Food was good, it was a bit oily. Service was awful and the restaurant has seen better days. There are huge holes in almost all of the booths. For the footprint they could really fix it up and make it nice.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Flourless Chocolate Cake
Emalie Jenik
I have been coming here for years, always recommend it to anyone that asks for pizza recs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Combination, Pepperoni Pizza, Fries, Mozzarella Sticks
Bill Gray
Normally very good. Dunedin or delivery. This time it was horrible.The blue cheese for the wings and the 1000 island dressing on the burger was as thin as water. Was like they forgot the mayo. :(
Food: 2
Carolina Guillen Arteaga
The habanero mango wings are my delicious favorites, recommended to ?Vegetarian options: There are vegetarian pizzasParking: There is a lot of parking aroundKid-friendliness: My son really likes pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Alcorn
Great food. And pinball!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peterson Creative
Great food, excellent service. I've been a few times & have only had the pizza, but it's delicious. A new favorite spot!Kid-friendliness: They've got a small pinball arcade in the back corner, which was awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Side Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza Standard
Ryan Wolff
Ordered takeout at 5:25. Was quoted 30-35 min so I arrived at 6:00. I was told I was early but it was in the works. They also didn’t have the garlic knots I ordered when I paid so I had to re-order those. Fast forward 35 minutes and I inquire about my order. I’m told I was quoted 40 minutes and “they’re working in it”. Then the rude employee who would rather talk over people than listen finds my cold pizza that’s probably been sitting the entire time I’ve been waiting and hands it to me. Several others in line waiting were having the same experience. Long story long… I waited over an hour for cold mediocre pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Michael Johansen
My wife and I have been coming to Stumpy's since it was a "takeout/buy a slice" joint in a strip mall off of Founder's. I'm from Queens NY and grew up on NY pies. This is the best in Colorado. (Honorary mention goes to Big Bill's.) Interestingly enough, my wife absolutely loves the burgers too. She claims they are better than most of the "high end" burgers in Castle Rock restaurants. The team does a great job, particularly since they, like everyone else, are having trouble attracting new employees. It's a sign of the times and Stumpy's does a great job of dealing with it. I guess it's been 10 years or so of eating Stumpy's pies. The best "test case" for a real NY pie is to order plain cheese. That way you get the pure deal. Of course, the toppings are fun too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Standard
Holly A.
Their Motzerrella Sticks and marinara are divine! Their pizzas are delicious! Their hamburgers are great and the thousand island dressing makes them perfecto‼ Stumpy's maranara is the first maranara sauce I've had that does NOT set my chest on fire due to acid reflux. I am so elated that I have finally found a maranara sauce that does not aggravate my stomach Thank you for being such great people and helping me out with my take out. My spine was mangled in a very bad accident and the fusions and the surgeries I have had were failed back surgeries except for the first surgery. I have permanent nerve damage and it is hard for me to walk. I fight everyday to keep walking, but my spine screams at me when I walk too far. Therefore, I truly appreciate your help with my orders. Awesome people who are employed by Stumpy's and the food, as well as, the atmosphere are all top of the line in my opinion. You have earned my respect and my business.
Eric Ortega
It was a fun little place to enjoy a nice slice of pizza. The food was good, they had arcade games which was cool, and the staff was friendly. All pluses in my book! ????
6 or more in your party you are automatically paying them 20% tip no matter the service. Never coming back. Who charges individually for dressings?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ryan C.
Some of the best Pizza out there. Anytime my parents drove through Castle Rock growing up we always made an effort to stop at Stumpy's (10-12 years ago) now that my wife and I have lived here for almost 3 years we always love getting some Stumpy's pizza. Would highly recommend!
Cyndi Roberts
Good food and friendly staff. There are even a few games in the back that the kids can play while the pizza is cooking. A few good beer choices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Josh R
Good pizza cheap beer good waitresses 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jared Streeper
I'm from Utah and we were in town for the Thanksgiving weekend. My in-laws wanted some pizza the day after Thanksgiving, so we picked some up from here on their recommendation. It immediately shot to the top 5 best pizza I've had! Very good and no complaints. So good, I'll be craving this again! Too bad it's 10 hours away!
Food was good, it was a bit oily. Service was awful and the restaurant has seen better days. There are huge holes in almost all of the booths. For the footprint they could really fix it up and make it nice.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Flourless Chocolate Cake
I have been coming here for years, always recommend it to anyone that asks for pizza recs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Combination, Pepperoni Pizza, Fries, Mozzarella Sticks
Normally very good. Dunedin or delivery. This time it was horrible.The blue cheese for the wings and the 1000 island dressing on the burger was as thin as water. Was like they forgot the mayo. :(
Food: 2
The habanero mango wings are my delicious favorites, recommended to ?Vegetarian options: There are vegetarian pizzasParking: There is a lot of parking aroundKid-friendliness: My son really likes pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food. And pinball!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, excellent service. I've been a few times & have only had the pizza, but it's delicious. A new favorite spot!Kid-friendliness: They've got a small pinball arcade in the back corner, which was awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Side Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza Standard
Ordered takeout at 5:25. Was quoted 30-35 min so I arrived at 6:00. I was told I was early but it was in the works. They also didn’t have the garlic knots I ordered when I paid so I had to re-order those. Fast forward 35 minutes and I inquire about my order. I’m told I was quoted 40 minutes and “they’re working in it”. Then the rude employee who would rather talk over people than listen finds my cold pizza that’s probably been sitting the entire time I’ve been waiting and hands it to me. Several others in line waiting were having the same experience. Long story long… I waited over an hour for cold mediocre pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My wife and I have been coming to Stumpy's since it was a "takeout/buy a slice" joint in a strip mall off of Founder's. I'm from Queens NY and grew up on NY pies. This is the best in Colorado. (Honorary mention goes to Big Bill's.) Interestingly enough, my wife absolutely loves the burgers too. She claims they are better than most of the "high end" burgers in Castle Rock restaurants. The team does a great job, particularly since they, like everyone else, are having trouble attracting new employees. It's a sign of the times and Stumpy's does a great job of dealing with it. I guess it's been 10 years or so of eating Stumpy's pies. The best "test case" for a real NY pie is to order plain cheese. That way you get the pure deal. Of course, the toppings are fun too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Standard
Their Motzerrella Sticks and marinara are divine! Their pizzas are delicious! Their hamburgers are great and the thousand island dressing makes them perfecto‼ Stumpy's maranara is the first maranara sauce I've had that does NOT set my chest on fire due to acid reflux. I am so elated that I have finally found a maranara sauce that does not aggravate my stomach Thank you for being such great people and helping me out with my take out. My spine was mangled in a very bad accident and the fusions and the surgeries I have had were failed back surgeries except for the first surgery. I have permanent nerve damage and it is hard for me to walk. I fight everyday to keep walking, but my spine screams at me when I walk too far. Therefore, I truly appreciate your help with my orders. Awesome people who are employed by Stumpy's and the food, as well as, the atmosphere are all top of the line in my opinion. You have earned my respect and my business.
It was a fun little place to enjoy a nice slice of pizza. The food was good, they had arcade games which was cool, and the staff was friendly. All pluses in my book! ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
6 or more in your party you are automatically paying them 20% tip no matter the service. Never coming back. Who charges individually for dressings?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Some of the best Pizza out there. Anytime my parents drove through Castle Rock growing up we always made an effort to stop at Stumpy's (10-12 years ago) now that my wife and I have lived here for almost 3 years we always love getting some Stumpy's pizza. Would highly recommend!
Good food and friendly staff. There are even a few games in the back that the kids can play while the pizza is cooking. A few good beer choices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Good pizza cheap beer good waitresses 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm from Utah and we were in town for the Thanksgiving weekend. My in-laws wanted some pizza the day after Thanksgiving, so we picked some up from here on their recommendation. It immediately shot to the top 5 best pizza I've had! Very good and no complaints. So good, I'll be craving this again! Too bad it's 10 hours away!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza