Colorado is not known for their pizza, BUT this location of Anthony’s pizza is the BEST ONE I’ve had since I’ve lived here. Been in Colorado for 2 years. I’m originally from Buffalo NY area. Best pizza in the world is Buffalo NY, then Brooklyn NY (little Italy area).
Nonetheless. Pizza restaurants need to study how this location makes their slices specifically. I judge pizza places by their slices first and then main pizza. If you can’t make a great slice, how can you even call yourself a true pizza place? lol 🤣
Great place to get a slice. That’s what I’m vouching for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
John Taylor
Called to order 1 large cheese, and 1 large sausage/pepperoni, was told it would be 15-20 minutes and it actually was over 30, no big deal. The big deal was that they charged me $64 dollars plus 15% tip on pickup, and there are more ingredients on a frozen totinos pizza. Taste was good but 2 inches of crust and 2 oz of cheese a little sauce, 10 pepperoni, 10 small chunks of sausage. They probably spent $3 dollars on the cheese and $4 on the pepperoni/sausage. WHAT A RIP OFF!! Not anything like the Anthony's on 112th and Colorado. They text me coupons once a week and the pies are 100% better. Drive a little farther and get it for half the price!! Will NEVER order from this Anthony's again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Barry Ennis
Salads were wonderful. Very fresh. Service was good..just know it's counter order, but they do bring it contour table when ready. No complaints. Great plac e so far. We have a few other menu items we want to try, so we will be back
Dustin
7.2 on my DP scale. Good crispy thin crust, lacking a little in the flavor department on the cheese. Also a little too much sauce for my perfect pizza. Still easily the best pizza in town, and will be back!
Valerie Aragon
Horrible behavior!! I was dine in on Saturday, too see something very disappointing..I was going to let it go, but it's just not sitting well with me. As I was waiting for my order, the little worker, was on the phone taking an order...when another worker about in her 50's, grab a piece of paper, crumbing it up, and tossing it at the little worker that was on the phone. It was completely uncalled for, very disrespectful and unprofessional in so many ways. The worker that was on the phone handled it very professionally. She continued to finish her phone call. I could see she was holding back tears.. I will never eat or order from this restaurant again. The owner needs to be notified, and something needs to be done. I will be reporting this to corporate. Nobody should ever mistreat others in the work place. This behavior is unreasonable..
Joseph Vespoli
Great food Great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diane
Side salads were tiny. Pizza had hardly any toppings. I expected more for $50+ dollars.
Keith Oetken
I wasn’t expecting it to be more of a fast food type of place, but I was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the food. The people were very friendly. It was a little expensive, but overall a good meal.
Shawna Lind
Seriously this establishment should just shut down. Cannot service their customers properly and honestly just a joke. High priced mediocre food when you get it. Save yourself a headache and order some place else!
Rodney Sanchez
The Best Anthony’s in town. The staff is always friendly and the food is always great and made correctly.
I work right next door at 3s bar and I don't ever get sick of it. Best in town with great portion size. Ooh amazing garlic knots!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza
Marc Bolduc
Ordered a large 18” pizza last night. The other comments were correct the company website is not good. Hard to navigate, buttons in odd places, very few pre built pizza prices are accurate. So we decided to call in. The lady who answered the phone sounded like she’d rather be getting a root canal than answer the phone. After reading reviews this was a shaky start. Nonetheless the pizza came out correct. Overall the cook on the pizza was perfect. It didn’t fit in the box (see photo) and so was folded over on one end tasted just as good! The toppings were on the lite side and I would have preferred a bit more cheese but all in all the fresh mushrooms, Canadian bacon, and pepperoni were very tasty. The crust bone was pretty good as well we did find ourselves wishing we had ordered a side of sauce (suggesting that during our order would have increased ticket total)
I had not eaten here in over a decade and it was a marked improvement from my last recollection.
Price wise a lot of others have commented how steep it is. I agree the price isn’t a bargain by any stretch. However, real dough, fresh meat and veggies do stand out above the chains. Not to mention a crust worth eating. So many of the others soak the crust in soybean/ butter alternatives and it’s gross!
While I did not dine in, I did wait in the restaurant for about 10min (I was early not the stores fault) Looking around I don’t think I would want to eat in this place. The floor was neglected for quite some time. Many of the tables had crumbs and grease from dinners. Many of the chairs and booths are well past needing to be recovered. The condiments sitting on the tables around me were all in need of cleaning from previous dinners. There was enough light to see even tho the bulbs were all different colors and it was warm in there on a cold day which was nice to wait in.
All in all we will likely be back for takeout of this special treat.
Note: Both the young guys in the store were extremely friendly and accommodating even offering a soft drink while they finished the cooking.
Parking: There isn’t too much parking but it wasn’t too busy when I went.
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes wheel in ramps and single level floor.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Bob Ross
Not the best pizza kinda pricey but ok would not go there again
Megan Bentzoni
Don't ever ask for half cheese, they will interpret that as half no cheese. After waiting an hour for delivery I got the pizza cold and put my own cheese on it and cooked it in the oven. The manager on duty said in order to get a refund I'd need to bring it back in the store so they could see it but I could get 10 percent off my next order. I paid 46 dollars for a cold medium pizza with half the ingredients and I cooked it myself with my own ingredients. Very poor customer service. Never again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ruthie Baldrey
We were craving pizza and decided to stop at Anthony’s because my husband had it in the past. We found the menu a bit confusing, most pizza joints have multiple “suggested “ pizza combinations but Anthony’s did not. I guess as of Nov 1st they started 3-4 suggested pizza options, what I found weird was we couldn’t change the red sauce for the white sauce. We opted for a large so we could have leftovers. Little did we know the large would be bigger than my husband. This would have been great if the pizza had flavor. Really, the only strong flavor in the pizza was the green peppers. The sauce wasn’t that good, the crust really didn’t taste like anything, and the meats were just blah. There are so many other pizza choices that I will not be going back.
Colorado is not known for their pizza, BUT this location of Anthony’s pizza is the BEST ONE I’ve had since I’ve lived here. Been in Colorado for 2 years. I’m originally from Buffalo NY area. Best pizza in the world is Buffalo NY, then Brooklyn NY (little Italy area).
Nonetheless. Pizza restaurants need to study how this location makes their slices specifically. I judge pizza places by their slices first and then main pizza. If you can’t make a great slice, how can you even call yourself a true pizza place? lol 🤣
Great place to get a slice. That’s what I’m vouching for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Called to order 1 large cheese, and 1 large sausage/pepperoni, was told it would be 15-20 minutes and it actually was over 30, no big deal. The big deal was that they charged me $64 dollars plus 15% tip on pickup, and there are more ingredients on a frozen totinos pizza. Taste was good but 2 inches of crust and 2 oz of cheese a little sauce, 10 pepperoni, 10 small chunks of sausage. They probably spent $3 dollars on the cheese and $4 on the pepperoni/sausage. WHAT A RIP OFF!!
Not anything like the Anthony's on 112th and Colorado. They text me coupons once a week and the pies are 100% better. Drive a little farther and get it for half the price!!
Will NEVER order from this Anthony's again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Salads were wonderful. Very fresh.
Service was good..just know it's counter order, but they do bring it contour table when ready.
No complaints. Great plac
e so far.
We have a few other menu items we want to try, so we will be back
7.2 on my DP scale. Good crispy thin crust, lacking a little in the flavor department on the cheese. Also a little too much sauce for my perfect pizza. Still easily the best pizza in town, and will be back!
Horrible behavior!! I was dine in on Saturday, too see something very disappointing..I was going to let it go, but it's just not sitting well with me. As I was waiting for my order, the little worker, was on the phone taking an order...when another worker about in her 50's, grab a piece of paper, crumbing it up, and tossing it at the little worker that was on the phone. It was completely uncalled for, very disrespectful and unprofessional in so many ways. The worker that was on the phone handled it very professionally. She continued to finish her phone call. I could see she was holding back tears.. I will never eat or order from this restaurant again. The owner needs to be notified, and something needs to be done. I will be reporting this to corporate. Nobody should ever mistreat others in the work place. This behavior is unreasonable..
Great food Great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Side salads were tiny. Pizza had hardly any toppings. I expected more for $50+ dollars.
I wasn’t expecting it to be more of a fast food type of place, but I was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the food. The people were very friendly. It was a little expensive, but overall a good meal.
Seriously this establishment should just shut down. Cannot service their customers properly and honestly just a joke. High priced mediocre food when you get it. Save yourself a headache and order some place else!
The Best Anthony’s in town. The staff is always friendly and the food is always great and made correctly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Salads
Restaurantji Recommends
I work right next door at 3s bar and I don't ever get sick of it. Best in town with great portion size. Ooh amazing garlic knots!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza
Ordered a large 18” pizza last night. The other comments were correct the company website is not good. Hard to navigate, buttons in odd places, very few pre built pizza prices are accurate.
So we decided to call in.
The lady who answered the phone sounded like she’d rather be getting a root canal than answer the phone. After reading reviews this was a shaky start.
Nonetheless the pizza came out correct.
Overall the cook on the pizza was perfect. It didn’t fit in the box (see photo) and so was folded over on one end tasted just as good! The toppings were on the lite side and I would have preferred a bit more cheese but all in all the fresh mushrooms, Canadian bacon, and pepperoni were very tasty. The crust bone was pretty good as well we did find ourselves wishing we had ordered a side of sauce (suggesting that during our order would have increased ticket total)
I had not eaten here in over a decade and it was a marked improvement from my last recollection.
Price wise a lot of others have commented how steep it is. I agree the price isn’t a bargain by any stretch. However, real dough, fresh meat and veggies do stand out above the chains. Not to mention a crust worth eating. So many of the others soak the crust in soybean/ butter alternatives and it’s gross!
While I did not dine in, I did wait in the restaurant for about 10min (I was early not the stores fault)
Looking around I don’t think I would want to eat in this place. The floor was neglected for quite some time. Many of the tables had crumbs and grease from dinners. Many of the chairs and booths are well past needing to be recovered. The condiments sitting on the tables around me were all in need of cleaning from previous dinners. There was enough light to see even tho the bulbs were all different colors and it was warm in there on a cold day which was nice to wait in.
All in all we will likely be back for takeout of this special treat.
Note: Both the young guys in the store were extremely friendly and accommodating even offering a soft drink while they finished the cooking.
Parking: There isn’t too much parking but it wasn’t too busy when I went.
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes wheel in ramps and single level floor.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Not the best pizza kinda pricey but ok would not go there again
Don't ever ask for half cheese, they will interpret that as half no cheese. After waiting an hour for delivery I got the pizza cold and put my own cheese on it and cooked it in the oven. The manager on duty said in order to get a refund I'd need to bring it back in the store so they could see it but I could get 10 percent off my next order. I paid 46 dollars for a cold medium pizza with half the ingredients and I cooked it myself with my own ingredients. Very poor customer service. Never again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We were craving pizza and decided to stop at Anthony’s because my husband had it in the past. We found the menu a bit confusing, most pizza joints have multiple “suggested “ pizza combinations but Anthony’s did not. I guess as of Nov 1st they started 3-4 suggested pizza options, what I found weird was we couldn’t change the red sauce for the white sauce. We opted for a large so we could have leftovers. Little did we know the large would be bigger than my husband. This would have been great if the pizza had flavor. Really, the only strong flavor in the pizza was the green peppers. The sauce wasn’t that good, the crust really didn’t taste like anything, and the meats were just blah. There are so many other pizza choices that I will not be going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loading...