The Batter Up Bakery

Maybe I went on a bad day but I ordered about 4 different desserts and they were dry

Best place to hang out have coffee and deserts.

Lisa is great and her cakes are delicious. Definitely recommend

In the words of Ned Flanders of Simpsons fame, “Scrump-dilly-umptious!” I was so nervous about flying in from Chicago and ruining a surprise for a friend whose birthday falls on a holiday, July 4, when a lot of businesses are understandably closed. But the folks at Batter Up Bakery made logistics seamless when I wasn’t able to pick up the cake during business hours. They were able to deliver a fresh custom cake to the restaurant for a very low fee. My buddy thanked me for what he called one of the best birthdays he’s had in a long time. Batter Up Bakery helped make that possible.

Disappointed by the Experience, Despite Good Intentions

We recently went wedding cake tasting while visiting from out of town. Our aunt, who generously wanted to treat us to this experience, chose the bakery and arranged the outing as a thoughtful gesture. Unfortunately, she didn’t realize a reservation was required, and we completely understood that we might not be able to be accommodated on the spot.

We politely asked if we could purchase a to-go wedding tasting box and follow up with our order details via email. While trying to be as flexible and low-maintenance as possible, we still felt that we were met with visible annoyance and a lack of warmth from the staff. Despite this, we chose to stay and try the cakes in-store, especially since our aunt was excited about the shop’s fun, themed interior. Sadly, even as we sat and ate, we felt watched and unwelcome, as if our presence was inconvenient.

One team member mentioned that the wedding cake coordinator might have a 30-minute to 1-hour gap between appointments and could possibly speak with us. We took that as a pleasant surprise and waited patiently. When she did meet with us, however, the interaction felt rushed and dismissive. Rather than listening to what we envisioned for our wedding cake, the focus seemed more on how young we were, with little opportunity for real discussion or customization.

Later, when we called to request a simple design change, we were told it couldn’t be done. We understand policies and timelines, but the change wasn’t drastic—it didn’t seem like something that should’ve been denied so firmly.

Overall, what should’ve been a sweet and meaningful experience, especially for our aunt, turned into something that left us feeling disregarded. As my wedding day approaches, it’s unfortunate that this part of the planning process brings feelings of disappointment.

Amazingly moist cakes. Friendly service. Owner is very helpful.

Beautiful design, taste great and I loved the filling. Highly recommended 10/10.

Ordered Gingerbread Men and a Yule Log for a Christmastime gathering- what a HIT! Best Yule Log for flavor and presentation and the Gingerbread Men were unbelievably good!
I highly recommend this bakery!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wedding and Baby Shower

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I would give this place a 0 star if I could. I frequent this place and order cakes all the time. They’ve cancelled on me twice. Don’t put your trust into this place especially if it’s for an important event like your kids birthday. I wasn’t given 24 hours to pay for my order to be canceled due to their short staff. The incompetent employee that told me this was rude and had no regard. Don’t waste your time with this place at all

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The best cake shop with the freshest ingredients. Highly impressed!!!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very clean place . Highly recommend.

Excellent service 👍👍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The cakes are delicious and beautifully made. Love this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was out of town and made an order for a birthday cake for my husband over the phone. Batter Up Bakery met every need and went above and beyond. The cake was absolutely delicious, hands down, the best cake I’ve ever had to be honest. Now let’s get to the design. How stunning is this cake?! I wanted something grown, sexy, and manly. Thank you Batter Uo Bakery.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake