Consistently excellent NY style pizza. A nice slightly sweet but not overwhelmingly tangy sauce and mozzarella that is creamy and not too greasy. Crust is crispy and light. Nothing fancy but this location puts out some of the best pizza in the Denver metro.
Peter Turner
The pizza here is just bad. Ordered a small bacon and onion, the dough was undercooked, and the sauce tastes like straight tomatoes. Never going here again.
Shawn curtin
How to take a break from my wife's procedures at Porter hospital only place I could find that I could afford. The lady working there help me out immensely.
Alejandro Villavicencio
Their pizza is absolutely amazing! I recently moved to the neighborhood and can say I found my pizza. Great service too! I think my delivery driver was Andy.
jo winget
This food made me sick, tasted like cold diarrhea in a Dixie cup 🥤😅turned my stomach 😫worst pizza I've ever eaten a nightmare of epic proportion I'm shocked such an owner would allow this dumpster fire to continue operating under their logo we can only hope that when the incompetent employees Burn this disgusting vile greasy repugnant excuse for a Roch trap down It does minimum property damage to nearby establishments. I dare the owner to explain the trash experience and food to me and others without making excuses 🙃 , 2025 never got better sad
Derek Berardi
The food is fine, but it's very unfortunate that you can't call to talk to an actual staff member. I was ordering food for a large group. I wanted to call to confirm the order since it said Anthony's opens at 11am and I'd made an order for 11:20am. There's an option when you call to talk to a person. I called multiple times and every time I selected to talk to a person, the system hung up on me. Beyond that, day of, there was no reminder or confirmation sent to me about the status of the order. You need to make yourself available to your customers. I wouldn't recommend this for catering. There's low dependability.
Debbie Walker
Dashed dinner tonight. Ordered chicken Alfredo and chicken parm. Breaded chicken is juicy and well seasoned. Sauces were bland and could have come out of a jar. Garlic bread was dense and hard to eat, but flavorful. Food arrived hot! Brownies are prepackaged.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Ted Gwathmey
I went to DU and still live in the area. Anthony's is an institution, but the current management has destroyed it. I called in to order, and the answering system hangs up on you. Then you get a text to order online. Okay, but you can't order and show up to pay in cash. You have to pay by card. It looks like they cut back staff, because the 3 guys working there couldn't keep up. We usually order from Anthony's once a week. I'll try again in a few weeks, but they are still using that automated system and you still can't order and pay in cash when you pick up, they won't be seeing anyone in my family again.
Addendum- despite the reply I got saying it was a glitch, I tried to order a pizza tonight, and whoever is answering the phone just picks up and hangs up. Anthony's is broken. Too much of a hassle to order food. I'm done.
Shirley Herman
Craving a good pizza. Found it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Jazmine Owens
Food was fantastic. We dined in and the older guy with the ponytail behind the counter was incredibly rude. We could hear him loudly mocking and insulting other customers who had been waiting for take out when we placed our order, calling them stupid and angry about the fact that someone had arrived 20 minutes early. When we got our order, I thought we were missing a slice and it turned out I hadn’t ordered it. I simply asked the cashier/waiter whether or not we ordered it and they went and asked the kitchen, where I heard the guy with the ponytail yell at the waiter “SHE GETS WHAT SHE PAID FOR.” Yes, that’s why I asked if we actually ordered it. When would you ever think that talking negatively and loudly about customers when other customers can hear you would be okay? Incredibly unprofessional. The other staff were great and attentive.
I am so sad as I write this review. Anthony’s has been my favorite NY-style pizza in Denver since 2001. Their delivery guys are wonderful, always on time and the pizza - hot! But the last several meals have been extremely disappointing. I would give Anthony’s one star if not for the nice people that work there. It’s the end of an era and I’m very sad.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Ronald E Robbins
Really good pizza - it's literally my go to pizza spot. But why is the guy at the cash register such a jerk? The last 5 times I came in the guy always has an attitude and it's getting really old. I couldn't imagine working with him. Overall morale from the other employees has dropped over recent months causing us to dine less. I really hope the manager does something about it.
Ordered takeout September 8th at 7PM. He tends to work the night shift...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
LaNesha Mitchell
The pizza was ok. It used to be delicious though. I just got slices, but I would've just gotten cheese. The meatballs that were added on were processed and I took all of them off. The customer service was awkward, but the dining area was nice. The pizza was soggy and I expected it to be crunchy. I don't think I will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
James Nicholas
Love the family atmosphere
Kid-friendliness: Great place to celebrate kids sports!
Consistently excellent NY style pizza. A nice slightly sweet but not overwhelmingly tangy sauce and mozzarella that is creamy and not too greasy. Crust is crispy and light. Nothing fancy but this location puts out some of the best pizza in the Denver metro.
The pizza here is just bad. Ordered a small bacon and onion, the dough was undercooked, and the sauce tastes like straight tomatoes. Never going here again.
How to take a break from my wife's procedures at Porter hospital only place I could find that I could afford. The lady working there help me out immensely.
Their pizza is absolutely amazing! I recently moved to the neighborhood and can say I found my pizza. Great service too! I think my delivery driver was Andy.
This food made me sick, tasted like cold diarrhea in a Dixie cup 🥤😅turned my stomach 😫worst pizza I've ever eaten a nightmare of epic proportion I'm shocked such an owner would allow this dumpster fire to continue operating under their logo we can only hope that when the incompetent employees Burn this disgusting vile greasy repugnant excuse for a Roch trap down
It does minimum property damage to nearby establishments. I dare the owner to explain the trash experience and food to me and others without making excuses 🙃 , 2025 never got better sad
The food is fine, but it's very unfortunate that you can't call to talk to an actual staff member. I was ordering food for a large group. I wanted to call to confirm the order since it said Anthony's opens at 11am and I'd made an order for 11:20am. There's an option when you call to talk to a person. I called multiple times and every time I selected to talk to a person, the system hung up on me. Beyond that, day of, there was no reminder or confirmation sent to me about the status of the order. You need to make yourself available to your customers. I wouldn't recommend this for catering. There's low dependability.
Dashed dinner tonight. Ordered chicken Alfredo and chicken parm. Breaded chicken is juicy and well seasoned. Sauces were bland and could have come out of a jar. Garlic bread was dense and hard to eat, but flavorful. Food arrived hot! Brownies are prepackaged.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I went to DU and still live in the area. Anthony's is an institution, but the current management has destroyed it. I called in to order, and the answering system hangs up on you. Then you get a text to order online. Okay, but you can't order and show up to pay in cash. You have to pay by card. It looks like they cut back staff, because the 3 guys working there couldn't keep up. We usually order from Anthony's once a week. I'll try again in a few weeks, but they are still using that automated system and you still can't order and pay in cash when you pick up, they won't be seeing anyone in my family again.
Addendum- despite the reply I got saying it was a glitch, I tried to order a pizza tonight, and whoever is answering the phone just picks up and hangs up. Anthony's is broken. Too much of a hassle to order food. I'm done.
Craving a good pizza. Found it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Food was fantastic. We dined in and the older guy with the ponytail behind the counter was incredibly rude. We could hear him loudly mocking and insulting other customers who had been waiting for take out when we placed our order, calling them stupid and angry about the fact that someone had arrived 20 minutes early.
When we got our order, I thought we were missing a slice and it turned out I hadn’t ordered it. I simply asked the cashier/waiter whether or not we ordered it and they went and asked the kitchen, where I heard the guy with the ponytail yell at the waiter “SHE GETS WHAT SHE PAID FOR.” Yes, that’s why I asked if we actually ordered it.
When would you ever think that talking negatively and loudly about customers when other customers can hear you would be okay? Incredibly unprofessional.
The other staff were great and attentive.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Beautiful people with beautiful pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am so sad as I write this review. Anthony’s has been my favorite NY-style pizza in Denver since 2001. Their delivery guys are wonderful, always on time and the pizza - hot! But the last several meals have been extremely disappointing. I would give Anthony’s one star if not for the nice people that work there.
It’s the end of an era and I’m very sad.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Really good pizza - it's literally my go to pizza spot. But why is the guy at the cash register such a jerk? The last 5 times I came in the guy always has an attitude and it's getting really old. I couldn't imagine working with him. Overall morale from the other employees has dropped over recent months causing us to dine less. I really hope the manager does something about it.
Ordered takeout September 8th at 7PM. He tends to work the night shift...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
The pizza was ok. It used to be delicious though. I just got slices, but I would've just gotten cheese. The meatballs that were added on were processed and I took all of them off. The customer service was awkward, but the dining area was nice. The pizza was soggy and I expected it to be crunchy. I don't think I will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
Love the family atmosphere
Kid-friendliness: Great place to celebrate kids sports!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
Loading...