Milk & Cookies

I don’t usually trust cookie places (overhyped or just too sweet), but this place? This one’s worth it for me. I liked it! Everything was fresh, soft, and not overly sugary (except maybe the choco chip, but that’s just me being meh about chocolate).

Snickerdoodle – Classic. Soft. Perfect. 9/10
Chocolate Chip – Crisp outer layer, soft gooey center. A little sweet for me, but still solid. 7.5/10
Toffee Crunch – Sweet but in a rich toffee way, not im dying sweet. Slightly sticky. Tasty. 8/10
Butter Cake Cookie – Fluffy as hell. Like soft cake with a little crisp outside. Wasn't giving cookie to me actually. 6/10
White Chocolate Macadamia – Firmer texture than the others, crispy edge. I'm biased, it’s my fave flavor. 10/10
Lemon and Blueberry – Smells amazing, tastes even better. Crispy outside, soft middle. Legit lemon blueberry. 9.5/10

Overall, I’d come back. Everything was displayed nicely for easy choosing, the staff was super helpful picking flavors, and it all felt fresh, nothing dry or hard. A couple were thinner (like the white choc and snickerdoodle), but for around $15? Totally fine. Quality was up there. 11/10 from me.

Good and great price for the 12 late nights dozen, but upon coming home ice cream was completely melted. More like a shake for the pint. Still tasted good but maybe b/c of the heat it melted so fast. Otherwise great.

so good bought 100000 cookies

The oatmeal cookie and Cowboy cookie are legit. And the ice cream is lights out.

The BEST cookies!!! Cookies and Cream is my personal favorite but I have tried several of the cookies and I loved all them.

We stopped here before heading to a show at Segerstrom and we were pleasantly surprised with the food and service. I couldn’t decide between the brown butter toffee ice cream and the cookie butter because they were both so good and they offered to give me a bit of both. I had the S’more cookie and my husband had the Cowboy and they were both so good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cowboy Cookie Jumbo, S'Mores Jumbo Size

Cookie was very small and got the wrong ice cream delivered, and the one we got was also freezer burned... Not a good experience overall

The cookies here are way better than Crumbl. I love how you can get a cookie with ice cream for 6$ or a cookie ice cream sandwich! Definitely worth the money and also very delicious ? will definitely be coming back! Also the service is very fast and the workers are always so kind!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

No phone number listed. When I am rerouted from other stores, the phone goes to voicemail

absolutely in LOVE with this place. My favourite is their peanut butter cookie with cookies and cream ice cream. cookies always served warm not much more I can ask for thanks Rana for the recommendation.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It's wild to me that a dessert place in California does not have calories listed. Couldn't even find them on the website either and although it might sound stupid I would like to know how many calories a cookie is so I know it's within my cheat parameters.The cookies themselves were tasty but the service was pretty bad, I walked in and nobody was at the front for a solid 5 minutes.Overall I would go back, but please find out the calories, even the people working there don't know and that's a big issue, and I'm pretty sure against the law in California (California menu-law since 2009)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip, S'Mores Jumbo Size

Always served

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Same concept as Insomnia Cookies in UCI but Insomnia Cookies come in a pizza box like container to keep cookies warm.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Warm cookies on demand ?

good cookies and I love it, the ice cream is alright, too. The only reason this is a 4 star is because there were no chocolate chip cookies. I would do 2 star, but im feeling nice today. This made me sad that there were no chocolate chip cookies. I don’t like being sad. :( (this is a half joke i like this place :))