Paul Martin's America

101 Hillsdale Shopping Center, San Mateo
(650) 212-7400

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tom and Vicki

Fantastic dinner. We all ordered the halibut and it was delicious! Loved the Cajun fries and the Spicy Shrimp. And the desserts were just as good: chocolate cake and cheesecake. So sorry to see this restaurant come to a close. Lots of good times and good eats at Paul Martin's in San Mateo.

Paul

So sorry to hear this restaurant will be closing soon. We had a really great dinner here this evening, as with all the other times we've visited. Really a treasure that San Mateo will be losing.

Mike

We went on a Saturday and the menu did not offer many choices. No crab cake appetizer, no pastas, chicken parm etc. We enjoyed the Shrimp appetizer, the Cobb salads were were fresh, loaded with protein and delicious. Burger was a perfect medium well. The server was excellent

katherine

The website said there was an all day menu available and there wasn't. This was disappointing because I intended to order from that. Only one veggie item on the regular menu

Nicole

I've eaten here before and had good experience with the food but this visit was a real step down from previous visits

Joseph

Upon checking in we were immediately seated. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. We were not rushed into ordering and enjoyed our appetizers before placing our dinner order. The food was served hot and ready to eat. The food was exceptionally good. Table service was excellent. This was our 57th Wedding Anniversary dinner and the staff made it a special occasion for us. We are return customers and as before we were not disappointed. We will be back again soon.

Maya

We love this restaurant every time we go.The deviled eggs are amazing.They didn't have sparkling water so that was a lil sad but it's still one of our favorites

Thomas

The Happy Hour menu and pricing is fantastic. The food was delicious, and the service was excellent.

lester

Had reservations at 6pm, but was allowed in early which was good. Restaurant was about 1/4 full. I ordered the ribeye and wife had the snapper. daughter had the seafood pasta. steak was okay, snapper was not a lot of quantity, and seafood pasta was good portions.

Barby

I love Paul Martin. The food is reliably great. The service is always great. I eat fish or veggies on Friday and they have good non meat choices.

Bryce

Outstanding customer service at this fantastic restaurant. Our server, Anau T. Was incredible, professional and very helpful. We enjoyed a very special birthday lunch for a 100 year old neighbor and Anau went above and beyond to help our table of four. Thanks again and we'll return soon. Sincerely, B&E

Nini Verl Fernandez

Our reservation originally was at 12:30pm on Mothers' Day, but we came early and just asked the host if we can be seated. She checked and we were seated right away. I did not get a chance to ask her name. Our server was Andre, very Professional and quick service. The food was well cooked and tastes so good. We enjoyed our dining experience and would definitely come back.

Faro

Our reservation originally was at 12:30pm on Mothers' Day, but we came early and just asked the host if we can be seated. She checked and we were seated right away. I did not get a chance to ask her name. Our server was Andre, very Professional and quick service. The food was well cooked and tastes so good. We enjoyed our dining experience and would definitely come back.

Kathleen

Attended Mother's Day brunch. Several of our breakfast orders were COLD, like they were taken out of the refrigerator. We sent them back and they returned them still cold. You don't want your eggs benedict cold! While they did credit us back some $ on our bill, it was still not a good experience. Especially for a celebratory family event like this. Bottom line: do not get the Benedict.

Arlene

It's too noisy with the music. It's already loud in the restaurant and very difficult to chat with your dining companions.

Loading...