MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza Company

68 W Sailer Dr, San Mateo
(650) 458-3545

Recent Reviews

James W.

The food is great and so is the dining room- light and stylish high ceiling space. Two gold tiled pizza ovens ... producing great food! Everything fresh and tasty

Natalie L.

Came here on a weekday night and was instructed to just choose my table because there was hardly anyone inside. I ordered a truffle prosciutto pizza because I was hoping the truffle make it something special. Sadly, the pizza wasn't particularly satisfying, and I didn't find myself enjoying it very much. It was just kind of meh because it got overly salty with the prosciutto on top. Crust did have a nice crunch and chew to it, so I'll give some points for that!Service was great and attentive, but I don't think I'd feel inclined to come back. Generally, the food was just okay.

Michelle P.

I was sick with a cold and laryngitis and didn't want to deal with parking and trying to order with no voice so ordered through Yelp - I just got some meatballs - sounded good - they arrived a little early so I never saw the delivery person because I was in a zoom meeting but they were still warm so I was happy about that. They were so good! There are 2 of them in an order, spices were right, covvered in melted mozzarella cheese and swimming in a tasty tomato based sauce - perfect size for a lunch - delivered with bread which was maybe garlic? I couldn't taste garlic, and tasted like it didn't have great quality butter on it - whatever. I put them in the toaster oven and shook some garlic salt on it - fixed! I will go in someday and actually get that arugula prosciutto pizza I saw on the menu. Overall I was pretty happy with this simple order!

Sissy R.

Delicious food, good serviceOutdoor dining and clean。 Chicken and pizza was great; fresh salad.Would return soon.

Slyvie S.

Amazing service, affordable pricing and food was delicious! Our server was very friendly, professional, had the food prepared within minutes and got it to us at the perfect temperature. He was very attentive and helpful. We ordered a 4 Formaggi Pizza, and added mushrooms and prosciutto as toppings. The pizza had a really crisp thin crust and cheese on the pizza melts right into our mouths. The wings and fries were the right amount of crispy with the meat still being soft and delicious. The ambiance was great, with a clear view of the outside and cheerful music in the background. 100% would recommend.

Ronn M.

Simple the best Napolitano pie in town. Nuff said.I'm a San Mateo (Foster City) resident.I luv Tony's North Beach, but wait time sux on weekends.

Kris P.

Was in the mood for pizza while in the area waiting. Stopped into this place on a random weeknight at the height of dinner rush. Walked into a huge space. Nice decor, tons of tables, huge open kitchen area. But virtually nobody there. I'm always skeptical of a restaurant with almost no patrons.Ordered up a margherita pizza. Came out relatively quick. First impressions were good. The pie was of the thin and crispy charred crust variety, which i like. It was also bigger than I expected. For reference, bigger than CPK pies. Took a bite and it was so so. Decent flavor from the sauce, but overall, it was too salty for my taste. Only finished half of it and took the rest home.My test for how good a previous dinner was? If I ended up eating the leftovers. In this case, I didn't touch it and went to waste. It wasn't bad, but far from my favorite. Especially given the price point. Space might be too big for this place. They might need to get creative and co-lease it to another tenant somehow.

Emily P.

Love this place! Discovered it last year while taking a trip and have been craving this ever since.Also perfect timing as Monday they have $5 off their pastas.I love how cheesy and creamy the chicken Alfredo is and it's a perfect portion size.It took maybe around 20 minutes to get my food after ordering in their store.Would love to come back again in the future!!

May L.

Delicious pizza spot at the Hillsdale mall. Inside is clean and decorated with personality. There's spacious seating with a wide window wall that lets in a lot of natural light. Dinner wasn't too busy and service was fast. We got the Diavola pizza with walnut salad. Portions are generous, and the salad was really refreshing. Loved the balsamic glaze and all the toppings. The pizza dough is chewy and toasted. It's flavorful with rich marina sauce and spicy sausage. Had to fold the pizza in half to eat it because it was so soft but overall tasted amazing.

Rosy P.

Will the place was nice in side and out. Bathroom need a little maintenance but it's ok. The pizza was good not amazing far from for the best it was just ok. The service was truly horrible. There wasn't anyone there. That alone should of been a sign. My son decided to set by the window and one of the works very rude stated that area was close for a pirate party. Which is totally fine I get it, but the way he said to a small child. That's what got me. If that wasn't bad he proceeds By grabbing the sign that state "please wait to be seated and smack it on the floor super loudly.! Right next to us! So for those reasons I would never eat there again!

Ying-Chieh Huang

The pizza and pasta just brought me and my family back to Italy immediately! So good.

Jessica N.

Located on the second floor at Hillsdale Mall above Lululemon. Ambience was very cute. Also features a patio overlooking the courtyard below. Portion size was pretty impressive. And quality was fair. Prices were decent. However service was very very slow as the 2 servers also doubled as the kitchen staff. So they would take our order and then proceed to the open kitchen and make the food. There were only 3-4 tables so it was not busy. It's unfortunate they have to be so understaffed. Each course was heavily spaced out. I would still come back again for the pizzas as it's hard to find a decent Neapolitan pizza in the Bay Area.

Majd Bakar

Amazing service, great atmosphere and awesome food. The cocktail selection is great. This is a place to eat, drink, and have fun with friends. Go for the Diavolo Pizza it's fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Diavola Pizza, Signature Nutella Calzone, Truffle Fries, Midici House Salad

Ying-Chieh Huang (Jay)

The pizza and pasta just brought me and my family back to Italy immediately! So good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Richard H

Located on the second floor of the Hillsdale Shopping mall (separated from the food court), authentic Neapolitan pizza! I spoke to the general manager, Juan who shared that their chefs are trained in Napoli, Italy to ensure that your pizza maintains the highest quality. The key is the temperature of the Wood baked oven, which produces a crispy crust. Their pizza dough is made fresh daily. We also tried the walnut and Gorgonzola salad, which was a large portion and delicious flavor. We were treated to their decadent Tiramisu, which finished the meal!

Load More

MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza Company

68 W Sailer Dr, San Mateo, CA 94403
(650) 458-3545