I've been sick for 2 days from this place. RUN AWAY!
Food: 1
Colorado Auto Tint
Very good pie, love it!Update:They just deliver, 10 out of 10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Tomer
Best pie in castle rock. Being from NY I just can't give 5 stars but it's comparable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Heather Harbinson
Our salad had a bug in it and our pizza was made with olives instead of green chili. We have had other issues in the past as well.
Food: 1
Paul Jones
So we ordered a large pepperoni... For the two of us... What came to our table was the largest pepperoni pizza I have ever seen. Which caused us to be self-conscious because I felt like the other customers thought we were going to scarf this whole thing down like a pizza challenge.We had two big slices, took the rest home ate on it for maybe two years and have not been back... NOT because the food was bad.. Just because we are still full as is is pretty delicious!Just ask about sizes before you order... Just sayin'
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Medium Cheese Pizza
Michael & Sherry Wright
It was alright—not bad, but I’ve definitely had better. I had a slice of the Neapolitan and a slice of the white, but they came out a bit bland. We salvaged the experience with several dashes of salt and pepper.
David Papadimitrio
Decided to give Anthony's a try after 2+ years (quality and service declined back then). Was desperate for a local, easy to pick up pizza. Tied the online ap twice now, and it works great, easy to order, pick up time stated and pies were ready at that time, not certain of new owners, but really happy with food and service. Will be back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Johansen
Came in at 2:00 PM on Friday. One person was waiting for an order. The person at the counter ignored us for about two minutes while he was talking with the guy in the back. When we got his attention he just pointed to a computer ordering screen on the counter. My wife asked if that was even if we were dining in. He simply pointed at the screen again. This is new. We have come to this location for years for decent NY style pies. But, we certainly don't appreciate whatever has motivated the ownership to move to a screen and a totally disengaged counterperson. This sure isn't what we expect in Castle Pines. We went over to Tony's and picked up some of their always good "to go" food. Message to Owner: You're probably engaged in the fast food drive to apps and online ordering. That probably makes some sort of sense in eliminating human error. Perhaps it's cost effective in some manner. But, you really need to do a little motivational training for the staff.
Good pizza fresh veggies in the salad and quick service?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darlene L.
The Customer service is good and the employees are respectful and nice. The pizza and calzones are really good. We have gone there several times with a family of over 15 and they always accommodate us and are real friendly toward our entire party. We have had delivary service as well and we have always been pleased.
Stacie
Please know, I’ve never left a one star review before, nor a bad review, but I feel this one is important. This is the most over priced pizza I’ve ever encountered. All I can say is it’s pizza. It’s not exceptional pizza. 20$ for a small cheese pizza and 2$/ topping after? Really? I hope you don’t like any vegetables on your pizza. Even by the slice you pay an additional 1$/topping. Get over yourselves. I’d rather order dominos and sacrifice quality instead of feeling assaulted. Yes, everybody has raised their prices, but you are taking FULL advantage. It’s ridiculous. And the reviews are telling. As residents of CPV, we will not support your business anymore.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Stacie J.
Please know, I've never left a one star review before, nor a bad review, but I feel this one is important. This is the most over priced pizza I've ever encountered. All I can say is it's pizza. It's not exceptional pizza. 20$ for a small cheese pizza and 2$/ topping after? Really? I hope you don't like any vegetables on your pizza. Even by the slice you pay an additional 1$/topping. Get over yourselves. I'd rather order dominos and sacrifice quality instead of feeling assaulted. Yes, everybody has raised their prices, but you are taking FULL advantage. It's ridiculous. And the reviews are telling. As residents of CPV, we will not support your business anymore.
Joe Costa
Pizza is always excellent, staff is always super friendly, delivery is always fast and hot out of the oven! Couldn’t ask for a better place!
Absolutely superb service. Great food. Decent portions for the price.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan, Chicken Alfredo
Our go to pizza delivery spot! Staff is always friendly and food is great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Sicilian, Buffalo Wings
I've been sick for 2 days from this place. RUN AWAY!
Food: 1
Very good pie, love it!Update:They just deliver, 10 out of 10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pie in castle rock. Being from NY I just can't give 5 stars but it's comparable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Our salad had a bug in it and our pizza was made with olives instead of green chili. We have had other issues in the past as well.
Food: 1
So we ordered a large pepperoni... For the two of us... What came to our table was the largest pepperoni pizza I have ever seen. Which caused us to be self-conscious because I felt like the other customers thought we were going to scarf this whole thing down like a pizza challenge.We had two big slices, took the rest home ate on it for maybe two years and have not been back... NOT because the food was bad.. Just because we are still full as is is pretty delicious!Just ask about sizes before you order... Just sayin'
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Medium Cheese Pizza
It was alright—not bad, but I’ve definitely had better. I had a slice of the Neapolitan and a slice of the white, but they came out a bit bland. We salvaged the experience with several dashes of salt and pepper.
Decided to give Anthony's a try after 2+ years (quality and service declined back then). Was desperate for a local, easy to pick up pizza. Tied the online ap twice now, and it works great, easy to order, pick up time stated and pies were ready at that time, not certain of new owners, but really happy with food and service. Will be back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came in at 2:00 PM on Friday. One person was waiting for an order. The person at the counter ignored us for about two minutes while he was talking with the guy in the back. When we got his attention he just pointed to a computer ordering screen on the counter. My wife asked if that was even if we were dining in. He simply pointed at the screen again. This is new. We have come to this location for years for decent NY style pies. But, we certainly don't appreciate whatever has motivated the ownership to move to a screen and a totally disengaged counterperson. This sure isn't what we expect in Castle Pines. We went over to Tony's and picked up some of their always good "to go" food. Message to Owner: You're probably engaged in the fast food drive to apps and online ordering. That probably makes some sort of sense in eliminating human error. Perhaps it's cost effective in some manner. But, you really need to do a little motivational training for the staff.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Good pizza fresh veggies in the salad and quick service?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Customer service is good and the employees are respectful and nice. The pizza and calzones are really good. We have gone there several times with a family of over 15 and they always accommodate us and are real friendly toward our entire party. We have had delivary service as well and we have always been pleased.
Please know, I’ve never left a one star review before, nor a bad review, but I feel this one is important. This is the most over priced pizza I’ve ever encountered. All I can say is it’s pizza. It’s not exceptional pizza. 20$ for a small cheese pizza and 2$/ topping after? Really? I hope you don’t like any vegetables on your pizza. Even by the slice you pay an additional 1$/topping. Get over yourselves. I’d rather order dominos and sacrifice quality instead of feeling assaulted. Yes, everybody has raised their prices, but you are taking FULL advantage. It’s ridiculous. And the reviews are telling. As residents of CPV, we will not support your business anymore.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Please know, I've never left a one star review before, nor a bad review, but I feel this one is important. This is the most over priced pizza I've ever encountered. All I can say is it's pizza. It's not exceptional pizza. 20$ for a small cheese pizza and 2$/ topping after? Really? I hope you don't like any vegetables on your pizza. Even by the slice you pay an additional 1$/topping. Get over yourselves. I'd rather order dominos and sacrifice quality instead of feeling assaulted. Yes, everybody has raised their prices, but you are taking FULL advantage. It's ridiculous. And the reviews are telling. As residents of CPV, we will not support your business anymore.
Pizza is always excellent, staff is always super friendly, delivery is always fast and hot out of the oven! Couldn’t ask for a better place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5