Sugarplum Cake Shoppe

Delicious local cupcakes, some of the best I’ve ever had! Fresh, perfect texture, and not too too sweet.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had out wedding cake and desserts here the cookies were fabulous. However the cake was not what we had pictured yes it still looked nice but it wasn't what we envisioned we wanted rose gold flakes which we were quoted and was attached to the cake bill. the cakes flavor was good but not much in the way of the filling. Inspo pic attached as well for reference. (yes inspo is 3 layers we only wanted 2)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

We ordered our wedding cake and favors from here and they were lovely! We provided them with what we wanted, and they created just that! We also had cookies as favors for our guests, and they individually wrapped and placed ribbon on all of them. Something else we loved about this business is how many options for cake and fillings. They have almost anything as a flavor and we found that to be helpful when ordering the cake. We were so happy with the cake and would recommend working with them!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

From the day the bride and groom went to the bakery for a taste test to the wedding, Sugar Plum Bakery made every special. The cake was gorgeous, and the cupcakes were the talk of all the guests. Real flowers from the florist were used on the cupcakes. It was perfect – the bakery was perfect – everything was perfect.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We used Sugarplum Cake Shoppe recently for our wedding cake and desserts and they were easily the most talked about item at our wedding. They were able to personalize the flavors of our cake and the design came out exactly how we had imagined it would look. We also chose to go with a dessert bar with a few different options and they all were fan favorites! I would highly recommend Sugarplum Cake Shoppe to anybody that is needing desserts for their wedding or large event.

Food: 5

Service: 5

I brought in a few pictures and asked if I could get a cake that looked similar to any of the pictures. I did this in a short notice, I believe 3 or 4 days before the actual event. They were able to get me in & they exceeded my expectations. I have referred a few people to them. I ordered the cake in June. It was delicious one layer was almond flavored & the other was strawberry. I also bought a few cupcakes that were on the display… they were delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sugarplumb Cake Shoppe was amazing for our wedding! Nicole was so sweet and easy to work with, giving us plenty of options and creative ideas to choose from. The cutting cake was beautiful, tasted incredible, and we had plenty leftover for everyone to enjoy. Delivery was right on time, and the whole experience felt effortless. On top of that, the shop itself is adorable! We couldn’t be happier and highly recommend Sugarplumb Cake Shoppe.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The cake was good but not great. It really wasn’t worth the price we paid. We also had cupcakes and they were good just nothing special for the cost. I wouldn’t use them again.
Communication was lacking as well.
Now our caterer was awesome at reaching out on several occasions and I had no worries and they were worth what we paid. (RK Prime)

Food: 4

Service: 2

Our wedding cake from SugarPlum was absolutely amazing! It was not only gorgeous to look at but also so delicious, we received so many compliments from our guests. The team at was wonderful and so easy to work with, which made the whole process stress-free. We couldn’t have asked for a better cake for our special day!

They work with the all-inclusive venue we used. Absolutely LOVED the cake. Sugar Plum made the process so easy and I loved how good it tasted and beautiful it was!!! Thank you for your hard work and making my cake so beautifully!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

I have been working with a baker here for several weeks on a cake for early October. And this even is a major military ceremony retirement after 30 years. Today I got a random email sating the baker is no longer with the company and they will not be able to honor the agreement she made to make my cake. Then they continue to recommend two other bakeries that DO NOT offer custom cakes with fondont, which of course mine does. Terrible! The size and complexity of the cake makes it impossible to find another reputable baker in time. Very unprofessional and if you want a guarantee that they will make you custom cake as agreed, don't come here....

We had Sugarplum Cake Shoppe make our wedding cake and it was absolutely perfect. Not only was the design beautiful and exactly what we envisioned, but the flavors were out of this world. Every layer was moist, delicious, and had our guests raving. People are still talking about how good the cake was.

Amanda was amazing to work with. She made the whole process easy and enjoyable, from the tasting to the final design. She really listened to what we wanted and brought it to life perfectly. We couldn’t have been happier and would recommend Sugarplum to anyone looking for a cake that tastes just as incredible as it looks.

10/10 highly recommend this little bakery. I looked high and low for someone who could make a little cake for my daughters birthday they absolutely nailed what she asked for! It was delicious as well! This will be our new little go to bakery from now on! Thank you!

Really enjoyed my birthday cake from this shop!!

Sugarplum created a gorgeous and delicious semi-naked vanilla cake including a tier that was vegan! It was just the right size for our wedding celebration and our guests loved it. Delivery was prompt and easy, thank you for making our day even more special!