Cottage Creations Custom Confections

We ordered a cake a month in advance, and we asked for a very specific item. My daughter was excited to get her dream cake. She'd sent a picture of exactly what she wanted so there would be no surprises.
We received a two layer cake frosted and decorated in stickers! Edible stickers. No butterflies made of frosting, no marzipan whale, flat frosting with a cookie on a stick, edible whale sticker.
The real fun began when we served the cake. Tasted off. Odd flavor, nobody ate it. See attached picture.
Lady knew we were picking up the cake on the 21st, at the last minute, with a snowstorm impending, she told us we'd have to pickup before 11a.m., or after 3. She isn't convenient, she is twelve miles off the main road. She had made another appointment to deliver another order. We weren't a priority.
Terrible disappointment for $80.00 spent.
This is a bakery she runs out of her small house in Bailey.
Would not recommend. Inconvenient drive, no customer service, high price for the bum's rush we got, she met us in her driveway with the box and ran, and we'd given her a clear picture, and a month to get it right.
We didn't spend enough money to get her best work.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Had my wedding cake and cupcakes done here. They were FANTASTIC! I wish I had better pics for cupcakes, they were so cute and gorgeous. Looked like REAL flowers on top. Lisa was great to work with throughout the whole process (was a destination wedding of sorts). The project was reasonably priced. Cakes were moist and delicious. Frosting was very good. Was delivered to my venue with zero issues. They did a perfect job of bringing my dream cake to life! It matched my wedding vibe, colors, and venue perfectly. Picture speaks for itself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lisa did a great job on our cake and cupcakes. She delivered on time to Conifer. Would highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Cottage Creations made our daughter’s birthday cake dreams come true! Not only was it beautiful, it tasted incredible!

Lisa was awesome! I ordered a paw print cake and the sheep cupcakes (from her photos) to pick up while my family and I were staying in Bailey. Very cute and yummy!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Birthday Cake

I am a chef based in #aspen Colorado and have many high end clients who love desserts. I used Lisa for the first time with a group of 20 and she delivered the most delicious and creative cakes I’ve had in years. Fast forward a year later and she continues to provide an outstanding product that not only tastes incredible but is visually fantastic ! I highly recommend #cottagecreationcakes

We received beautiful and delicious cupcakes for our daughter's birthday party!

Great price and birthday cake

I ordered a cake for my grandma's Celebration of Life party. It was absolutely beautiful and delicious! I will definitely order from this business again. Highly recommend!

We’re from out of state and we decided to travel to Bailey for my daughters birthday and to visit family. I always bake my daughters cakes because she’s so picky, but I didn’t take into account the elevation the night before when I tried baking her cake layers, and had an emergency the morning of her birthday so I realized I wouldn’t even have time to try again. Which… her birthday also fell on a Friday and a holiday weekend. I contacted her the morning of her birthday and asked for whatever is easy since I knew I needed it at the last minute and it would be cutting it close. I didn’t even expect anything but a very simple cake because of time, but she even asked my daughter’s favorite colors for the happy birthday and added sparkles which she loved! It tasted so good, was so adorable, and was definitely better than anything I could have done! ? I can’t even explain how grateful I am!

Pictures do not do justice, the cake was so beautiful and so delicious.

Our Nightmare Before Christmas birthday cake was divine! ...and that silky orange cream frosting against the moist chocolate cake - OUT OF THIS WORLD! I wish I'd thought to grab pic to share

Our wedding cake was absolutely stunning! We had a small hiccup, but Lisa handled everything so perfectly and we had the most beautiful cake! I highly recommend! She was super thorough and responsive throughout the entirety of my planning. I could not have asked for a more perfect cake, I can’t stress this enough. Thank you for making our day stress free and handling everything so professionally! We appreciate you!

Our wedding cake was absolutely stunning! We had a small hiccup, but Lisa handled everything so perfectly and we had the most beautiful cake! I highly recommend! She was super thorough and responsive throughout the entirety of my planning. I could not have asked for a more perfect cake, I can’t stress this enough. Thank you for making our day stress free and handling everything so professionally! We appreciate you!

We love getting cakes and other treats from here! She always does a great job and they taste wonderful! She is so easy to work with and really makes the entire design process go so smoothly! I highly recommend getting your next cake from them. You won't be disappointed!