The price of the large pizza is insane. Greek pizza was good but definitely not worth the
Food: 4
Kevin C
their pizza crust, sauce, and overall ratios are pretty bad. the two slices I got, it was like they fully baked the crust then added the toppings and baked it again, crunchier than a cracker. the pizza tastes like a lunchable pizza that someone left in the oven for too long.absolutely nothing like NY pizza and not really good by california standards either
Food: 2
Jenny Munoz
The lasagna was a great surprise, one of the best that u had tasted in the area! I will b back for more :)
Food: 5
Leo
Vegetarian options: They had a Gluten Free option for my kid was a bit expensive about $24 with tip but was delicious nonetheless.Parking: Parking was difficult, was able to find parking in the garage however eventually. Was about a 2 min walk.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Pizza, All Green Pizza, Jumbo Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Thelma Wilburn
I ordered a salad and almost everything was wrong with it. There were many pieces of rotten lettuce that were black and mushy. The cucumbers were very soggy and soft. The tomatoes were all wrinkled and mushy. Horrible.Then on a different day I ordered a slice of pizza. The vegetables were all chopped up into small bits as if they were gonna make a indian masala or something.This new york pizza is not the same as before. Not sure if they changed owners but it was a lot better when they had the latinos working there. Wayyy better pizza in that time and fresher salads. Now there is only Indians there and you can tell the difference in quality and taste. The way they chop them veggies be having the pizza taste like a curry.Amici’s and north beach pizza is way better.
Majool
This place is okay but there are other better pizza joints in downtown San Mateo. I found that the dough is inconsistent as it is sometimes might be too thick or too thin. Guess it depends on who is working there on that day. Would that being said. This place is located right next to a bar where you can take your pizza inside.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Matthew G.
this place used to mail coupons all the time. but i guess they are popular enough where they dont need marketing tools to get customers. sad because i like saving money! normally i order a king kong size pizza to feed the fam of 4. the presentation is great because the box is huge! but its new york style so its thin and floppy needing the fold to eat. i call in, its ready and i leave. very seamless and perfect. the toppings and ingredients are fresh and plentiful. normally get the combo that comes with veggies and meat. for around 50$ it can feed everyone happily. they have other foods like pastas and sandwiches and salads but ive only tried the pizza. maybe one day i'll venture out. good solid pizza thats dependable.
James Tosta
Great local pizza joint for giant slices made to order. They are open late and always take care of their customers. Bonus being next to a bar! If you ask they will bring the pizza next door for you to enjoy with a nice cold beer.Vegetarian options: Lots of veggie options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Mary M.
We have ordered delivery off and on since they opened and never had any issue that I can remember. The food is good, and it's consistent. The staff is always very friendly when I've called in. I can't say one bad thing .
Erika Mediano
We ordered Buffalo wings they were ok but Domino's better. Pizza was good we had combo really good recommend. We placed order by phone great customer service. Would recommend to family and friends ?
A late night snack really hit the spot and even though it was nearly time to close they made a delicious "pie".
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura B.
Wanted NY style pizza ordered takeout from here. Got 2 types of pizza, both were good! Definately hit the spot and will go back!
Aravind V.
I thought San Mateo was really missing places to go to just get a quick slice of pizza, but this scratched that itch perfectly! I got there not knowing what to expect but the staff there at the time gave me a rundown on all the types of pizza they had, how they liked to modify it, how other customers liked to modify it, and left me with so many options that sounded delicious. The slices are HUGE and the price is quite low for a single slice -- I saw the price and I convinced myself I had to get two since they "must be tiny", but ended up not even being able to finish. You can chill in the bar next door and they will deliver your made-to-order pizza right to you, which was awesome:)
Diana K.
Go to pizza place, great pizza accommodating staff! always on time! have gone there for twenty years
Wayne P.
Right next to the cinemark in San Mateo. You order up front then they bring the food out to you. They don't give you a number for your order or receipt. Ordered the margherita and pesto chicken. Waited about close to an hour to get my food. Went in multiple times to ask about the progress on my order and they kept telling to wait a few minutes. And they said they ran out of pesto chicken slices so they gave me the personal size pizza instead, which didn't seem as crispy. Finally got my order and pizza was ok. Crispy, hot, decent flavor but the whole waiting kind of ruined the experience.
The price of the large pizza is insane. Greek pizza was good but definitely not worth the
Food: 4
their pizza crust, sauce, and overall ratios are pretty bad. the two slices I got, it was like they fully baked the crust then added the toppings and baked it again, crunchier than a cracker. the pizza tastes like a lunchable pizza that someone left in the oven for too long.absolutely nothing like NY pizza and not really good by california standards either
Food: 2
The lasagna was a great surprise, one of the best that u had tasted in the area! I will b back for more :)
Food: 5
Vegetarian options: They had a Gluten Free option for my kid was a bit expensive about $24 with tip but was delicious nonetheless.Parking: Parking was difficult, was able to find parking in the garage however eventually. Was about a 2 min walk.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Pizza, All Green Pizza, Jumbo Pepperoni Pizza Slice
I ordered a salad and almost everything was wrong with it. There were many pieces of rotten lettuce that were black and mushy. The cucumbers were very soggy and soft. The tomatoes were all wrinkled and mushy. Horrible.Then on a different day I ordered a slice of pizza. The vegetables were all chopped up into small bits as if they were gonna make a indian masala or something.This new york pizza is not the same as before. Not sure if they changed owners but it was a lot better when they had the latinos working there. Wayyy better pizza in that time and fresher salads. Now there is only Indians there and you can tell the difference in quality and taste. The way they chop them veggies be having the pizza taste like a curry.Amici’s and north beach pizza is way better.
This place is okay but there are other better pizza joints in downtown San Mateo. I found that the dough is inconsistent as it is sometimes might be too thick or too thin. Guess it depends on who is working there on that day. Would that being said. This place is located right next to a bar where you can take your pizza inside.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
this place used to mail coupons all the time. but i guess they are popular enough where they dont need marketing tools to get customers. sad because i like saving money! normally i order a king kong size pizza to feed the fam of 4. the presentation is great because the box is huge! but its new york style so its thin and floppy needing the fold to eat. i call in, its ready and i leave. very seamless and perfect. the toppings and ingredients are fresh and plentiful. normally get the combo that comes with veggies and meat. for around 50$ it can feed everyone happily. they have other foods like pastas and sandwiches and salads but ive only tried the pizza. maybe one day i'll venture out. good solid pizza thats dependable.
Great local pizza joint for giant slices made to order. They are open late and always take care of their customers. Bonus being next to a bar! If you ask they will bring the pizza next door for you to enjoy with a nice cold beer.Vegetarian options: Lots of veggie options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Pepperoni Pizza Slice
We have ordered delivery off and on since they opened and never had any issue that I can remember. The food is good, and it's consistent. The staff is always very friendly when I've called in. I can't say one bad thing .
We ordered Buffalo wings they were ok but Domino's better. Pizza was good we had combo really good recommend. We placed order by phone great customer service. Would recommend to family and friends ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
A late night snack really hit the spot and even though it was nearly time to close they made a delicious "pie".
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wanted NY style pizza ordered takeout from here. Got 2 types of pizza, both were good! Definately hit the spot and will go back!
I thought San Mateo was really missing places to go to just get a quick slice of pizza, but this scratched that itch perfectly! I got there not knowing what to expect but the staff there at the time gave me a rundown on all the types of pizza they had, how they liked to modify it, how other customers liked to modify it, and left me with so many options that sounded delicious. The slices are HUGE and the price is quite low for a single slice -- I saw the price and I convinced myself I had to get two since they "must be tiny", but ended up not even being able to finish. You can chill in the bar next door and they will deliver your made-to-order pizza right to you, which was awesome:)
Go to pizza place, great pizza accommodating staff! always on time! have gone there for twenty years
Right next to the cinemark in San Mateo. You order up front then they bring the food out to you. They don't give you a number for your order or receipt. Ordered the margherita and pesto chicken. Waited about close to an hour to get my food. Went in multiple times to ask about the progress on my order and they kept telling to wait a few minutes. And they said they ran out of pesto chicken slices so they gave me the personal size pizza instead, which didn't seem as crispy. Finally got my order and pizza was ok. Crispy, hot, decent flavor but the whole waiting kind of ruined the experience.