Blue Mountain Creamery

5166 N Nevada Ave #100, Colorado Springs
(719) 599-9800

Recent Reviews

Magaret E.

It's important to know who runs this business, Forsham Williams Jr., registered sex offender, who was featured on KRDO as having committed fraud on multiple gyms he has opened in both Colorado Springs and Gleneagle. Some employees have not received checks according to the article, and given his criminal history I would be wary of doing business with his man in any capacity.

Samantha K.

Went into Blue Mountain Creamery today and was welcomed with a smiling face and a glorious selection of ice cream. The employee working there was very nice and was very helpful. Had a wonderful experience here at Blue Mountain Creamery and recommend anyone looking for a sweet tooth fix to go and enjoy their made in house, ice creams.

J. Rowe

After having been to this establishment and working there, I know that this place is great. Despite all the drama in the recent past, there seem to be no discrepancies to note. I thoroughly enjoy working for the creamery and do encourage people come in and give it a shot. The owner, while having been talked about a lot recently, is not what the media portrays him to be. The media has shaped this man into a monster that should be avoided at all costs however that is not the case, if you do come into Blue mountain you will be greeted with a smile and vast selection of ice cream and gelato no matter what. This place is not to be avoided but enjoyed by everyone here in Colorado Springs, so please do come by and pay a visit.

Melody

I'm writing this review as a recent, previous, employee of Blue Mountain Creamery who worked under the new, current owner and boss. I beg anyone who sees this to not support this business, there are much better and kinder ice cream shops here in Springs that are so much more deserving of your time and money! As others have stated, the owner, my previous boss, is not a good person. All of the employees here, which are mostly college and highschool students, are not treated well or respected at all and I can say that without a doubt from experience. The owner, again as others have stated, is a scammer and on one occasion bounced my pay check days before I needed to pay rent and would not pay me what was taken until I haggled him about for multiple days and hardly got back any communication on it. I only got paid back after showing multiple pieces of evidence for this massive error, and it took days and hardly no communication on his part for it to happen, days after my rent was supposed to be due. I'm more lucky than others, because I know past employees have flat out not been paid for their service which can be shown by KRDO news reports on the owner and his absolutely shady business practices. Do not support this establishment and give this man more money because that's the only one who is benefiting from it. This isn't a family owned store, go support actual family owned operations that respect their employees and treat people fairly with kindness and respect.Edited to add: the positive most recent review from Alice is most definitely a fake account from the owner and shouldn't be trusted ? All my time working there, there was no Alice and he is making up accounts because no one in real life has anything positive to say about him ??

Melody G.

I'm writing this review as a recent, previous, employee of Blue Mountain Creamery who worked under the new, current owner and boss. I beg anyone who sees this to not support this business, there are much better and kinder ice cream shops here in Springs that are so much more deserving of your time and money! As others have stated, the owner, my previous boss, is not a good person. All of the employees here, which are mostly college and highschool students, are not treated well or respected at all and I can say that without a doubt from experience. The owner, again as others have stated, is a scammer and on one occasion bounced my pay check days before I needed to pay rent and would not pay me what was taken until I haggled him about for multiple days and hardly got back any communication on it. I only got paid back after showing multiple pieces of evidence for this massive error, and it took days and hardly no communication on his part for it to happen, days after my rent was supposed to be due. I'm more lucky than others, because I know past employees have flat out not been paid for their service which can be shown by KRDO news reports on the owner and his absolutely shady business practices. Do not support this establishment and give this man more money because that's the only one who is benefiting from it. This isn't a family owned store, go support actual family owned operations that respect their employees and treat people fairly with kindness and respect.

Philip Lataille

Owner did not pay employee wages, and just lost a suite claiming he never paid $440,000 to the previous owner! Dont go here. There are many other places to get icecream in COS. Try the Thai ice cream on woodmen

Ronald M.

Ice cream ( made in-house ) was delicious. The banana split we ordered was well made. We will return.

Austin Ledger

Awesome experience! Visiting the area and found this shop. Employee on duty was extremely nice and the ice cream was fantastic! Wish I could take the store back home with me.

Hannah Robinson

Ice cream was great! Poor girl was working all by herself on a busy Tuesday night, but she was very kind and apologetic about the wait! 10/10 customer service experience

James “Jimmy” Laverty

The Gelato was pretty good, but I've had better here in town. The staff gal was helping other people. They could have used another person on staff to serve the customers.There didn't seem to be enough chairs for the tables there. The couch and chair of to the side was nice to sit at.

Patrick Covey

I'm writing this review in the parking lot of this establishment, because I was so disgusted by what I saw when I walked in the door. A man wearing a New York Yankees hat was griping out the only employee on duty when I walked in. He continued to do so while I was waiting to order. I could tell the poor girl was mortified, because she kept glancing over at me. Nothing about this is professional. If the employee was doing something wrong, it should be discussed behind closed doors, not out in the open and especially not while customers are waiting to order. I don't see this place lasting long due to his actions. My family has owned and operated a business for 14 years and this is not how you treat employees.

Heather Lanam

Blue Mountain Creamery is the best ice cream establishment I've ever been to! They have multiple delicious flavors they make in house they have some of the BEST customers service we've experienced in a long time. They truly make the experience top notch!!

Neha V.

This is such a cute nicely decorated ice cream shop! The place had an arcade, a fancy recliner sofa, and great ice cream. I got the chocolate chip chocolate ice cream and it was creamy, sweet, and the chocolate chips added a different texture. I also got the expresso gelato which was bitter by itself but with the added chocolate chips it balanced out the bitterness making it good. There were not that many flavors but the employees were super nice.

Corina DeVries

If you're looking for a delicious ice cream shop in Colorado Springs, look no further than Blue Mountain Creamery. I recently visited this charming little spot with my granddaughters and was blown away by the homemade ice cream and friendly service.From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel right at home. They were patient and kind with my granddaughters, who were a little bit overexcited about all of the delicious flavors. We were treated to some of the best ice cream we've ever tasted - you can really tell that it's made with care and attention to detail.After we finished our treats, we settled into a cozy little alcove with a love seat and some toys for the girls to play with. It was such a nice touch and really made the experience all the more special.Overall, I would highly recommend Blue Mountain Creamery to anyone looking for a great ice cream shop in Colorado Springs. The ice cream is top-notch and the staff goes above and beyond to make you feel welcome. This will definitely be a priority stop for me every time I visit in the future!

Rachel Brower

Nice little ice cream shop, really nice girl working there, free samples of anything you'd like to try before you buy. I got the chai vanilla ice cream and it was GREAT. The green tea was a bit disappointing because it just tasted like vanilla ice cream, but that's why you taste test first ?

Load More