I come here often since it's in front of my home... But when the male bartender is there, he always forgets my order or forgets I'm even there because he's so busy talking to friends.
But when the young female bartender is there, I get great service.
Pizza and wings are good. Mozarella sticks are great.
Bread is mediocre and Mac and cheese is cold and awful
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
LMS
Location at Colorado Blvd and 7th Ave is amazing! We have only utilized delivery service for a family of 7 They go out of their way for customer service, always answer the phone, helpful, polite, and on time! Food quality and quantity is excellent. The entire staff is wonderful. Thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lilliam Roman
Pitzza slice so big!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicholas Jones
Amazing pizza and beer selection, but the service is the best part of coming here. We just moved to this neighborhood and Elena “AAA” gave such amazing service and made us feel at home. Looking forward to becoming regulars here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hero Sub, Pepperoni Pizza
Dom Bel
Not the Same Anthony’s Pizza I’m Used To
I’ve been a loyal Anthony’s Pizza fan for the past 15 years, with the last seven spent ordering from this location. One of the things I’ve always appreciated about Anthony’s is their high-quality ingredients, great pizza, and consistent flavor.
Unfortunately, my recent visit was a letdown. I ordered my usual—a large cheese pizza—but something just felt off from the first bite. The sauce tasted different, almost too salty, and the overall combination of sauce, cheese, and crust just didn’t work. Even my son noticed it and said it didn’t taste quite right.
I called the store to see if they had changed the sauce recipe, but the person I spoke to wasn’t sure.
It might have just been an off day for them, and I’m willing to give Anthony’s another chance because of my past experiences. But honestly, I was disappointed this time around. Here’s hoping the next visit brings back the flavor and quality I’ve come to expect.
Food: 2
Service: 4
Brian Clancy
Great pizza, cold beer and plenty of both! Good staff, very attentive, and a friendly atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sara Moon Murphy (Mooners)
Great place to eat laguna!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
Jared DePalma
This pizza spot needs to learn how to make dough properly. Like most pizza shops on the Colorado front range, there is zero pride in this slice. floppy floppy floppy and Covered in grease. If I was Dave Portnoy I’d give this pizza a 4.2 / 10.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Real Deal
OK, so I was here once ever about six years ago and my first review is below This paragraph This place is a disgrace yet again, more specifically, the staff or at least the only staff member I was dealing with this time They should be doing way better for the area and how it’s growing. I would go an extra mile to buy pizza somewhere else then this Location. The arrogant owner or employee was so busy chewing food did not have enough decency to even greet me or the other customer just proceeded to ring up Food with a mouthful. I had a driver for delivery come in before me and he was arrogant to her as well. Made me feel uncomfortable as a customer. Your pizza isn’t good enough to have that poor customer service you got a second chance never again do not recommend. If you saw the employees you would loose your appetite as I did mine. The girl employee in there had shorts so far up her rear you can see every crease and roll she had. So inappropriate for a restaurant not to mention it looks like she wore these shorts all week, they were filthy. The pizza was heated to much, the crust was like cardboard cracking with every bend. I was served a to go box even though I planned to eat there but was never asked. So i had to ask for a plate napkins and pepper. I was given one packet of pepper and three napkins which i had to soak the grease off the pizza. Based on the reviews it looks like the owner doesnt give a s%/! About that place GROSS
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jordan LiVolsi
Go to the Anthony’s by DU it’s better. The service at this place sucks and they don’t know how to make pizza at this location
Not sure what changed but the pizza I ordered was worse than frozen pizza and the wings were tiny and not crispy at all
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Carlos Mora
We have been looking for a pizza joint that sold pizza by the slice since our old spot went OOB (insert sad face). Anthony's took care of a group of eight kids and two adults without blinking twice. Price is reasonable and food delicious. Staff was super friendly and had a great sense of humor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stefan Mastin
I love this place but the last 2 times my family has ordered from this location the pizza has had no sauce on it at all is like they didn't even attempt to put it on there
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Anneliesa Cappelli
When I picked up my pepperoni pizza ordered online & discovered pepperoni UNDER the cheese, it was unappetizing to me. I was very surprised because if you order a pepperoni pizza by the slice in the very same store, you get it done the New York way (pep "on top") & its great.
So I handed back my untouched pie & asked them to do it over with pepperoni on top. Seems to me a reasonable request to expect product consistency. Website makes no reference to putting the pepperoni under the cheese. An easy ask, an easy fix one might expect.
Instead I got an argument from the manager Dan, who was interested only in a monologue about how they do things - which is...to sum up..if you order a pepperoni pie you get the opposite presentation than if you order a slice. Their attitude is - If you aren't happy about this 180, too bad!! I'm amazed at how rudely he treated me and my friend. Instead of listening he adopted a combative defensive attitude, revealing that if he ever knew anything about customer service, its been long forgotten.
Truth is, I'm not into spending $25 on a pizza & instead of getting something good to eat, I get a lecture from a bully "manager".
All Dan had to do from the get-go was say "I'm sorry let me do it over for you!!" & perhaps suggest to management to add something on the website to alert customers to this 180 situation at the point of ordering. Judging from his reaction, this is not the first complaint he has had on this topic.
Don't shoot the messenger / customer!! It seems to me that management & staff would benefit from a trip to New York and learn that its NOT the New York style to put pepperoni under the cheese. Is that even the style anywhere ??
Too bad as Anthony's USED to be my favorite pizza place & I was loyal to it, & and often overruled my family's preference for Blue Pan, who bends over backwards making sure you are more than happy. I'll be going there from now on. They make a great pizza plus they know where to put the pepperoni!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Anneliesa Barta
Come ON!! It's NOT New York style to put pepperoni UNDER THE CHEESE. That would be a stromboli. Capisce?? I mean, if you are going to ruin pepperoni at least give unsuspecting people a heads up when ordering. I ordered the pie online but I know the last time I walked in and ordered a slice the pepperoni was on top.... I.e. normal. Ok this New Yorker is passionate about pizza & I asked them to re-do it and the manager gave me a hassle. Unacceptable. Hence the low rating which is well-deserved just because of the bad attitude but pizza is ordinary great. Just beware of pepperoni placement.
I come here often since it's in front of my home... But when the male bartender is there, he always forgets my order or forgets I'm even there because he's so busy talking to friends.
But when the young female bartender is there, I get great service.
Pizza and wings are good. Mozarella sticks are great.
Bread is mediocre and Mac and cheese is cold and awful
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Location at Colorado Blvd and 7th Ave is amazing!
We have only utilized delivery service for a family of 7
They go out of their way for customer service, always answer the phone, helpful, polite, and on time! Food quality and quantity is excellent. The entire staff is wonderful. Thank you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pitzza slice so big!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pizza and beer selection, but the service is the best part of coming here. We just moved to this neighborhood and Elena “AAA” gave such amazing service and made us feel at home. Looking forward to becoming regulars here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hero Sub, Pepperoni Pizza
Not the Same Anthony’s Pizza I’m Used To
I’ve been a loyal Anthony’s Pizza fan for the past 15 years, with the last seven spent ordering from this location. One of the things I’ve always appreciated about Anthony’s is their high-quality ingredients, great pizza, and consistent flavor.
Unfortunately, my recent visit was a letdown. I ordered my usual—a large cheese pizza—but something just felt off from the first bite. The sauce tasted different, almost too salty, and the overall combination of sauce, cheese, and crust just didn’t work. Even my son noticed it and said it didn’t taste quite right.
I called the store to see if they had changed the sauce recipe, but the person I spoke to wasn’t sure.
It might have just been an off day for them, and I’m willing to give Anthony’s another chance because of my past experiences. But honestly, I was disappointed this time around. Here’s hoping the next visit brings back the flavor and quality I’ve come to expect.
Food: 2
Service: 4
Great pizza, cold beer and plenty of both! Good staff, very attentive, and a friendly atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place to eat laguna!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
This pizza spot needs to learn how to make dough properly. Like most pizza shops on the Colorado front range, there is zero pride in this slice. floppy floppy floppy and Covered in grease. If I was Dave Portnoy I’d give this pizza a 4.2 / 10.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
OK, so I was here once ever about six years ago and my first review is below This paragraph
This place is a disgrace yet again, more specifically, the staff or at least the only staff member I was dealing with this time
They should be doing way better for the area and how it’s growing. I would go an extra mile to buy pizza somewhere else then this Location. The arrogant owner or employee was so busy chewing food did not have enough decency to even greet me or the other customer just proceeded to ring up Food with a mouthful. I had a driver for delivery come in before me and he was arrogant to her as well. Made me feel uncomfortable as a customer. Your pizza isn’t good enough to have that poor customer service you got a second chance never again do not recommend.
If you saw the employees you would loose your appetite as I did mine. The girl employee in there had shorts so far up her rear you can see every crease and roll she had. So inappropriate for a restaurant not to mention it looks like she wore these shorts all week, they were filthy. The pizza was heated to much, the crust was like cardboard cracking with every bend.
I was served a to go box even though I planned to eat there but was never asked. So i had to ask for a plate napkins and pepper. I was given one packet of pepper and three napkins which i had to soak the grease off the pizza. Based on the reviews it looks like the owner doesnt give a s%/! About that place GROSS
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Go to the Anthony’s by DU it’s better. The service at this place sucks and they don’t know how to make pizza at this location
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Not sure what changed but the pizza I ordered was worse than frozen pizza and the wings were tiny and not crispy at all
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
We have been looking for a pizza joint that sold pizza by the slice since our old spot went OOB (insert sad face). Anthony's took care of a group of eight kids and two adults without blinking twice. Price is reasonable and food delicious. Staff was super friendly and had a great sense of humor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love this place but the last 2 times my family has ordered from this location the pizza has had no sauce on it at all is like they didn't even attempt to put it on there
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
When I picked up my pepperoni pizza ordered online & discovered pepperoni UNDER the cheese, it was unappetizing to me. I was very surprised because if you order a pepperoni pizza by the slice in the very same store, you get it done the New York way (pep "on top") & its great.
So I handed back my untouched pie & asked them to do it over with pepperoni on top. Seems to me a reasonable request to expect product consistency. Website makes no reference to putting the pepperoni under the cheese. An easy ask, an easy fix one might expect.
Instead I got an argument from the manager Dan, who was interested only in a monologue about how they do things - which is...to sum up..if you order a pepperoni pie you get the opposite presentation than if you order a slice. Their attitude is - If you aren't happy about this 180, too bad!! I'm amazed at how rudely he treated me and my friend. Instead of listening he adopted a combative defensive attitude, revealing that if he ever knew anything about customer service, its been long forgotten.
Truth is, I'm not into spending $25 on a pizza & instead of getting something good to eat, I get a lecture from a bully "manager".
All Dan had to do from the get-go was say "I'm sorry let me do it over for you!!" & perhaps suggest to management to add something on the website to alert customers to this 180 situation at the point of ordering. Judging from his reaction, this is not the first complaint he has had on this topic.
Don't shoot the messenger / customer!! It seems to me that management & staff would benefit from a trip to New York and learn that its NOT the New York style to put pepperoni under the cheese. Is that even the style anywhere ??
Too bad as Anthony's USED to be my favorite pizza place & I was loyal to it, & and often overruled my family's preference for Blue Pan, who bends over backwards making sure you are more than happy. I'll be going there from now on. They make a great pizza plus they know where to put the pepperoni!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Come ON!! It's NOT New York style to put pepperoni UNDER THE CHEESE. That would be a stromboli. Capisce?? I mean, if you are going to ruin pepperoni at least give unsuspecting people a heads up when ordering. I ordered the pie online but I know the last time I walked in and ordered a slice the pepperoni was on top.... I.e. normal. Ok this New Yorker is passionate about pizza & I asked them to re-do it and the manager gave me a hassle. Unacceptable. Hence the low rating which is well-deserved just because of the bad attitude but pizza is ordinary great. Just beware of pepperoni placement.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Loading...