My family has been here probably five times, we always bring family from out of town to visit this quaint restaurant with wonderful service. However, our visit last week was so disappointing. The server, not the usual adorable waitress from New Hampshire who is half the reason we go to Jimmy's, delivered our drinks 30 minutes after we ordered them and actually forgot one of our drinks. The food arrived after a full hour's wait and the server didn't even apologize. We were very hungry after waiting that long and my daughter couldn't believe that after that wait her spaghetti was cold! She sent it back. It was embarrassing that we subjected our visiting aunt and uncle to this experience. We will certainly think twice before coming back.
Keli K.
Cute enough from the outside. Servers trying their best. Food underwhelming and seemed to be mainly sourced from jars I could buy at World Market. Bill for 1 glass of wine, 1/2 beet salad, and sea bass special = 74.00 I won't be going back-
Alex Porter
The pasta is delicious and the service superb. Small but mighty wine list with reasonable prices. The Alfredo is amazing. Soup salad bread with your meal. It's how good restaurants used to be, and Jimmy's is just that, a solid restaurant. Finish with the flambe bananas foster for a great show.
Carlos is an excellent server. Very knowledgeable about the menu. The food was "Delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephen Johnson
Great little bit of New York in this place. Jimmy has done a great job with his new restaurant. Would highly recommend for nice casual dinner with friends and family. Will definitely be returning soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cliff Murphey
One of my favorite spots and the food is amazing! Worth a stop if you’re in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jean Fisher
The first time we ate here, about 6 months ago, the food was exquisite. The next 2 times, it was not as good—merely average. The waitstaff is lovely and they do have gluten free options. But the red sauce tastes almost like tomato paste straight out of the can. The first time the offer of Parmesan involved fresh cheese grated on top, but now the server brings over a shaker of Parmesan to the table.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
tomcat
Has a nice neighborhood restaurant feel. Jimmy used to have one of my old favorite restaurants, Footer's. The food is great and even when busy the service has been top notch. I highly recommend it!
Amazing place. Great atmosphere and good service. Just right sized portions of delicious food. I was here last night and I'm back for lunch. My new favorite place in Denver! Sophia and Marilyn are the most wonderful hostess/servers you could find West of the Mississippi. Definitely recommend for a nice meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ігор Кваша
Amazing place. I haven’t eaten such good Italian food even in Italy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaitlin Booth
I had the most incredible experience with Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe recently. Jimmy personally delivered a delicious menu to my mother's birthday party. I cannot express enough how impressed and grateful I am for their exceptional service.First and foremost, the menu we received was absolutely outstanding. We ordered Linguine Primavera, Fettuccine Alfredo, and Lobster Raviolis. Each dish was prepared to perfection, showcasing the culinary expertise of the chef at Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe. The Linguine Primavera was a delightful medley of fresh vegetables, perfectly cooked pasta, and a flavorful sauce we loved. The Fettuccine Alfredo was creamy and indulgent we all enjoyed it, while the Lobster Raviolis were a true delicacy, bursting with mouthwatering flavors. The ravioli was my favorite!Accompanying our main courses, we also received Jimmy's Salad, it came with a refreshing light wine dressing. The salad was packed with delicious toppings all of our guests loved it. Additionally, the large portion of Fettuccine Buttered Noodles with a side of mini meatballs, and extra Marinara Sauce was a huge hit for the little kids. We loved the fresh garlic bread.The soup served by Jimmy's was simply exceptional. Butternut squash soup is my mother’s favorite and it was delicious we loved it.To sweeten the celebration we finished off with Cannolis.What made this experience even more special was the fact that Jimmy himself personally delivered the menu to our mother's birthday party. His warm smile, friendly demeanor, and genuine care made the occasion even more memorable. It's rare to find such personalized service and attention to detail.I cannot thank Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe enough for going above and beyond to make this celebration remarkable. The combination of delicious food, personalized service, and heartwarming gestures truly sets them apart. If you're looking to make your special occasions even more extraordinary, I highly recommend Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Whitcomb
Excellent service, great atmosphere, and I have found nothing on the menu that wasn't delicious. Great wine selection. And if you are lucky Jimmy will be in.
We were very disappointed in the food. The server was unique...difficult to understand, although with good intentions. Like the neighborhood location & energy in the restaurant; nice looking.
My family has been here probably five times, we always bring family from out of town to visit this quaint restaurant with wonderful service. However, our visit last week was so disappointing. The server, not the usual adorable waitress from New Hampshire who is half the reason we go to Jimmy's, delivered our drinks 30 minutes after we ordered them and actually forgot one of our drinks. The food arrived after a full hour's wait and the server didn't even apologize. We were very hungry after waiting that long and my daughter couldn't believe that after that wait her spaghetti was cold! She sent it back. It was embarrassing that we subjected our visiting aunt and uncle to this experience. We will certainly think twice before coming back.
Cute enough from the outside. Servers trying their best. Food underwhelming and seemed to be mainly sourced from jars I could buy at World Market. Bill for 1 glass of wine, 1/2 beet salad, and sea bass special = 74.00 I won't be going back-
The pasta is delicious and the service superb. Small but mighty wine list with reasonable prices. The Alfredo is amazing. Soup salad bread with your meal. It's how good restaurants used to be, and Jimmy's is just that, a solid restaurant. Finish with the flambe bananas foster for a great show.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo, Bananas Foster
Carlos is an excellent server. Very knowledgeable about the menu. The food was "Delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great little bit of New York in this place. Jimmy has done a great job with his new restaurant. Would highly recommend for nice casual dinner with friends and family. Will definitely be returning soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of my favorite spots and the food is amazing! Worth a stop if you’re in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The first time we ate here, about 6 months ago, the food was exquisite. The next 2 times, it was not as good—merely average. The waitstaff is lovely and they do have gluten free options. But the red sauce tastes almost like tomato paste straight out of the can. The first time the offer of Parmesan involved fresh cheese grated on top, but now the server brings over a shaker of Parmesan to the table.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Has a nice neighborhood restaurant feel. Jimmy used to have one of my old favorite restaurants, Footer's. The food is great and even when busy the service has been top notch. I highly recommend it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tenderloin Ceasar Salad, Scampi Romano, Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo, Grilled Cesar Salad
Wonderful food. Recommend the linguine with clams. Veronica is so sweet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food...could use more kitchen and wait staff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing place. Great atmosphere and good service. Just right sized portions of delicious food. I was here last night and I'm back for lunch. My new favorite place in Denver! Sophia and Marilyn are the most wonderful hostess/servers you could find West of the Mississippi. Definitely recommend for a nice meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing place. I haven’t eaten such good Italian food even in Italy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had the most incredible experience with Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe recently. Jimmy personally delivered a delicious menu to my mother's birthday party. I cannot express enough how impressed and grateful I am for their exceptional service.First and foremost, the menu we received was absolutely outstanding. We ordered Linguine Primavera, Fettuccine Alfredo, and Lobster Raviolis. Each dish was prepared to perfection, showcasing the culinary expertise of the chef at Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe. The Linguine Primavera was a delightful medley of fresh vegetables, perfectly cooked pasta, and a flavorful sauce we loved. The Fettuccine Alfredo was creamy and indulgent we all enjoyed it, while the Lobster Raviolis were a true delicacy, bursting with mouthwatering flavors. The ravioli was my favorite!Accompanying our main courses, we also received Jimmy's Salad, it came with a refreshing light wine dressing. The salad was packed with delicious toppings all of our guests loved it. Additionally, the large portion of Fettuccine Buttered Noodles with a side of mini meatballs, and extra Marinara Sauce was a huge hit for the little kids. We loved the fresh garlic bread.The soup served by Jimmy's was simply exceptional. Butternut squash soup is my mother’s favorite and it was delicious we loved it.To sweeten the celebration we finished off with Cannolis.What made this experience even more special was the fact that Jimmy himself personally delivered the menu to our mother's birthday party. His warm smile, friendly demeanor, and genuine care made the occasion even more memorable. It's rare to find such personalized service and attention to detail.I cannot thank Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe enough for going above and beyond to make this celebration remarkable. The combination of delicious food, personalized service, and heartwarming gestures truly sets them apart. If you're looking to make your special occasions even more extraordinary, I highly recommend Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent service, great atmosphere, and I have found nothing on the menu that wasn't delicious. Great wine selection. And if you are lucky Jimmy will be in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tenderloin Ceasar Salad, Scampi Romano, Grilled Cesar Salad, Bananas Foster, Calamari
We were very disappointed in the food. The server was unique...difficult to understand, although with good intentions. Like the neighborhood location & energy in the restaurant; nice looking.