Casa Tua is quietly firing on all cylinders right now. Same intimate, late-night Aspen energy, but noticeably smoother across the board. Food is on point, pacing is dialed, and the service feels relaxed, confident, and genuinely hospitable.
You can tell the restaurant is being run by someone who understands both the food and the people. Staff seems supported, nothing feels forced, and the experience just flows the way it should.
If you know, you know—Casa Tua is in a really good place right now.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lorena Bordan
Casa Tua Aspen never misses. As a local who was just recently in Rome, I can confidently say the food here is truly top notch—authentic, refined, and full of soul. The pistachio ice cream in particular took me straight back to Italy… honestly Rome-level good. What really elevated the night was the service—Bobby from Macedonia was exceptional. Warm, attentive, and genuinely made my friends and I feel taken care of without ever hovering. This is the kind of place that delivers both world-class food and world-class hospitality. Can’t wait to be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Naomi Beyrut
January 31st at 5:30 PM, we arrived with a reservation that was not showing as “verified.” The initial interaction with the hostess was rude, dismissive, and unhelpful. She offered no solutions and insisted on speaking English despite clearly understanding Spanish, which made me feel discriminated against and poorly treated.
Thankfully, another hostess was professional and kind, found us a table, and from that moment on the service and food were excellent.
Casa Tua is an excellent restaurant, but the host staff should be at the same level and treat guests with the same excellence as the rest of the experience.
Michelle Gutierrez
OMG! I AM BEYOND APPRECIATIVE FOR HOW NANCY WAS ABLE TO ACCOMMODATE MY RESERVATION. I AM EXTREMELY GRATEFUL FOR HER SWIFT AND PROFESSIONAL MANNER, SHE MADE THE IMPOSSIBLE POSSIBLE! I COULDN'T BE MORE HAPPY. THANK YOU NANCY HERNANDEZ!
Service: 5
CharlesTexian
Legendary for a reason!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Billy Chocallo
Absolutely wonderful experience. The sole was great. I never thought pistachio ice cream and sublime would ever occur in a sentence, but I was wrong. An amazing dessert!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Schiffer
I don't give restaurant reviews often...because the experience these days just doesn't measure up...most of the time. Well, Casa Tua is an exception! The eggplant was the best I have ever had. The pasta seemed homemade, thick and cooked perfectly. The prime beef was beautifully seared. Slicing it was interesting and maybe allowed it to cool to quickly. My wife and daughter loved their gin drinks and my Old Fashion was classic and tasty. Service was spot on and spotting Justin Bieber in the corner was a goof.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anzhelika Tolstikhina
The experience, food and service was so good that im even taking time to write this review! Thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jill Burke
I have visited Casa Tua multiple times and have never had a bad experience until now. As soon as we were seated the hostess requested my fiance take his hat off - fine. We then proceeded to watch 3 other tables sit, all with various hats on - beanies etc. extremely rude to discriminate to one party then not apply your rules to the rest. Service was terrible. We saw two workers fighting with each other right next to us. Food was delicious but pasta was extremely al dente even coming from someone who loves al dented pasta. Ravioli came out very cold and the waiter did nothing to make it right. Worst experience I’ve had in a long time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Kiana Do
Excellent vibe, awesome location with mountain views. Negroni’s were great!
I really enjoyed my experience at this restaurant. The food was great and the service was excellent. A special thanks to the manager, Jorge, who was very friendly and made sure everything was perfect. I would definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Insta Painting
Excellent experience!! From the host and the Manager at the front , accommodating us, to our waitress Tatiana with great recommendations and our server Pedro who was very nice and attentive. They truly made us feel right at home. Everyone that works there seems to know how to make their guests feel special. Plus the food was great! This restaurant is worth every penny!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marcela Walsh
One of our favorites restaurants in Aspen and New York! The service, food and ambience are all excellent! Happy Holidays to all the wonderful staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ana Estrada
Horrible service. We waited over 40 minutes before our order was taken, and then another 30 minutes just to receive our drinks. The food was average at best and certainly nothing memorable. Overall, the experience was extremely disappointing and nothing like Casa Tua in Miami or NYC. To make matters worse, our waitress was very rude and made no effort to understand or accommodate our needs. We left very dissatisfied.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Adrianna Blanchet
I’ve been going to Casa Tua’s multiple locations for a long time, and it has become an anniversary tradition for me and my boyfriend to go to the Miami location. This year however we decided to have our anniversary dinner in Aspen instead.
One thing that we found off-putting was that when we asked the hostess if she could take our coats, she took mine but refused to take my boyfriends for some reason. Secondly, as I’ve mentioned, we’ve had many anniversary dinners at Casa Tua Miami and their attention to detail is always on point— rose petals scattered on the table, a “happy anniversary” message with our desert; these were all lacking during our Aspen visit.
That being said the food was excellent as expected. Drinks were good as well; I enjoyed their special Casa Tua gin and tonic. The pasta was perfectly cooked and you can tell it’s homemade. The beef tenderloin with foie gras is one of my favorites, I order it every time; while it was excellent and perfectly medium-rare as well, I did notice that the sauce was broken.
Coats aside, the service was generally good but nothing special. Our waiter was very polite but at times it did feel like we were being rushed.
The space is not as cozy as the Miami location, which is to be expected as the Miami is the original “casa”😅, but the decor is very chic. The atmosphere might’ve been perfect if the dress code was enforced… (hoodies, baseball caps, etc.)
Overall, we enjoyed our dinner. Though for a nice restaurant with a high price tag, I would expect more as the restaurant holds sentimental value to me and I have experienced better.
Casa Tua is quietly firing on all cylinders right now. Same intimate, late-night Aspen energy, but noticeably smoother across the board. Food is on point, pacing is dialed, and the service feels relaxed, confident, and genuinely hospitable.
You can tell the restaurant is being run by someone who understands both the food and the people. Staff seems supported, nothing feels forced, and the experience just flows the way it should.
If you know, you know—Casa Tua is in a really good place right now.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Casa Tua Aspen never misses. As a local who was just recently in Rome, I can confidently say the food here is truly top notch—authentic, refined, and full of soul. The pistachio ice cream in particular took me straight back to Italy… honestly Rome-level good.
What really elevated the night was the service—Bobby from Macedonia was exceptional. Warm, attentive, and genuinely made my friends and I feel taken care of without ever hovering. This is the kind of place that delivers both world-class food and world-class hospitality. Can’t wait to be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
January 31st at 5:30 PM, we arrived with a reservation that was not showing as “verified.” The initial interaction with the hostess was rude, dismissive, and unhelpful. She offered no solutions and insisted on speaking English despite clearly understanding Spanish, which made me feel discriminated against and poorly treated.
Thankfully, another hostess was professional and kind, found us a table, and from that moment on the service and food were excellent.
Casa Tua is an excellent restaurant, but the host staff should be at the same level and treat guests with the same excellence as the rest of the experience.
OMG! I AM BEYOND APPRECIATIVE FOR HOW NANCY WAS ABLE TO ACCOMMODATE MY RESERVATION. I AM EXTREMELY GRATEFUL FOR HER SWIFT AND PROFESSIONAL MANNER, SHE MADE THE IMPOSSIBLE POSSIBLE! I COULDN'T BE MORE HAPPY. THANK YOU NANCY HERNANDEZ!
Service: 5
Legendary for a reason!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely wonderful experience. The sole was great. I never thought pistachio ice cream and sublime would ever occur in a sentence, but I was wrong. An amazing dessert!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don't give restaurant reviews often...because the experience these days just doesn't measure up...most of the time. Well, Casa Tua is an exception! The eggplant was the best I have ever had. The pasta seemed homemade, thick and cooked perfectly. The prime beef was beautifully seared. Slicing it was interesting and maybe allowed it to cool to quickly. My wife and daughter loved their gin drinks and my Old Fashion was classic and tasty. Service was spot on and spotting Justin Bieber in the corner was a goof.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
The experience, food and service was so good that im even taking time to write this review! Thank you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have visited Casa Tua multiple times and have never had a bad experience until now. As soon as we were seated the hostess requested my fiance take his hat off - fine. We then proceeded to watch 3 other tables sit, all with various hats on - beanies etc. extremely rude to discriminate to one party then not apply your rules to the rest. Service was terrible. We saw two workers fighting with each other right next to us. Food was delicious but pasta was extremely al dente even coming from someone who loves al dented pasta. Ravioli came out very cold and the waiter did nothing to make it right. Worst experience I’ve had in a long time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Excellent vibe, awesome location with mountain views. Negroni’s were great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
I really enjoyed my experience at this restaurant. The food was great and the service was excellent. A special thanks to the manager, Jorge, who was very friendly and made sure everything was perfect. I would definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent experience!! From the host and the Manager at the front , accommodating us, to our waitress Tatiana with great recommendations and our server Pedro who was very nice and attentive. They truly made us feel right at home. Everyone that works there seems to know how to make their guests feel special. Plus the food was great! This restaurant is worth every penny!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of our favorites restaurants in Aspen and New York! The service, food and ambience are all excellent!
Happy Holidays to all the wonderful staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Horrible service. We waited over 40 minutes before our order was taken, and then another 30 minutes just to receive our drinks. The food was average at best and certainly nothing memorable. Overall, the experience was extremely disappointing and nothing like Casa Tua in Miami or NYC. To make matters worse, our waitress was very rude and made no effort to understand or accommodate our needs. We left very dissatisfied.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
I’ve been going to Casa Tua’s multiple locations for a long time, and it has become an anniversary tradition for me and my boyfriend to go to the Miami location. This year however we decided to have our anniversary dinner in Aspen instead.
One thing that we found off-putting was that when we asked the hostess if she could take our coats, she took mine but refused to take my boyfriends for some reason. Secondly, as I’ve mentioned, we’ve had many anniversary dinners at Casa Tua Miami and their attention to detail is always on point— rose petals scattered on the table, a “happy anniversary” message with our desert; these were all lacking during our Aspen visit.
That being said the food was excellent as expected. Drinks were good as well; I enjoyed their special Casa Tua gin and tonic. The pasta was perfectly cooked and you can tell it’s homemade. The beef tenderloin with foie gras is one of my favorites, I order it every time; while it was excellent and perfectly medium-rare as well, I did notice that the sauce was broken.
Coats aside, the service was generally good but nothing special. Our waiter was very polite but at times it did feel like we were being rushed.
The space is not as cozy as the Miami location, which is to be expected as the Miami is the original “casa”😅, but the decor is very chic. The atmosphere might’ve been perfect if the dress code was enforced… (hoodies, baseball caps, etc.)
Overall, we enjoyed our dinner. Though for a nice restaurant with a high price tag, I would expect more as the restaurant holds sentimental value to me and I have experienced better.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Loading...