The Penny Ice Creamery | Pleasure Point
820 41st Ave, Santa Cruz
(831) 204-2523
Recent Reviews
Sort by
820 41st Ave, Santa Cruz
(831) 204-2523
Great ice cream. Great service. The blonde was very friendly. Definitely returning again when in town.
Their burnt caramel ice cream is in my top favorite 3 ice creams of all time. Epic spot.
An adorable little ice cream and coffee shop with incredible flavors, helpful staff and a great vibe. The selection is limited but everyone found something they loved. The marshmallow fluff topping was delicious. Will 100% return again!
i love their cone and you can get like marshmallow cream on the outside it was really good 👍
Not a fan- we got the mint ice cream and it was way too garden tasting- we should've tasted ice cream first, but we tasted natural organic mint, which is a great thought, but a horrible taste. Went back in and explained that we did. They asked if we licked it of course we did. It's ice cream..... and they gave us a minuscule scoop of vanilla and called it a day. Do not recommend horrible customer service. The guy was kind of snarky and did not fulfill the full scoop. I paid for way too much. I don't mind paying a good penny for good ice cream but if it's crappy, no thank you
The price was high but worth it the ice cream was good
Best ice cream ever! The cone is so perfectly sweet and the ice cream is so nice and sweet but not overly sweet! The marshmallow topping is really nice and a good toasty deep flavor :)
PS. The girl working on 4/22/25 @ 5 pm is so pretty and nice, she provided great customer service and had such a nice contagious smile. She complimented my bangs and made my day :)
Great product, but terrible customer service
This used to be the best place in town but now it’s nasty! They are constantly putting out new “Artisan” flavors and not a single one I’ve tried has been anywhere close to decent, they used to have a line out the door and now every time I go I’m unbelievably disappointed DO NOT
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I love their continually changing flavors, they are always amazing! Don't forget the mini double scoop if you can't decide between two of them!
Restaurantji Recommends
I tried the chocolate roasted almonds and marshmallows and omg IT WAS GOOD!! The texture, the size of the scoop and the service were beyond expectations. I highly recommend it ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Single Scoop, Gelato
The flavors are amazing! And the host was so kind and friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It showed open but closed
Kinda rude, felt rushed and wasn't that great tasting.
Very helpful, great tasting cones
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...