Sutter's Mill Restaurant

I love this place low-key family orientated great food at a great price. Always makes me feel like I’m at home or with a family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A very wonderful place to have a great meal and connect with family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

SuttersMills is a hidden gem in Simi Valley. I met with my ckise friends for dinner. I ordered the salmon with stuffed baked potatoes and green beans. The food was very tasty. Green beans we delicious. My friends ordered from tbe 6 Oz Riibeye with baked potatoe. They enjoyed it! And last but least the other ordered a prime rib sandwich with French fries. Lots of meat piled on tbe roll. They had enough for another meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Prime rib is extremely tough. The fat should be soft and edible this was as tough as a hide on the cow. I ordered a salad and since they didn't have balsamic vinegar, I chose the olive oil and vinegar choice, the oil was seed oil not pure olive oil. It was very thin, no color and most importantly there was absolutely no sting in the back of my throat like real pure olive oil does. Which is a complete shame here in California! The green beans were over cooked, soggy and tasteless. Not that I wanted any, but I overheard a couple complain about no bread being offered. I would have expected some bread or buns for a $50.00 meal and that was with just water. Just when I thought it couldn't get worse they gave me a broken pen to sign the check! SMH

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 3

First time here but not my last because everything was perfect.

For my birthday, I ordered the prime rib with baked potato and Mac & cheese. I also had the crab stuffed mushrooms. It was a to-go order which I placed with the bartender who was very kind and helpful. The prime rib was in the top three that I have ever had. All of the food was perfectly prepared and packaged appropriately. The service was great. The prices are very reasonable. The quality is fabulous.

Definitely highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crab Stuffed Mushrooms, Prime Rib Plate w Green Beans and Loaded Baked Potato

The holiday ambience was amazing. The decorations were beautiful. Our server was amazing. The food was fantastic. They also gave me a military discount which was greatly appreciated

It is commendable that Sutter's Mill has stayed open and family-owned for generations. Keeping a restaurant consistent that long is no small feat.

With that in mind, they have certainly stayed consistent, rather than modernizing. This has its pros and cons.

The atmosphere is very homey. Old west, wooden, tall birthday, very cozy. And we went during December; they had thoroughly decorated which was a lovely touch.

The food is alright. Sutter's Mill presents themselves as an upscale steakhouse and I just don't feel that's is exactly correct. It's more like a family restaurant with mood lighting.
Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed my meal. But not necessarily proportional to the quality level they're telegraphing.
My only specific complaint is the salad. It's somewhere in the neighborhood of $5-7, and is just lettuce and roughly chopped tomatoes and cucumbers. And they ask if tomatoes and cucumbers are okay... If you decline, do you literally just get lettuce? It's silly.

However, the service is very friendly and sincere. On top of refills, quick wit, good timing, no complaints at all.

Definitely check out Sutter's Mill; go in expecting cozy rather than elevated and I don't think you'll be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

One of our favorite restaurants in Simi Valley! Great quality food and staff! Prices are very reasonable!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Exceptional service. Outstanding meal. Intimate atmosphere that's not too casual but refined, though parking nearby is limited. If I'm town I would dine here again.

The food was excellent. Nice variety of steaks and a few seafood options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great service in the upper section. Ask for it💯 The meats are to die for. Prime Rib, Rib Eye, Filet, all are cooked to perfection. Love, love, LOVE this place💯🌴

For as much noise that has been the great steak house, it was a great disappointment. The service was slow and lengthy, the food was 1/2 way decent for the price. I have had better prime rib at Black Bear restaurant. This is one of those experiences one goes trough, but one does remember not to go back even if invited. I would not recommend this place to people I like, but a great place to send people you don't like. It's just not worth it.

Great service, fantastic meal, Luther was a great Server, I didn't get the name of the Bartender but, she was super nice and very cordial. Good Times ...

To serve in the same spot, with the same spirit, since 1958 — for 67 years — is not just admirable, it’s a quiet triumph. It tells its own story: of consistency, care, and character. The choice of the name Sutter’s Mill is no coincidence; it echoes with the very roots of California’s bold beginnings — a subtle nod to legacy.

Over the years, we’ve brought many guests to your doors, and each time, we’ve found the same charm: a graceful blend of old-school warmth, elegant décor, and service that still remembers the value of attentiveness.

Sutter’s Mill isn’t just a restaurant — it’s a keeper of tradition in a world that rushes to forget. Please, carry this torch forward, untouched by fleeting trends, and keep shining for at least another 67 years.

Thank you. 🤌🏻🫶🏻

A great, long-time, local neighborhood steakhouse. Comforting food and drinks with cozy booths. Their famous prime rib is juicy and tender. The au jus sauce was so flavorful. I forgot to take a picture of our 8 ounce Prime Rib with sides mac n cheese and steak fries- because we ate it up so quickly lol. Sorry guys, my bad!
But we also had Shrimp Cocktail and Crab Stuffed Mushrooms. They were both very delicious!
We sat at the bar. Go see Carrie at the bar. She’ll take good care of you. Thank you all!