Love this pizza! Best in Colorado. Garlic knots are so yummy and finish with the cinnamon knots. Never disappoints
Jen R
The Blue Buffalo Chicken pizza is amazing!
Alex Mihlstin
Great pizza and garlic knots. Just like back home on Long Island!
Jennifer Rhatigan
An 18 inch cheese pizza ($19.41) is more expensive than a specialty pizza (white pizza $18.25) and, only a dollar cheaper than a lot of the other specialty pizzas. If this is inaccurate, then your website pricing is inaccurate, which is misleading to customers and may fall under deceptive advertising, potentially warranting a consumer protection complaint. I stand by my review.
Sarah Costin
We have been coming here for about 5 years. We have dined in, place takeout orders on almost a weekly basis, and have celebrated numerous events here. We liked that the food was pretty good and it was a fun atmosphere for kids/families. Things have since changed, they have become very strict with the size of parties. We have come in the past to socialize in group gatherings with friends and family. On this visit we were here at 4:15 PM to about 5:40 PM, on a Thursday. Not a busy or high demand time, there were numerous open tables, about 3 low tables were taken and 1 high top in the bar area. This time another family in our group asked to start a separate tab from the one we had, and they were turned down. The waitress told us that it had to be on our tab and that if more people joined our party then the 8 seats available at our table, they would not be allowed to occupy another table. I just don’t understand turning down business or making people feel awkward or uncomfortable if they have a large party. There was also another parent in our that tried to order from the bar, when the kids were playing the games, and again they were denied. I feel like this restaurant has the type of atmosphere we have utilized it for and promotes social gatherings in a casual environment, where you can enjoy food and drinks, and the arcade area. After our experience today, we will no longer be taking our business here nor will we continue to recommend Stumpy’s. Very disappointing.
S
We love Stumpys! They have a great lunch deal, amazing food and the staff is always friendly. The booths are in need of repair, but I would still highly recommend eating there.
Mary Weaver
Stumpy’s Pizza is the best! They came to our rescue. We are an out of state soccer team that had a league game in town and after the game we needed to feed the players and families. After being rudely turned away from their competitors Gretchen, Stumpy’s manager came to our rescue. Gretchen welcomed our team with open arms. Her staff was professional and efficient. Our experience was top notch. A huge thank you to Gretchen and the staff at Stumpy’s they were awesome!!!
Jennifer Zaur
Our soccer team was visiting from out of state and came to Stumpy's after our game. They provided amazing service to our team of 30! The pizza came quickly and the thin crust was great. Gretchen in particular made our night. If our team is ever back in Castle Rock we'll be sure to be back!
Rob Kennedy
Great food great service. We brought our soccer team here after a game and it was wonderful.
Tam Boxer
The pizzas good, wish they were more generous on the toppings though.
Environment is fun despite it being a little dark. We went in the early afternoon and it had a night atmosphere.
Could not place take out order in the phone! Had to order in person! Castle Rock restaurants just suck!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
B Caldwell
Absolutely love the pizza here. Some of the best in the state! The kids love coming here to eat and play the pinball machines. I would've posted a picture of the pizza, but we usually eat it too fast to snap a pic 😁
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots
David Nelson
Delicious Italian Chef's Salad, and fresh made garlic knots were as good as I've ever had...service was great (Celso at the Bar is awesome, Kimber too!) Definitely recommended!
It was busy in the place but kimber was phenomenal and attentive. The place is very welcoming. Pizzas took a bit longer. But homemade dough and pizza is great. I wouldn't mind waiting for the quality. Def a great little pizza place I'll ALWAYS support!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
Stephen Italiano
As a pizza aficionado from the east coast, this place is criminally underrated. A shining example of ignorance is bliss. If you like good pizza, come here. Great NY style! Very confused on the 4.3 stars.
Love this pizza! Best in Colorado. Garlic knots are so yummy and finish with the cinnamon knots. Never disappoints
The Blue Buffalo Chicken pizza is amazing!
Great pizza and garlic knots. Just like back home on Long Island!
An 18 inch cheese pizza ($19.41) is more expensive than a specialty pizza (white pizza $18.25) and, only a dollar cheaper than a lot of the other specialty pizzas.
If this is inaccurate, then your website pricing is inaccurate, which is misleading to customers and may fall under deceptive advertising, potentially warranting a consumer protection complaint. I stand by my review.
We have been coming here for about 5 years. We have dined in, place takeout orders on almost a weekly basis, and have celebrated numerous events here. We liked that the food was pretty good and it was a fun atmosphere for kids/families. Things have since changed, they have become very strict with the size of parties. We have come in the past to socialize in group gatherings with friends and family. On this visit we were here at 4:15 PM to about 5:40 PM, on a Thursday. Not a busy or high demand time, there were numerous open tables, about 3 low tables were taken and 1 high top in the bar area. This time another family in our group asked to start a separate tab from the one we had, and they were turned down. The waitress told us that it had to be on our tab and that if more people joined our party then the 8 seats available at our table, they would not be allowed to occupy another table. I just don’t understand turning down business or making people feel awkward or uncomfortable if they have a large party. There was also another parent in our that tried to order from the bar, when the kids were playing the games, and again they were denied. I feel like this restaurant has the type of atmosphere we have utilized it for and promotes social gatherings in a casual environment, where you can enjoy food and drinks, and the arcade area. After our experience today, we will no longer be taking our business here nor will we continue to recommend Stumpy’s. Very disappointing.
We love Stumpys! They have a great lunch deal, amazing food and the staff is always friendly. The booths are in need of repair, but I would still highly recommend eating there.
Stumpy’s Pizza is the best! They came to our rescue. We are an out of state soccer team that had a league game in town and after the game we needed to feed the players and families. After being rudely turned away from their competitors Gretchen, Stumpy’s manager came to our rescue. Gretchen welcomed our team with open arms. Her staff was professional and efficient. Our experience was top notch. A huge thank you to Gretchen and the staff at Stumpy’s they were awesome!!!
Our soccer team was visiting from out of state and came to Stumpy's after our game. They provided amazing service to our team of 30! The pizza came quickly and the thin crust was great. Gretchen in particular made our night. If our team is ever back in Castle Rock we'll be sure to be back!
Great food great service.
We brought our soccer team here after a game and it was wonderful.
The pizzas good, wish they were more generous on the toppings though.
Environment is fun despite it being a little dark. We went in the early afternoon and it had a night atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Could not place take out order in the phone! Had to order in person! Castle Rock restaurants just suck!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Absolutely love the pizza here. Some of the best in the state! The kids love coming here to eat and play the pinball machines. I would've posted a picture of the pizza, but we usually eat it too fast to snap a pic 😁
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots
Delicious Italian Chef's Salad, and fresh made garlic knots were as good as I've ever had...service was great (Celso at the Bar is awesome, Kimber too!) Definitely recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Salads, Garlic Knots
It was busy in the place but kimber was phenomenal and attentive. The place is very welcoming. Pizzas took a bit longer. But homemade dough and pizza is great. I wouldn't mind waiting for the quality. Def a great little pizza place I'll ALWAYS support!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
As a pizza aficionado from the east coast, this place is criminally underrated. A shining example of ignorance is bliss. If you like good pizza, come here. Great NY style! Very confused on the 4.3 stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...