Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church

The service was outstanding! Our waitress found a table that my mother could sit at with a walker and it was away from other people so we could hear each other. That was much appreciated. The food was outstanding, as usual. My husband got the chicken Parmesan, I had the lasagna and my mother had the crab stuffed shrimp with linguine. The Ambience was awesome! We had the house bread pudding with homemade Oreo, ice cream drizzled with homemade chocolate sauce. That was to die for.

Absolutely great food. Really enjoyed. Our server was terrific. Her timing was perfect and attentive without hovering over us. My only 2 complaints are that the music was a little too loud to have an easy conversation. The room was partially empty, due to weeknight, and we were seated right next to the only other couple, and we had a reservation. I'm sure they were able to hear all our conversation as we did theirs. There were many other tables empty. We'll go back and try again. The food is delicious.

Loved this spot - we will definitely be back! The food was fresh and delicious. Our server, Lee, was awesome and helped us make some great selections from the menu.

We really enjoyed our service and had a great time. The Last Supper table is nice and have us privacy for our dinner.

The food and the service were excellent. The church portion was being remodeled so that took the ambience down a notch.

Too much dressing on the salads. And too much red sauce on the past with the chicken parmesan dinner. But the gluten free pasta was really good

We had one hiccup, but it was acceptable. Our friends ordered a pizza to go and only received a slice. We were charged for the slice, but they really loved the pizza and wanted a whole one to take home. The food was delicious and the atmosphere was nice. Drinks were delicious too!

Fantastic food. Not a quiet place but vibrant and alive. I great place for a group of friends. My go to Italian food.

It can be noisy at times and the ambience is somewhat bland but overlooked that as prices were decent and food was very good as was the service! I recommend the restaurant to those who like good Italian food and very good service....both are important to me! Try it out, its worth it!

Double Date - all 4 of us raved about how good our dinners were! I had the Frutta Di Mare, my husband the Lasagna, others had the Stuffed Shrimp - Fantastic! I even asked for a substitution (angel hair vs linguini) no problem! The wine was on "sale" a very nice wine at a very reasonable price. Our server, Megan I think ... was fun and informative and just the right about of attention ... meaning she was "around" if we needed her and formally checked in several times. Reasonable price for such a good meal. We specifically asked for a quiet table on our reservation, so not sure if it's much louder in the open area, our table was perfect. Then Oh!! the Pistachio Martini!??? Oh my - that was delicious!! We will definitely be back!

We had a great meal. We started with the meatball appetizer and garlic bread. There was plenty for the three of us. They also brought us complimentary bread with EVOO and balsamic. Bread was tasty. Next was a Caesar salad, with an excellent dressing and croutons. Two of us had lasagna. Portions were large,and we had leftovers. Another had salmon with risotto and broccolini. The restaurant was packed, but service was good and food arrived timely. Everything was great, and we really enjoyed our meal.

Everything was amazing! We had a large group of people and couldn't have been happier with the service.

The location, ambience and service are great. However, the food is average. I would recommend going for the ambience only.

It was my husband‘s birthday and we had a very tall waiter named Matt and he was terrific. He brought my husband a beautiful cannoli with a candle.

The bread is amazing. Sit in the confessional booth if there's just two of you. Will definitely come back for special occasions.