I can’t say enough about how great this place is! Great food, great service (Grahme) was the best Server. Gave local info, attentive and always kept drinks full. Congrats to the success of a great business!
Jase Krstic
I’m unsure what to say, I was SO excited to come back after a long time and I’m sad to say that the food was just okay, they pump out zas like nobody’s business but that amount of flow is reflected in the quality of the food. Feels quick. The atmosphere doesn’t feel the same either, it feels as though money became more important than passion. Service was fantastic but food and atmosphere was lacking. 40 dollars for a mid pizza. FORTY
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Aïa Moallemi-Skaf
Bad pizza. That’s it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Peter
This is some damn fine pizza. The prices suck but what else is new?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Grahm Ski
Did got good pizza and they have polite and respectful people working there I didn't go for the food or drink I was actually meeting somebody there to buy a vehicle give me some pizza and he's very cordial he's very nice and the pizza was good definitely will stop in there for a social call in the future
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Nelae Steele
Toppings on pizza lacking flavor and volume. Dough is good. Obnoxiously priced and lacked quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Chris Geltz
Unique bar/restaurant in Crested Butte. Margaritas were very bland, tasted like all mix and no tequila.. My wife thought pizza was too salty. Decor was interesting. Service was almost too attentive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Doris Rigoni
We have been eating at Secret Stash every time we visit CB (1-2x/year) for a decade. This past trip, the service and vibe was horrible. The server rushed us, was rude and frankly, was an entitled server who was unappreciative of a 16% tip when our waters were not even refilled. She was rude to the point to start an argument with one of our party about what she thinks she should have been tipped (noting that guest leave $1,000 to them). I cannot image why anyone would for the absolutely unpleasant experience. Won’t come back here again as the vibe is not what it used to be.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Sol
Although we waited a little! It wasn't too much for the number of people there! Delicious food and very friendly service✨ One of the places that is pleasant to return to 🫶🏼
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
vijay kumar
Had very bad experience staff They don't give u correct information abt. What they serve. They are rude after the service. They don't care for the tourists
I read so many positive reviews of this place and for the life of me, cannot figure out why. The pizza is subpar at best, fries are your average pub fry, nothing special, and fried pickles are more flavorless batter than pickle. I am convinced people who claim this is the best pizza/fried pickle in Colorado have never eaten anywhere else in Colorado. The staff was friendly enough but quite nonchalant and clearly didn’t try too hard to make a good impression. Another server came by before we were seen saying she was so ready to leave, asking me to pass back and forth the basket with the utensils and napkins so she could complete her side work. All in all, fine place to grab food but just know you’re not getting anything special by any means.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
amber mercer
Meh! Awesome atmosphere but it took an hour and a half after being seated (before 5pm) to get our pizza. We had two young kids with us and totally understand it’s a small mountain town during busy season but the wait should have been communicated up front. Server only checked in with us once the entire time and never thought to check on our pizza for us. When it finally came we asked for it to go and told him we’d been waiting 1.5hrs and he told us this was standard during this time of year. When we got the pizza home it hardly had any toppings on it. Not worth the long wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Christina Fischer
We ordered pizza. Pricey for sure but fresh and extremely good. I would have given 5 stars on the food. However, my leftovers that I took back left some disappointment. One of my slices had a blond hair baked into it. 😵💫🤢 I guess the darker lighting serves a purpose. 2 people $140 and that's without an appetizer nor dessert! 2 beers and a fancy lemonade for drinks. Nothing too outrageous.
Recommended dishes: Pizza Ever
Kelly Joy
Cool vibe - pizzas are expensive - considering it’s just pizza - the Buddha bowl was awful, too much cheese, and sauce , way too salty and poorly presented looked like vomit in a plate. It’s running off it’s reputation , not sure how long that will last
Kid-friendliness: Great with the kids
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Gabriel Myers
Overpriced, gross pies. Doughy and undercooked in the middle. When you pick up a slice all the toppings slide off like a wet pile of shit. Do yourself a favor and go to Mikey’s instead.
I can’t say enough about how great this place is! Great food, great service (Grahme) was the best Server. Gave local info, attentive and always kept drinks full. Congrats to the success of a great business!
I’m unsure what to say, I was SO excited to come back after a long time and I’m sad to say that the food was just okay, they pump out zas like nobody’s business but that amount of flow is reflected in the quality of the food. Feels quick. The atmosphere doesn’t feel the same either, it feels as though money became more important than passion. Service was fantastic but food and atmosphere was lacking. 40 dollars for a mid pizza. FORTY
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Bad pizza. That’s it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
This is some damn fine pizza. The prices suck but what else is new?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Did got good pizza and they have polite and respectful people working there I didn't go for the food or drink I was actually meeting somebody there to buy a vehicle give me some pizza and he's very cordial he's very nice and the pizza was good definitely will stop in there for a social call in the future
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Toppings on pizza lacking flavor and volume. Dough is good. Obnoxiously priced and lacked quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Unique bar/restaurant in Crested Butte. Margaritas were very bland, tasted like all mix and no tequila.. My wife thought pizza was too salty. Decor was interesting. Service was almost too attentive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
We have been eating at Secret Stash every time we visit CB (1-2x/year) for a decade. This past trip, the service and vibe was horrible. The server rushed us, was rude and frankly, was an entitled server who was unappreciative of a 16% tip when our waters were not even refilled. She was rude to the point to start an argument with one of our party about what she thinks she should have been tipped (noting that guest leave $1,000 to them). I cannot image why anyone would for the absolutely unpleasant experience. Won’t come back here again as the vibe is not what it used to be.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Although we waited a little! It wasn't too much for the number of people there! Delicious food and very friendly service✨
One of the places that is pleasant to return to 🫶🏼
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Had very bad experience staff They don't give u correct information abt. What they serve. They are rude after the service. They don't care for the tourists
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I read so many positive reviews of this place and for the life of me, cannot figure out why. The pizza is subpar at best, fries are your average pub fry, nothing special, and fried pickles are more flavorless batter than pickle. I am convinced people who claim this is the best pizza/fried pickle in Colorado have never eaten anywhere else in Colorado. The staff was friendly enough but quite nonchalant and clearly didn’t try too hard to make a good impression. Another server came by before we were seen saying she was so ready to leave, asking me to pass back and forth the basket with the utensils and napkins so she could complete her side work. All in all, fine place to grab food but just know you’re not getting anything special by any means.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Meh! Awesome atmosphere but it took an hour and a half after being seated (before 5pm) to get our pizza. We had two young kids with us and totally understand it’s a small mountain town during busy season but the wait should have been communicated up front. Server only checked in with us once the entire time and never thought to check on our pizza for us. When it finally came we asked for it to go and told him we’d been waiting 1.5hrs and he told us this was standard during this time of year. When we got the pizza home it hardly had any toppings on it. Not worth the long wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
We ordered pizza. Pricey for sure but fresh and extremely good.
I would have given 5 stars on the food. However, my leftovers that I took back left some disappointment. One of my slices had a blond hair baked into it. 😵💫🤢
I guess the darker lighting serves a purpose. 2 people $140 and that's without an appetizer nor dessert! 2 beers and a fancy lemonade for drinks. Nothing too outrageous.
Recommended dishes: Pizza Ever
Cool vibe - pizzas are expensive - considering it’s just pizza - the Buddha bowl was awful, too much cheese, and sauce , way too salty and poorly presented looked like vomit in a plate. It’s running off it’s reputation , not sure how long that will last
Kid-friendliness: Great with the kids
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Overpriced, gross pies. Doughy and undercooked in the middle. When you pick up a slice all the toppings slide off like a wet pile of shit. Do yourself a favor and go to Mikey’s instead.
Loading...