First time trying Mary's Pizza Shack and really enjoyed it! Pizza was really good, but I especially liked the crust. Nice blend of char, crispy and chewy. I had pepperoni and the sauce and pepperoni had just a little bit of spicy to it that was not spicy but a little more bold than a generic pepperoni pizza.We also had some bread sticks which were good, though slightly under-done. We had the mozzarella garlic bread which I liked better than the bread sticks. My wife had spaghetti with marinara which she really liked. But my favorite was the minestrone soup! Was fantastic! Made with ham hocks it was absolutely delicious. Will be back!
Maria G.
Came to grab take out, got a Mary's entree salad. $15 prices have gone up a little bit. You get more bang for your buck if you dine in. Love this location, they are always so friendly. They accept Apple Pay. For an entree salad you'll get 3 2oz cups of dressing
Randy S.
I have ordered pizza here for probably seven years and I always order the Toto's special. I ordered two medium Toto's on 3/10/22. When I got home and tasted the pizza I noticed the cheese looked and tasted just like a cheese spread. Totally unacceptable. I don't know what has changed but I will not buy that again.
Mrs Iverson
I love coming in and being greeted by the super kind staff. They always make me feel welcomed and the food is bomb! The night crew is the best! Yall are doin perfect! Keep up the great work!
Jammersws
Fantastic service and amazing food! A wonderful aroma meets you in the parking lot and intensifies as you enter. We were greeted promptly and sat immediately. A server quickly arrived at our table and took our drink order. Hot bread and butter basket appeared! We decided to split a large salad and then ordered 2 small specialty pizzas. The salad was perfect - fresh greens, beets, three bean mix, salami, etc. our pizzas arrived promptly and were prepared perfectly. Mary’s never disappoints when it comes to food, service or accommodations. Our “go to” spot in Sebastopol.
Jim M.
Fantastic service and amazing food! A wonderful aroma meets you in the parking lot and intensifies as you enter. We were greeted promptly and sat immediately. A server quickly arrived at our table and took our drink order. Hot bread and butter basket appeared! We decided to split a large salad and then ordered 2 small specialty pizzas. The salad was perfect - fresh greens, beets, three bean mix, salami, etc. our pizzas arrived promptly and were prepared perfectly. Mary's never disappoints when it comes to food, service or accommodations. Our go to spot in Sebastopol.
Catie Fletcher
Great food, good service. What more can you ask for. Thank's Mary's!
Scott Roberts
undercooked pizza, chicken Parmigana burnt, bread sticks super long and thin, pizza sauce, had a different flavor, and the marinara, was watered down...the only thing good was the Salad. spent $100, been going there for years, going to take a break...you should too.
Juan G.
I had a slice of pizza with mushrooms and salami and a Mary's salad this afternoon. Was it great, na. Was it what they said it was? Ya. I don't know what more to say. I took it as a take out order. Is it pizza? Yes. I've had better. Those two items cost 11 dollars. Prices are rising. Yes, I'll probably go there again.
TrippinwSis C.
Met some friends here for lunch. A great local family-run restaurant offering yummy Italian food. Staff was friendly and efficient. Delicious pizza, pasta, salads and more. Even had a good selection of gluten free and vegan options for me! Highly recommend the pesto breadsticks and can't go wrong with any of the specialty pizzas. Thanks and keep up the good work!
Food was okay, the service was so slow. The server said the cooks didn’t hear her call out our pizza so we sat for about 30 minutes before she realized what happened. It took another 30 minutes to get our pizza and our server didn’t really apologize, try to compensate, nothing. She checked in once and then brought our bill. Overall a bad experience.
Donna Jones
Good food. Servers have their favorites.
Elizabeth See
The food was great. Service was even better. Although they offer outdoor seating we chose to be inside to avoid yellow jacket problems. The waitstaff helped us decide that by being truthful about either option.
Madison G.
Got the penne pesto and chicken fettuccine Alfredo. Was not impressed by either. The portion I was given for the penne was not worth the $13 and was neither was the flavor as it was pretty bland. Not sure what Alfredo sauce they use but it looks and tastes like something I've never had before.
Kimberly K.
After a couple of years of not ordering from Mary's I thought it was time to try again. For years they were such an incredible Family style restaurant that was great whether you ate there or ordered to go/ be delivered etc. The last few times I ordered food to go in 2018 and 2019 the orders were totally screwed up. I believe in giving small biz the benefit of the doubt as things happen at times. After being off and closed down for 15 months at last we are open in the same small town of Sebastopol. My coworker and I ordered food to be delivered to our establishment I payed with my credit card and when the order arrived I did not check it, my mistake! The entire order was so screwed up that i will never go there again or let my customers order from there again. I tried calling to avoid putting this online to no avail. so here is my review. I
First time trying Mary's Pizza Shack and really enjoyed it! Pizza was really good, but I especially liked the crust. Nice blend of char, crispy and chewy. I had pepperoni and the sauce and pepperoni had just a little bit of spicy to it that was not spicy but a little more bold than a generic pepperoni pizza.We also had some bread sticks which were good, though slightly under-done. We had the mozzarella garlic bread which I liked better than the bread sticks. My wife had spaghetti with marinara which she really liked. But my favorite was the minestrone soup! Was fantastic! Made with ham hocks it was absolutely delicious. Will be back!
Came to grab take out, got a Mary's entree salad. $15 prices have gone up a little bit. You get more bang for your buck if you dine in. Love this location, they are always so friendly. They accept Apple Pay. For an entree salad you'll get 3 2oz cups of dressing
I have ordered pizza here for probably seven years and I always order the Toto's special. I ordered two medium Toto's on 3/10/22. When I got home and tasted the pizza I noticed the cheese looked and tasted just like a cheese spread. Totally unacceptable. I don't know what has changed but I will not buy that again.
I love coming in and being greeted by the super kind staff. They always make me feel welcomed and the food is bomb! The night crew is the best! Yall are doin perfect! Keep up the great work!
Fantastic service and amazing food! A wonderful aroma meets you in the parking lot and intensifies as you enter. We were greeted promptly and sat immediately. A server quickly arrived at our table and took our drink order. Hot bread and butter basket appeared! We decided to split a large salad and then ordered 2 small specialty pizzas. The salad was perfect - fresh greens, beets, three bean mix, salami, etc. our pizzas arrived promptly and were prepared perfectly. Mary’s never disappoints when it comes to food, service or accommodations. Our “go to” spot in Sebastopol.
Fantastic service and amazing food! A wonderful aroma meets you in the parking lot and intensifies as you enter. We were greeted promptly and sat immediately. A server quickly arrived at our table and took our drink order. Hot bread and butter basket appeared! We decided to split a large salad and then ordered 2 small specialty pizzas. The salad was perfect - fresh greens, beets, three bean mix, salami, etc. our pizzas arrived promptly and were prepared perfectly. Mary's never disappoints when it comes to food, service or accommodations. Our go to spot in Sebastopol.
Great food, good service. What more can you ask for. Thank's Mary's!
undercooked pizza, chicken Parmigana burnt, bread sticks super long and thin, pizza sauce, had a different flavor, and the marinara, was watered down...the only thing good was the Salad. spent $100, been going there for years, going to take a break...you should too.
I had a slice of pizza with mushrooms and salami and a Mary's salad this afternoon. Was it great, na. Was it what they said it was? Ya. I don't know what more to say. I took it as a take out order. Is it pizza? Yes. I've had better. Those two items cost 11 dollars. Prices are rising. Yes, I'll probably go there again.
Met some friends here for lunch. A great local family-run restaurant offering yummy Italian food. Staff was friendly and efficient. Delicious pizza, pasta, salads and more. Even had a good selection of gluten free and vegan options for me! Highly recommend the pesto breadsticks and can't go wrong with any of the specialty pizzas. Thanks and keep up the good work!
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was okay, the service was so slow. The server said the cooks didn’t hear her call out our pizza so we sat for about 30 minutes before she realized what happened. It took another 30 minutes to get our pizza and our server didn’t really apologize, try to compensate, nothing. She checked in once and then brought our bill. Overall a bad experience.
Good food. Servers have their favorites.
The food was great. Service was even better. Although they offer outdoor seating we chose to be inside to avoid yellow jacket problems. The waitstaff helped us decide that by being truthful about either option.
Got the penne pesto and chicken fettuccine Alfredo. Was not impressed by either. The portion I was given for the penne was not worth the $13 and was neither was the flavor as it was pretty bland. Not sure what Alfredo sauce they use but it looks and tastes like something I've never had before.
After a couple of years of not ordering from Mary's I thought it was time to try again. For years they were such an incredible Family style restaurant that was great whether you ate there or ordered to go/ be delivered etc. The last few times I ordered food to go in 2018 and 2019 the orders were totally screwed up. I believe in giving small biz the benefit of the doubt as things happen at times. After being off and closed down for 15 months at last we are open in the same small town of Sebastopol. My coworker and I ordered food to be delivered to our establishment I payed with my credit card and when the order arrived I did not check it, my mistake! The entire order was so screwed up that i will never go there again or let my customers order from there again. I tried calling to avoid putting this online to no avail. so here is my review. I