From NC working a yearly tradeshow, and asked some locals who has the best NY pie downtown...and it was slammin'. Will 100% be my go-to pizza place each year I'm in town.Ordered delivery as well to my hotel.(The ranch is also really good)
Food: 5
Service: 5
J. Traveler
Fat Sully's pizza. Denver Colorado. Off Broadway. Excellent network style pizza. Great beer also enjoyed spruce tip IPA , by upslope brewery.Pizza slice x 21.) Sausage, mushrooms2.) garlic and extra cheese3.) Feta + sausage4.) Anchovies + extra cheese.Highly recommended. Great place for a Friday wind downWheelchair accessibility: Yes they are compliant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Salad, Balsamic Vinaigrette Dip, Loaded Garlic Knots
Heather Fishburn
After waiting an extra 30 minutes for my pizza, turned out to be extra well done.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Jen Kaufman
i know this is a pizza place but the cheeseburger is insanely good. love it everytime (even after walking it home for 10-15 mins-still so good)!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burgers
Austin Friend
Very intimate setting, lighting perfect, music not too loud. Great place for a first date meet and get to know each other. Unfortunately my date didn’t go well, but I’ll definitely try again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Johnny U.
Where else can you go in Denver and have three different restaurants /bar in one place? Start off in the morning at the Denver biscuit Company, slide into lunch and dinner, and Wala you turn into Fat Sullys! Slide the atomic cowboy in for drinks and You have pretty good concept. Since we're focusing on fat Solae's, let's just say you have to get the large pizza. When I say large were talking a 26 inch pizza. Unfortunately you can't get this to go but I don't think I would wanna eat this pizza anywhere else. Pair it with a salad and you're set to go.
MilenaMega
The pizza here is amazing! My favorite spot for a late night snack.Recommend ordering the garlic knots, the dips that comes with it is absolutely amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Loaded Garlic Knots
Jade
Went here to get some food tonight and the guy with the glasses and tattoos was very rude from the beginning. First he asked “what can I do for you?” in a rude tone and before I could finish my first word he cut me off and then said “can I get a name?” again rude tone. Finally, when I handed him my card to pay he snatched it from me and couldn’t even hand it back to me, he just left it on the counter. No need to be rude to customers who have been nothing but polite and are paying money here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Aditya Anand
The pizza is decent. Nothing to write home about. I'm from Jersey and while it does fill my thin crust needs, it doesn't make me go WOW.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Zac Bianco
Cool spot. Ordered from the window and was served quick. Little generic tasting to me. Great staff. Good for a drunk bite.
Absolutely amazing pizza! This place totally hits the spot. They have a large selection of toppings to pick from to customers your slice to perfection. The chipotle ranch is AMAZING. I order a side of it every time I get a slice. The service is pretty quick for making custom slices fresh. The walk up window is excellent when you're strolling down Broadway and want a slice on your way to find a beer at a local drinkery. Or, stop in and get a drink here! They have a full bar. The employees are always friendly and helpful. I've been coming here for years and the food continues to be consistent time after time. Don't change anything!
Shelby S.
This place is pretty good. I'm a sucker for a good Caesar salad. I ended up getting a big slice of pizza as well as a Caesar then two drinks as well. All the food was good and the atmosphere is cool. Only down side I would say is that our food took FOREVER to come out. I think we had been there for an hour before we even got our food. Total of my meal came out to about $30 which is decent for a slice of pizza, a big salad, and two drinks.
Tony M.
$6 beer and shot on a Sunday afternoon is a necessity. Their wings and smash burger are absolutely delicious as well. A great vibes pretty slow night. Their caesar salad is delicious as well. The pizza was perfectly done. Super crispy. Best location out of all of them imo.
Marina V.
Extraordinarily overpriced. Wait time for a single pizza was almost an hour after ordering. Pizza was mediocre at best. Total for one pizza and 2 drinks was $70. Insane. Definitely do not recommend.
Andrew William
Came from nyc: this is the best and most similar to nyc pizza in Denver. My favorite.
From NC working a yearly tradeshow, and asked some locals who has the best NY pie downtown...and it was slammin'. Will 100% be my go-to pizza place each year I'm in town.Ordered delivery as well to my hotel.(The ranch is also really good)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fat Sully's pizza. Denver Colorado. Off Broadway. Excellent network style pizza. Great beer also enjoyed spruce tip IPA , by upslope brewery.Pizza slice x 21.) Sausage, mushrooms2.) garlic and extra cheese3.) Feta + sausage4.) Anchovies + extra cheese.Highly recommended. Great place for a Friday wind downWheelchair accessibility: Yes they are compliant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Salad, Balsamic Vinaigrette Dip, Loaded Garlic Knots
After waiting an extra 30 minutes for my pizza, turned out to be extra well done.
Food: 1
Service: 5
i know this is a pizza place but the cheeseburger is insanely good. love it everytime (even after walking it home for 10-15 mins-still so good)!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burgers
Very intimate setting, lighting perfect, music not too loud. Great place for a first date meet and get to know each other. Unfortunately my date didn’t go well, but I’ll definitely try again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Where else can you go in Denver and have three different restaurants /bar in one place? Start off in the morning at the Denver biscuit Company, slide into lunch and dinner, and Wala you turn into Fat Sullys! Slide the atomic cowboy in for drinks and You have pretty good concept. Since we're focusing on fat Solae's, let's just say you have to get the large pizza. When I say large were talking a 26 inch pizza. Unfortunately you can't get this to go but I don't think I would wanna eat this pizza anywhere else. Pair it with a salad and you're set to go.
The pizza here is amazing! My favorite spot for a late night snack.Recommend ordering the garlic knots, the dips that comes with it is absolutely amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Loaded Garlic Knots
Went here to get some food tonight and the guy with the glasses and tattoos was very rude from the beginning. First he asked “what can I do for you?” in a rude tone and before I could finish my first word he cut me off and then said “can I get a name?” again rude tone. Finally, when I handed him my card to pay he snatched it from me and couldn’t even hand it back to me, he just left it on the counter. No need to be rude to customers who have been nothing but polite and are paying money here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
The pizza is decent. Nothing to write home about. I'm from Jersey and while it does fill my thin crust needs, it doesn't make me go WOW.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Cool spot. Ordered from the window and was served quick. Little generic tasting to me. Great staff. Good for a drunk bite.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely amazing pizza! This place totally hits the spot. They have a large selection of toppings to pick from to customers your slice to perfection. The chipotle ranch is AMAZING. I order a side of it every time I get a slice. The service is pretty quick for making custom slices fresh. The walk up window is excellent when you're strolling down Broadway and want a slice on your way to find a beer at a local drinkery. Or, stop in and get a drink here! They have a full bar. The employees are always friendly and helpful. I've been coming here for years and the food continues to be consistent time after time. Don't change anything!
This place is pretty good. I'm a sucker for a good Caesar salad. I ended up getting a big slice of pizza as well as a Caesar then two drinks as well. All the food was good and the atmosphere is cool. Only down side I would say is that our food took FOREVER to come out. I think we had been there for an hour before we even got our food. Total of my meal came out to about $30 which is decent for a slice of pizza, a big salad, and two drinks.
$6 beer and shot on a Sunday afternoon is a necessity. Their wings and smash burger are absolutely delicious as well. A great vibes pretty slow night. Their caesar salad is delicious as well. The pizza was perfectly done. Super crispy. Best location out of all of them imo.
Extraordinarily overpriced. Wait time for a single pizza was almost an hour after ordering. Pizza was mediocre at best. Total for one pizza and 2 drinks was $70. Insane. Definitely do not recommend.
Came from nyc: this is the best and most similar to nyc pizza in Denver. My favorite.