These are some of the BEST cupcakes I’ve EVER had!!! Beautiful store front, and the gal up front is extremely nice and helpful!! I had the Oreo and Peanut butter Pie slices the other day and OMG talk about heaven in your mouth!!! I won’t but cupcakes from anywhere else!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies & Cream, Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Unicorn Cake, Hostess, Oreo Cheesecake Pie, Better Than Sex, Cookies and Cream
Laura Collier
I would trade my soul for a lifetime supply of the tiramisu cupcakes from this shop. To be fair, all of the cupcakes I have tried have been absolutely delicious and the presentation is perfection. But the offer stands for the tiramisu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Better Than Sex, Cookies and Cream, Red Velvet
Cory Howard
Very Delicious cupcakes!! I was astonished by how moist they were. The store has very cute and clean look and the seasonal decorations are so fun! one of my favorite stops in Castle
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sara C.
I should have taken a picture. I got the cookies and cream and spiced carrot cupcakes. They were probably the best cupcakes I've ever had. I generally don't like cake or cupcakes because of the dry nature of the dessert but these were fantastic!! I could have used a little more filling on the spiced carrot but still so so so good.
AM Novilla
Cupcakes have progressively gone smaller since we've visited over the years and they have increased prices! Also, 2 different prices $5 online and $6 in store. Not sure how this makes sense ?
Tom Carter
We’ve gotten cup cakes and cookies from here several times. They’ve been amazing every time, and the service was excellent. We missed the chance for some Halloween cupcakes and they made some new ones for us right then.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Banzai Pipeline
I’ve given the cupcakes two chances and each time they were dry. The frosting is amazing which helps with the dryness. They aren’t baking them fresh everyday, that’s obvious.They are beautifully presented and the coffee shop next door serves as a way to dip a bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Taylor Chase
The Cake Company made an awesome tiered cake and cupcakes for my brother’s wedding rehearsal this weekend! The little touches of baby’s breath and pearl beads were perfection!!! Not to mention, it was delicious!
Zoe Pielsticker
1000/10 OH MY GOD THIS CAKE IS AMAZING!I was connected with The Cake Co through my planner, and im so happy I did. I’ve been gluten free for 15+ years. I’ve witnessed the evolution of gluten free foods since then and have high expectations when it comes to quality gf baking. The Cake Co delivered more than I could have hoped for! The whole experience working with The Cake Co was lovely. They host tastings in the neighboring coffee shop which created a lovely semi private atmosphere and relaxed the formality of a tasting. They made me 4 gf sample cupcakes, we ended up loving the white cake even though im a chocolate fiend. We got a 6” gf cutting cake and 100 regular cupcakes of different varieties. They were a HIT! We only got the first bite from our cake cutting, everything else was devoured before the end of the night.Thankfully, my mother lives about 2 miles from their storefront, so we will definitely be buying more cakes from them in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
EDT
I don't like cupcakes in general because they are always too sweet for my taste. This store changed my mind about cupcakes. They are very well balanced, and everything here are delicious!
How can you work here and not eat all day?!?!?! Oh My GOODNESS! This place is FULL of YUMMY GOODNESS so beautifully displayed....and bonus....they have SAMPLES AND Gluten-free products. Not just 1 gluten free choice but about 6! This is amazing! The store is so beautifully decorated for the holidays and it just smells as fantastic as it looks. Unfortunately, due to my allergies- I could not try anything myself....but it was somewhere I would like to bring my husband for him to try something!
Tray B.
How can you work here and not eat all day?!?!?! Oh My GOODNESS! This place is FULL of YUMMY GOODNESS so beautifully displayed....and bonus....they have SAMPLES AND Gluten-free products. Not just 1 gluten free choice but about 6! This is amazing! The store is so beautifully decorated for the holidays and it just smells as fantastic as it looks. Unfortunately, due to my allergies- I could not try anything myself....but it was somewhere I would like to bring my husband for him to try something!
Zoe P.
1000/10 OH MY GOD THIS CAKE IS AMAZING! I was connected with The Cake Co through my planner, and im so happy I did. I've been gluten free for 15+ years. I've witnessed the evolution of gluten free foods since then and have high expectations when it comes to quality gf baking. The Cake Co delivered more than I could have hoped for! The whole experience working with The Cake Co was lovely. They host tastings in the neighboring coffee shop which created a lovely semi private atmosphere and relaxed the formality of a tasting. They made me 4 gf sample cupcakes, we ended up loving the white cake even though im a chocolate fiend. We got a 6" gf cutting cake and 100 regular cupcakes of different varieties. They were a HIT! We only got the first bite from our cake cutting, everything else was devoured before the end of the night. Thankfully, my mother lives about 2 miles from their storefront, so we will definitely be buying more cakes from them in the future.
Andrea C.
Beautiful and delicious cake and cupcakes for our large event. Great service and communication too! Thank you Lauren!
Julie F.
Ordered cupcakes for a business meeting and they were a hit! The assortment looked beautiful and everyone was "mmmmmmmm! These are so good!" Success!
These are some of the BEST cupcakes I’ve EVER had!!! Beautiful store front, and the gal up front is extremely nice and helpful!! I had the Oreo and Peanut butter Pie slices the other day and OMG talk about heaven in your mouth!!! I won’t but cupcakes from anywhere else!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies & Cream, Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Unicorn Cake, Hostess, Oreo Cheesecake Pie, Better Than Sex, Cookies and Cream
I would trade my soul for a lifetime supply of the tiramisu cupcakes from this shop. To be fair, all of the cupcakes I have tried have been absolutely delicious and the presentation is perfection. But the offer stands for the tiramisu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Better Than Sex, Cookies and Cream, Red Velvet
Very Delicious cupcakes!! I was astonished by how moist they were. The store has very cute and clean look and the seasonal decorations are so fun! one of my favorite stops in Castle
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I should have taken a picture. I got the cookies and cream and spiced carrot cupcakes. They were probably the best cupcakes I've ever had. I generally don't like cake or cupcakes because of the dry nature of the dessert but these were fantastic!! I could have used a little more filling on the spiced carrot but still so so so good.
Cupcakes have progressively gone smaller since we've visited over the years and they have increased prices! Also, 2 different prices $5 online and $6 in store. Not sure how this makes sense ?
We’ve gotten cup cakes and cookies from here several times. They’ve been amazing every time, and the service was excellent. We missed the chance for some Halloween cupcakes and they made some new ones for us right then.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve given the cupcakes two chances and each time they were dry. The frosting is amazing which helps with the dryness. They aren’t baking them fresh everyday, that’s obvious.They are beautifully presented and the coffee shop next door serves as a way to dip a bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
The Cake Company made an awesome tiered cake and cupcakes for my brother’s wedding rehearsal this weekend! The little touches of baby’s breath and pearl beads were perfection!!! Not to mention, it was delicious!
1000/10 OH MY GOD THIS CAKE IS AMAZING!I was connected with The Cake Co through my planner, and im so happy I did. I’ve been gluten free for 15+ years. I’ve witnessed the evolution of gluten free foods since then and have high expectations when it comes to quality gf baking. The Cake Co delivered more than I could have hoped for! The whole experience working with The Cake Co was lovely. They host tastings in the neighboring coffee shop which created a lovely semi private atmosphere and relaxed the formality of a tasting. They made me 4 gf sample cupcakes, we ended up loving the white cake even though im a chocolate fiend. We got a 6” gf cutting cake and 100 regular cupcakes of different varieties. They were a HIT! We only got the first bite from our cake cutting, everything else was devoured before the end of the night.Thankfully, my mother lives about 2 miles from their storefront, so we will definitely be buying more cakes from them in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don't like cupcakes in general because they are always too sweet for my taste. This store changed my mind about cupcakes. They are very well balanced, and everything here are delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
How can you work here and not eat all day?!?!?! Oh My GOODNESS! This place is FULL of YUMMY GOODNESS so beautifully displayed....and bonus....they have SAMPLES AND Gluten-free products. Not just 1 gluten free choice but about 6! This is amazing! The store is so beautifully decorated for the holidays and it just smells as fantastic as it looks. Unfortunately, due to my allergies- I could not try anything myself....but it was somewhere I would like to bring my husband for him to try something!
How can you work here and not eat all day?!?!?! Oh My GOODNESS! This place is FULL of YUMMY GOODNESS so beautifully displayed....and bonus....they have SAMPLES AND Gluten-free products. Not just 1 gluten free choice but about 6! This is amazing! The store is so beautifully decorated for the holidays and it just smells as fantastic as it looks. Unfortunately, due to my allergies- I could not try anything myself....but it was somewhere I would like to bring my husband for him to try something!
1000/10 OH MY GOD THIS CAKE IS AMAZING! I was connected with The Cake Co through my planner, and im so happy I did. I've been gluten free for 15+ years. I've witnessed the evolution of gluten free foods since then and have high expectations when it comes to quality gf baking. The Cake Co delivered more than I could have hoped for! The whole experience working with The Cake Co was lovely. They host tastings in the neighboring coffee shop which created a lovely semi private atmosphere and relaxed the formality of a tasting. They made me 4 gf sample cupcakes, we ended up loving the white cake even though im a chocolate fiend. We got a 6" gf cutting cake and 100 regular cupcakes of different varieties. They were a HIT! We only got the first bite from our cake cutting, everything else was devoured before the end of the night. Thankfully, my mother lives about 2 miles from their storefront, so we will definitely be buying more cakes from them in the future.
Beautiful and delicious cake and cupcakes for our large event. Great service and communication too! Thank you Lauren!
Ordered cupcakes for a business meeting and they were a hit! The assortment looked beautiful and everyone was "mmmmmmmm! These are so good!" Success!