Mikey's Pizza

611 3rd St, Crested Butte
(970) 349-1110

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Pete Shavie

Ouch, why pass that off on me?

Daniel Gottlieb

Great pizza and very friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stacy Johnson

We are a local family. We ordered take out the other night after Alpenglow. The crust couldn't have been thinner. There was a minimal amount of cheese. The toppings were sparse as well. Very disappointing to see a great pizza joint slip so far.

Food: 1

Janet Bortot

Off the beaten path in CB, making it a perfect location to get a homemade pizza! The Gluten free crust was delicious, and though there was a wait, it was well worth it in the end. It was obvious this was where the locals got their pizza, so we knew it would be great.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oleg Uryasev

Great pizza. Super nice guy. By the slice is probably the best deal in CB.

Sarah Spears

This place is great! You can stop by and just buy a single slice or you can buy a whole pizza! The pizza is really good and the single slices are pretty big and filling. It has really cute outside seating the seats are made out of skis which fits the vibe and its a very chill atmosphere. Its also great if you just want to take a pizza home. However if you are looking to sit inside, this is not your place. Also the pizza is really good and the single slices are pretty big. The man that was working there I assume he owns it, he was very nice also.

Jack Cullinan

Not a place that will develop a lot of atmosphere. To small. Food is great though

Baba Fletch

The calzones are very generously sized. The red sauce had a lot of flavor and complexity for a walkup joint. Easy order, easy delivery. The salad dressing was Ken's (not homemade) but did the job, and the greens were fresh.

D T

Delicious pizza at a great price! The slices are huge and the staff is super friendly.

John Edge

Dudes rock slices, yo!

Calen Anderson

Good location and food

Tim Alvarado

NY style pizza that would make you think you were in NY.

Gabriel Myers

Pizza was always pretty good

Mandy Vaux

WARNING This restaurant is the worst place to get food I have ever been to. The food looks and tastes like dog food. I wouldn't even feed it to my dog.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Large Slice of Pizza, Shell Pasta w Marinara

Cam Thomas

Got a delicious hot slice of cheese pizza that was bomb and then a cheesesteak extreme and a white cc macadamia cookie. Everything was fresh and fire.

Vegetarian options: Good food

Parking: Pull up walked my pup and pull out

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Large Slice of Pizza, The Cheesesteak Extreme

Loading...