Noah's NY Bagels

50 E 4th Ave, San Mateo
(650) 347-2364

Recent Reviews

Ammar Feroz

I usually place a Mobile order and pick up and I’m tired of them messing up my order. It’s either the wrong cream cheese or missing ingredients and this happens almost every

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

ZENG PhotoArt

This coffee shop provide a good service and has a lot of guests, good environment too, It is located in the center of the local area, which is very convenient.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Bagel Deli Kit

John M

From NYC and this ain't no NY bagel. This is the consistency of a toast with seasoning on top and a hole in the middle. ?

Don

Closed on Thursday due to maintenance issues.

Service: 1

Nick Parikh

Ordered Avocado toast from the menu and look at what they give me. Just cut avocado slices placed on top which felt very raw. Worst avocado toast ever.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Jay Sathe

The only bagel place you want to

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Yogya Hari Prakash Burra

Messed up a simple order of 2 bagels and cream cheese. Not toasted well enough and got the wrong cream cheese, disappointed as we were looking forward to taste this before our flight.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg Cheese Bagel

Ian McDonald

The food is generally decent (though the bagels are far from NY-quality). And they can be a bit hit or miss. Got a jalepeno-cheddar and it was missing all but one jalepeno. You can see where they once were, no longer.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

ifoney1

The owner/manager is always mad at someone and disrespectful to staff and customers. That is probably why they cannot keep good workers who can get orders right. Order a few bagels and they always manage to screw up something.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Marlee M.

We have frequently come to this Noah's in San Mateo and wanted to keep giving it a try even though each time, the Lox and Bagel is not to our satisfaction. How can you mess up a Bagel sandwich? Today will be our last visit. A five-year-old could have done a better job of making this bagel sandwich. The lox is always over to one side of the bagel, the cucumbers are not fresh (soggy), and someone needs to learn how to cut a sandwich in half. For as many staff members today, I would like to receive a quality sandwich, especially since it is expensive. Unfortunately, this will be our last visit.

Cuong Nguyen

Not sure what happened to Noah’s Bagels - the menu is a lot smaller than what I remembered and the portions are ridiculously small. The service was nice and quick but the food is just embarrassing. I ordered the farmhouse that had the thinnest slices of bacon, thinnest ham, and smallest egg I have ever seen. It’s quite comical when you think about it! Probably start making my own bagel sandwiches at this point.

Tiffany Yu

Delicious I go for farmers breakfast

Linda A.

The staff is so rude. They talk to each other and not to the customers. This establishment has gone downhill.

Cuazzy N.

Not sure what happened to Noah's Bagels - the menu is a lot smaller than what I remembered and the portions are ridiculously small. The service was nice and quick but the food is just embarrassing. I ordered the farmhouse that had the thinnest slices of bacon, thinnest ham, and smallest egg I have ever seen. It's quite comical when you think about it! Probably start making my own bagel sandwiches at this point.

Bashir A.

This past Sunday was my first trip to this Noah's NY Bagels location. I normally visit the one in Fremont but happen to be in the area and craving a good bagel. I arrived at approximately 10am. The restaurant was very, very busy. Even with a fair amount of staff, the line reached the door. That being said, the staff is pretty good at moving the line so I didn't wait very long. The reason I'm giving it a 3-Star is due to a few factors:1. They were out of stock of many items. It seemed like everyone (including myself) had to choose an alternate item. It was still early in the day so I didn't understand why they were out of things already.2. The seating is not adequate for the level of customers. There's 3 tables outside and some counters inside, but they were all occupied and the turnover was too slow for the amount of patrons. A few more tables and chairs outside would make a big difference.3. The costs have really skyrocketed. I know due to inflation everything has gotten more expensive, but $30 for 2 bagels and 2 coffees seemed expensive. This is exuberated with the fact that the bagels are not all that big. The bagels themselves were good. They were fresh and tasty. The coffee was hot. Overall made for a quick snack.

Load More