3
Pizza, Italian, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian

Wynston's Ice Cream Co.

250 N City Dr Suite 7, San Marcos, CA 92078
(858) 923-1411