Tomatina

401 S B St, San Mateo
(650) 918-5030

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ben

Good place to go for a decent Italian inexpensive dinner. Friendly service, good food. Pizza tasty and the extra large is definitely large! Always enjoy this place.

Lane Burgett

Cold lasagna, my bro got three meat balls, restaurant has all windows open on 60 degree day, overpriced

Cbay Mult

7/18/25 12:50pm Fri place empty on beautiful day. Now i know why. Says wait to be seated but 2 staff ignored me & when finally attended had no smile or words. The place has no ac or fans and when I mentioned it being warm server didn't respond. Then i realized place smelled like urine !!! (from using same mop for bathroom everywhere! Will report to health dept). Also a large filled trash bag on restaurant seat. The table was sticky all over! Gross.
Sandwich served on same plate as a salad and was soggy and wet from the dressing 👎. No bueno. Server didn't care.
Big turn off dollar tree plastic flowers with white rocks...tacky! Who is manager?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Alex S

It's okay. The food is very non offensive and the ingredients all taste like they're straight out of the Sysco catalog. Just no depth in the flavor. The service was great, but we probably won't be back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Steph

American Italian staple in downtown San Mateo. Staff was great, although our server seemed to be doing everything for the restaurant (host, bartender, server, busser, cleaner)! My Dad was disappointed that they didn't have the bread pudding; not sure if it's permanently gone or just that night.

heidi hoffman

We had an awesome waitress! Very friendly. Food was so good we came back the next day for dinner! I'm sure we'll eat here again before going back home.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Calzone

Dena Perez

Very pleasant

RD Mahanpour

Nice place to eat

AC M

Nice place to eat

Dmitry Feldman

I was there on Friday night and was pleasantly surprised on how quiet and welcoming it was. Great food, excellent service, plenty of parking nearby.

tomdegraff

First time there looking for traditional spaghetti and meatballs. It was very good and our waitress was 5 stars.

Murillo Pontual

Good Italian food at the heart of San Mateo. Both the pizza and pasta are tasty and well made.

Stephen Helton

Server was marginally attentive. Food was excellent. Ranch for the wings was delicious. Garlic knots-AWESOME. Chicken alfredo was very good. Sauce was a little watery but much flavor. Need to stock Disarono.

Asha Keba

Always love this place! A family favorite - the hummus piadine is super delicious, and you can't miss the bruschetta!

Gary Ogawa

Go there for their shitake mushroom pizza. Delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...