$40 teeny tiny pizza that arrived cold, safety seal was broken and there wasn’t even enough cheese to cover the pizza. The worst food value experience I’ve had in Marin yet. And that is saying a lot.
M L
Excellent pizza. Exceptional service. Giants game on. Recommend NY style pepperoni with fresh garlic.
linda herbert
Had pasta..💥 happy to discover WEDNESDAY is 1/2 price pasta 💌
Roberto Velasco
Going to be honest, though ive always liked Amicis enough to come back every now and then i havent always been impressed with the food quality. But i just came back from dinner and happy to report i was pleasantly surprised about our experience and food today. I discovered their garlic bread today and it was amazing. In the past some of their pastas didn’t feel as freshly made as they could but today they completely hit the mark. Keep it up and i may start coming back slightly more often! Great and friendly service today by the way! Thank you.
Victoria Lamke
The pizza in town!
El Metate
The super friendly manager, 10/10 the incredible pizzas, 100% recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lillian
I frequent the Amici’s Pizzeria in Vacaville, CA. Luv the pizza. Their thin crust, oven flamed fired pizza is so good. So when I was in San Rafael for the night and realized there was an Amici’s close by, I definitely made it a point to order a pizza. I called in an order for pickup. I ordered my favorite… pepperoni pizza. It was delicious. Plus the customer service was fantastic.
The pizza is baked in an open flame pizza oven. The pizza from this Amici’s had a thin crust; it was light with a soft chew. The pizza was beautifully lightly blistered. The pepperoni is so good, great quality and taste. The pepperoni curled up into little cup shapes with crisp edges. They use quality mozzarella as well. Overall just a darn good pizza.
The customer service is great. Everyone I spoke to was kind, outgoing, and helpful. The restaurant itself is on the smaller side, as are most of the downtown eateries. Another thing to note is the parking situation; there are metered street parking and a paid city lot around the corner down a block on C and 5th Street.
Parking: Metered street parking in front. And around the corner, one block away is a city paid parking lot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
A Phelps
This is my go to when I come to town for pizza. I like thin crust pizza and the New Haven White Clam pizza is my standard order with some type of salad. I have had various salads they are all delicious and fresh. The picture is from a previous take out. The standard salad is big enough for two to share. I went with a colleague and we shared the antipasto salad and each ordered our own pizza. I have tried the meat balls and sausage and enjoyed both of them. I go to the clam pizza because it is not something you can get everywhere. The food is fantastic, the service good, lots of people do take away or delivery.
Parking: Parking is on the street depends what time of day if it is free or paid.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New Haven White Clam
Johann C. Frey
Best pizza in Marin
Mike
Amazing pizza! The staff was very polite and tried to accommodate our dietary restrictions as best they could. I have to knock off a star since their alternative options were limited, and the interior could use a makover.
I just wanna give a shoutout to the staff. We came to town with a group of about 40 people and basically took over the pizza shop. The staff did their best and got our orders out as quickly as they could. The pizza was delicious, our table got a few different kinds and some of their meatballs as well and were not disappointed ? I would include pictures but I'm not one to take pictures of my food ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
wes Stedman
Best NY pizza this side of Jersey!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura f
I ordered a small Amici’s combo pizza with a garden salad. This cost me $40 on DoorDash (this does not include tip). I ordered this “No bacon”. Not only did it have bacon it did NOT have mushrooms or black olives. I literally hate bacon so much I didn’t eat this pizza. I meant to take it to work but kept forgetting so the whole pizza went in the trash, minus a bite of the crust. I ordered from here thinking it would be better quality than the other lower cost pizza places, I ordered at 4:30pm on a Wednesday- a low volume time so it should have been an easy task… I was wrong… I basically paid $40 for a salad that didn’t have enough dressing.
Food: 1
Martin Ramos
Pricey for what I had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natalie Carrera
Had the best service tonight by Rodrigo. He was an incredible person to wait on us, very attentive and kind. The food was great as always but I’m leaving this review tonight because the service was so good.
$40 teeny tiny pizza that arrived cold, safety seal was broken and there wasn’t even enough cheese to cover the pizza. The worst food value experience I’ve had in Marin yet. And that is saying a lot.
Excellent pizza. Exceptional service. Giants game on. Recommend NY style pepperoni with fresh garlic.
Had pasta..💥 happy to discover WEDNESDAY is 1/2 price pasta 💌
Going to be honest, though ive always liked Amicis enough to come back every now and then i havent always been impressed with the food quality. But i just came back from dinner and happy to report i was pleasantly surprised about our experience and food today. I discovered their garlic bread today and it was amazing. In the past some of their pastas didn’t feel as freshly made as they could but today they completely hit the mark. Keep it up and i may start coming back slightly more often! Great and friendly service today by the way! Thank you.
The pizza in town!
The super friendly manager, 10/10 the incredible pizzas, 100% recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I frequent the Amici’s Pizzeria in Vacaville, CA. Luv the pizza. Their thin crust, oven flamed fired pizza is so good. So when I was in San Rafael for the night and realized there was an Amici’s close by, I definitely made it a point to order a pizza. I called in an order for pickup. I ordered my favorite… pepperoni pizza. It was delicious. Plus the customer service was fantastic.
The pizza is baked in an open flame pizza oven. The pizza from this Amici’s had a thin crust; it was light with a soft chew. The pizza was beautifully lightly blistered. The pepperoni is so good, great quality and taste. The pepperoni curled up into little cup shapes with crisp edges. They use quality mozzarella as well. Overall just a darn good pizza.
The customer service is great. Everyone I spoke to was kind, outgoing, and helpful. The restaurant itself is on the smaller side, as are most of the downtown eateries. Another thing to note is the parking situation; there are metered street parking and a paid city lot around the corner down a block on C and 5th Street.
Parking: Metered street parking in front. And around the corner, one block away is a city paid parking lot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my go to when I come to town for pizza. I like thin crust pizza and the New Haven White Clam pizza is my standard order with some type of salad. I have had various salads they are all delicious and fresh. The picture is from a previous take out. The standard salad is big enough for two to share. I went with a colleague and we shared the antipasto salad and each ordered our own pizza. I have tried the meat balls and sausage and enjoyed both of them. I go to the clam pizza because it is not something you can get everywhere. The food is fantastic, the service good, lots of people do take away or delivery.
Parking: Parking is on the street depends what time of day if it is free or paid.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New Haven White Clam
Best pizza in Marin
Amazing pizza! The staff was very polite and tried to accommodate our dietary restrictions as best they could. I have to knock off a star since their alternative options were limited, and the interior could use a makover.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York
Restaurantji Recommends
I just wanna give a shoutout to the staff. We came to town with a group of about 40 people and basically took over the pizza shop. The staff did their best and got our orders out as quickly as they could. The pizza was delicious, our table got a few different kinds and some of their meatballs as well and were not disappointed ? I would include pictures but I'm not one to take pictures of my food ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best NY pizza this side of Jersey!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a small Amici’s combo pizza with a garden salad. This cost me $40 on DoorDash (this does not include tip). I ordered this “No bacon”. Not only did it have bacon it did NOT have mushrooms or black olives. I literally hate bacon so much I didn’t eat this pizza. I meant to take it to work but kept forgetting so the whole pizza went in the trash, minus a bite of the crust. I ordered from here thinking it would be better quality than the other lower cost pizza places, I ordered at 4:30pm on a Wednesday- a low volume time so it should have been an easy task… I was wrong… I basically paid $40 for a salad that didn’t have enough dressing.
Food: 1
Pricey for what I had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the best service tonight by Rodrigo. He was an incredible person to wait on us, very attentive and kind. The food was great as always but I’m leaving this review tonight because the service was so good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...