Two Dog Night Creamery

The ice cream flavor selection is pretty basic. Nothing fancy or unusual, and although I’m well aware of the nitrogen process in making this product, I wouldn’t be able to tell the difference between this and Baskin Robbins. I wanted to sample the lemon poppyseed flavor, but was told they do not do sample anymore because of the “waste” of the wooden sample sticks. However, the ICS (ice cream scooper) informed me that if the ice cream wasn’t to my liking, she would “remake” it for free of charge. I don’t know how throwing out a $6 cup of ice cream is more cost effective than purchasing 1000 wooden or plastic spoons from the dollar store, but I’m not a business owner, and I don’t pretend to be one. Although the dark chocolate peanut butter I got was delicious, this place seems to lack any kind of personality in regards to the flavors available and the service.

I really enjoyed the ice cream here. I had the vegan maple and I tasted the dark chocolate peanut butter. Both were delicious. The staff was really friendly too. Definitely would get ice cream here again.

Amazing ice cream. The salted caramel was so good. My daughter had the creamsicle and wow so good! The banana split is a decent size. We will be back.

Ice cream is decent. No sample spoons is diabolical at an ice cream joint. Also they have one size cone, a giant waffle cone for my child’s one scoop that fell into the depths of this giant cone that she had to eat away to get to the ice cream. If I want ice cream from Sebastopol I’m going to Screaming Mimi’s from now on.

If you're looking for a charming, feel-good spot to satisfy your sweet tooth, this family-owned ice cream shop is a hidden gem. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and the kind of personal service you just can't get at big chains.

The ice cream itself is top-notch—creamy, rich, and clearly made with care. They offer a great variety of classic and creative flavors, many of which rotate regularly, so there's always something new to try. Standouts for me were the homemade waffle cones and their seasonal specials.

What really makes this place special is the love and attention behind everything they do. You can tell the family takes pride in their work, from the quality ingredients to the friendly conversations at the counter. It's the kind of place where kids light up, and adults find a little nostalgic joy.

Highly recommended for a treat that feels both indulgent and heartfelt.

Ice cream was great service left something to be desired

My husband and I got the Snickerdoodle flavored ice cream. Best ice cream I’ve ever had! Can’t wait to go back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

No tasting spoons so no samples. Mid ice cream.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Had vegan cardamom ice cream as well as pb&j flavour which were both great. Nice staff :)

If you care about the organic, velvety, local milk as the main base of your ice-cream, this creamery is your place to go. The best ice-cream in the Bay Area I tried so far, well balanced in terms of sugar and no natural flavors, real ingredients. Stunning ice cream, soooo yummy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good ice cream and fun sundaes! Fundaes?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I love the pineapple ? that's only available in the summer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delicious ice cream

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Foster Crunch

We were there Thursday night and showed up 5 minutes before close. The two guys working were not bothered by this and didn't rush us at all. We ate our ice creams outside the shop. My almost 2yo daughter was walking with her cute little kid cone when she dropped it, ice cream down first. I scrapped the part that hadn't touched the ground to give back to her. I shouldn't have bothered because one of the staff saw, and instantly came over to offer us another cone. While the guys were young, they showed excellent customer service and kept our little girl happy! Thank you guys!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ice cream itself was pretty standard but I would definitely recommend a cup because TWO workers touched my cone with their bare hands which is pretty disgusting for a place with several cash-preferred signs (the girl who scooped it and the cashier). This is interesting because the owner claims below they stopped the sampling spoon practice because it would be unhygienic with real spoons.