Martha's Old Mexico Restaurant

We absolutely love Martha's for so many reasons!
The food is outstanding... and trust me you get plenty, and we love the decor in the back seating area with the deer, rabbits & squirrels (not real but it makes a wonderful setting), especially if you bring young children!!!
It's a regular for us when we want Mexican Food.
The owner is absolutely as gracious as one can be!!!!

We recently ate here and I ordered the
Tostada Mazatlan Prawns. This was nothing like it was described on the menu and the prawns literaly tasted like spicy dirt. It was horrible. I let the waitress know and she didn't offer to comp the meal. When I ordered sour cream to try to make it somewhat edible I was charged an extra $2! The patio decor was rather ugly and creepy. Don't bother trying this place.

If you ever in Sebastopol California, and you want some great Mexican food come to Martha’s the food the service the environment is great. From the sampler platter to the Martha’s old Mexico salad, to your tacos, burritos, enchiladas, they have it. They have a patio in the back, which is so secluded and beautiful, it’s all nature. However, the food is fantastic and delicious. You would love this place while enjoying delicious Mexican food. Always remember, love life, love food, and shut up and eat! #shutupandeat!

This place is a hidden gem!! I can’t believe I’ve not eaten here before today but that is definitely going to change going forward!

As you can gather from my enthusiasm - the food was delicious! They gave me a cup of salsa and a cup of hot beans to start, and both were fabulous! The hot beans were a surprise for me, but were bursting with flavor. I devoured both.

I got the lunch carne asada Colima and ate til I was stuffed… then ate the rest! It was fantastic. I’m already dreaming about going back 🤤🤤🤤

The service was great as well - fast and very friendly.

Nice friendly and good food.

Love Martha's, the first Mexican restaurant I tried in Sebastopol around 20 years ago. Our Cinco de Mayo was festive with a stop in here, try their patio if dining in and make sure to check out their options for self catering your next big party. They are very good at facilitating large parties with togo options for a couple hundred dollars that will feed 20-40 people.

I use to love the fish tacos here! I came for the first time in quite awhile and was truly disappointed in the fish served on the fish tacos! Looked like a frozen fish patty but so thin you barely tasted any fish! Definitely not worth the price which I think is the same as before but was a great piece of fish before!

Super fresh and tasty. Order the Burrito Cancun

Tried this restaurant over the weekend, the presentation of the food was colorful, and delicious. I complimented the chef on his passion for making the plates look full to overflowing, and decoratively delicious! Great value, and great service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The back patio is unique and comfortable.
The food is great! Can't go wrong!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

We love this place and go out of our way to keep coming back! We always sit upstairs in the back dining area where their whimsical open garden is.
Their food is fresh and there’s lots of choices choose from their large menu

Great little spots! Extensive menu options for everyone with dietary restrictions and their burritos were on point.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burrito, Complimentary Chips & Salsa

Service was very slow and exacerbated by the fact it was over 80 degrees inside. I’ve never sweated so much inside of a restaurant before. Food was mediocre to boot.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Complimentary Chips & Salsa

Great food and service. They have a cozy balcony with an open garden or you can stay inside.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Complimentary Chips & Salsa