This place has always been my favorite pizza in the Bay area. The calzones are especially delicious and the pizza hits the spot every time. I'm not even a fan of just cheese pizza, but I'll eat it here!
Kyle Clark
Consistently solid and the staff are always friendly
Aurian Saleh
Delicious pizza spot, really hits the spot, quality ingredients
CJ Melendez
The pizza doesn’t have the texture or structural integrity of a New York City style (too floppy and airy like most Bay Area pizza places) but the flavor and toppings are good. Maybe their thin crust option is better but “regular” was too bready.
Cory Mathews
Definitely a very good pizza. We ordered it from the restaurant but we were next door at eddy's bar and they delivered the pizza with plates and all the stuff needed to the bar like we were sitting in their establishment. Not boxed up but on the baking tray and all
ramin sinsoleimani
Great pizza, clean store, great service.
Ali Inspires
I went here after a friend told me about it. I walked in and Billy greeted me so nicely and asked me if I’d been in before. I told him it was my first time. Being from NY it’s hard to get a good slice around here. So I was pleasantly surprised with how amazing it was. 10/10 recommend.
Pao Ortega
I get great service, every single time?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
John B
Needed a quick spot after a long day. Ready for 7:45 flight tomorrow. NY Pizza was very close to Atrium hotel. Quick service great food. We did NOT get the metre wide King Long however.
Tracey Ferguson
I've been ordering pizza from New York Pizza for the past 5 years. I order pizza every week.
This is the first time I've been dissatisfied. The pizza was hard, barely any cheese or sauce. The mushrooms looked dehydrated. The bell peppers used to be nicely sauce. And now there chopped in tiny squares. The pepperoni was smaller. And there was barely any meet.
I would hate to think my favorite pizza place has jumped on the band wagon of shrinkflation.
Wow.. was just walking by this place looking for a bite while I had time to kill and thought a slice sounded good... was amazed by what i got.. one of best slices of pizza I've ever had.. price, flavor, cooked to perfection.. had to leave instant review, wish I lived closer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Mahdi Arfa
Rude cashier horrible customer service and long wait never come here again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Hit List
Might be a little better than a hot pocket, but it's misleading to associate this place with such high standards as New York when the flavor doesn't come close to what NY pizza is known for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Trevor Johnson
this place is a hidden gem
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
W S
Great $5.99 combo deal! You can get any of their pizzas as a slice. The crust is crispy and thin even when you get a slice with a lot of toppings. Probably the best pizza on B Street and open late. The halal chicken and LA combo are delicious!
This place has always been my favorite pizza in the Bay area. The calzones are especially delicious and the pizza hits the spot every time. I'm not even a fan of just cheese pizza, but I'll eat it here!
Consistently solid and the staff are always friendly
Delicious pizza spot, really hits the spot, quality ingredients
The pizza doesn’t have the texture or structural integrity of a New York City style (too floppy and airy like most Bay Area pizza places) but the flavor and toppings are good. Maybe their thin crust option is better but “regular” was too bready.
Definitely a very good pizza. We ordered it from the restaurant but we were next door at eddy's bar and they delivered the pizza with plates and all the stuff needed to the bar like we were sitting in their establishment. Not boxed up but on the baking tray and all
Great pizza, clean store, great service.
I went here after a friend told me about it. I walked in and Billy greeted me so nicely and asked me if I’d been in before. I told him it was my first time. Being from NY it’s hard to get a good slice around here. So I was pleasantly surprised with how amazing it was. 10/10 recommend.
I get great service, every single time?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Needed a quick spot after a long day. Ready for 7:45 flight tomorrow. NY Pizza was very close to Atrium hotel. Quick service great food. We did NOT get the metre wide King Long however.
I've been ordering pizza from New York Pizza for the past 5 years. I order pizza every week.
This is the first time I've been dissatisfied.
The pizza was hard, barely any cheese or sauce. The mushrooms looked dehydrated. The bell peppers used to be nicely sauce. And now there chopped in tiny squares. The pepperoni was smaller. And there was barely any meet.
I would hate to think my favorite pizza place has jumped on the band wagon of shrinkflation.
Joseph F
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Wow.. was just walking by this place looking for a bite while I had time to kill and thought a slice sounded good... was amazed by what i got.. one of best slices of pizza I've ever had.. price, flavor, cooked to perfection.. had to leave instant review, wish I lived closer!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Rude cashier horrible customer service and long wait never come here again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Might be a little better than a hot pocket, but it's misleading to associate this place with such high standards as New York when the flavor doesn't come close to what NY pizza is known for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
this place is a hidden gem
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great $5.99 combo deal! You can get any of their pizzas as a slice. The crust is crispy and thin even when you get a slice with a lot of toppings. Probably the best pizza on B Street and open late. The halal chicken and LA combo are delicious!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...