Pie Society Pizza

4615 E Mississippi Ave, Glendale
(303) 757-3333

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brian Sheppard

PEOPLE!!!! I'm telling you, this pizza was absolutely amazing!! They actually offer cream cheese as a topping. If you never had pizza with cream cheese as a topping then you never had a great pizza! Seriously, trust me

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joseph Vincent

Screwed up my order and two other orders while I was there. Never put in my order, another order, and screwed up a third order. She then started cursing me out instead of admitting she screwed up.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Jason Martin

Used to be awesome when some dude with a bunch of pizza tats worked there. The pizza is bad now, overly cheesy every time. No care put in to it at all. The service is slow as possible but they are nice. As a New Yorker that knows pizza, I won’t be going here any more.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

E G

Very solid food and pies and the nice lady there gave our dog some slices of pepperoni. ????

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Casey Henderson

For 8 bucks, you too can be the proud owner of 2 burnt greasy slices.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chris Lenda

Very disappointing.
I travel extensively for work and always try to eat local when I do.
After a long day of meetings, I wasn't feeling great and wanted delivery. This place was close.
I ordered a 16" pepperoni and mushroom, pretty basic. This was at around 5:50pm that I placed my order online, and they said delivery would be between 6:45 and 6:50. Timing was fine and not too long given it was the dinner rush.
The food didn't arrive until 7:35 but the woman delivering it was very kind and friendly.
My disappointment started as soon as I opened the box. The pizza was partially folded over on itself and of course was stripped of toppings when I tried to unfold it.
The pepperoni spread was adequate but the mushrooms were sparse.
At some places the crust was so thin I could literally see red (sauce) through it.
Disappointed all around and won't return.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 4

Dretsel Johnson

Good pizza I was pleasantly surprised. Never had been to this place before but I decided to give it a try and the pizza was actually good ? I must confirm.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Wings, Wings, The Cherry Creek Trail Salad, Cannoli, Build Your Own Pasta, Pepperoni Roll

David Harring

Never again

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Karl Franklin

I dont write many reviews anymore but this place.. im new to denver looked online seen some reviews and thought ok this should be some of the best pizza ever... Idk how this place has 4 stars.
I wald inside there is dust and black dirt all over the ceiling and vent fans and walls now im from California so hole in the wall shops usually have the best food but this was not the case, i was told will be ready in 20 minutes waited over an hour in the blazing heat outside in my car for a 15 inch pizza and amazing seasoned frys or at least i was told the frys were amazing by an employee, i make my order and before i tipped i told the employee i was tipping hey il leave you a tip if you bring it out to my car when it is done after im waiting at least 40 minutes i see employees leaving with food for themselves fo i go inside and ask if my pizza is ready and its not formed yet nor frys cooked was told 10 more minutes, so i go back outside in the heat, after an hour i see the employee i told i would tip if she would bring my pizza put to me in my car so im not in and out coming out with pizza and other food and i think ok finally this is my order nope she gets in her car and takes off, at this point im thinking my pizza is probably never going to actually be made so i go so after another 30 mins i go back inside and im told 10 minutes again this time i wait inside and wait 20 minutes and then i hear my name i get up to check the pizza out its a small box of pizza and frys that definitely came from the king soopers freezer isle, i had ordered a 16 inch pizza for family not this mittle pizza that was given to me she asked me if i could wait a little bit longer and she would make me another pizza.... i had already been waiting way to ling to go thru that again, at that point i asked for a refund the only good thing about this place was the manager actually giving me a refund asking me if i want to take the food still i said no then as i am leaving she asked again so this time i said yes i take the pizza i open it up in the car i am immediately disappointed with the quality of the pizza so i go to a local mexican food restaurant to get food for my family because a tiny pizza was not it, i get home everyone grabs a slice and trys it without me explaining the situation of me waiting or a bad vibe of the irritating eye twitch that i had prior to entering my home, the frys... idk i cant even get into it, just cook at home if you plan on eating here just go somewhere else dont even waste your time with this placewe did not finish the pizza it was a great first bite but everything after that was horrible so before we threw it away i took a few pictures to show that this is the quality you get here... i will say thank you to the manager for trying to make things right in what way she can that wqs about the only positive thing from this place i experienced i always end up in the worst places to eat in Denver idk how i do it but it keeps happening and only in denver if anyone has better places to get food in denver please lmk asap i just moved here and i am absolutely hating the food here i wish i just stopped at McDonald's it has more flavor more season in the frys and you are out pretty quick, i will never buy from this place again nor will i eat anything from this place this was the absolute worst pizza stop i had made in my life, the cardboard little Ceasars was better...

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Robert Lipper Jr

I love'd the pizza but damn when did the slices get smaller and more expensive? The staff wasn't exactly friendly either. Guess I will have to find another pizza place in Glendale.

Kris Kilton

Pizza is great and the homemade tiramisu is amazing! Great service too.

Vegetarian options: They have vegan cheese

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu

Kw Muldo

My pizza was absolute perfection, sometimes when you get a really large pizza the middle ends up being soggy for some reason but not with this place it is perfectly cooked with the right amount of crispy, each one of my jalapenos was the size of a silver dollar and it was ready in like 15 minutes I've been eating here for 5 years and even if I move I'm coming back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Ryan Schmich

Great, efficient service but pizza is lacking. Dry and flavorless. Ordered extra cheese and there’s less cheese than dominoes. First thing I noticed was the box seemed light for a large pie. My wife and I split a large with no leftovers and usually have 3-4 slices left when we order from garlic knot. Wanted to try something new but won’t be ordering from here again.

Food: 2

Service: 5

Carter Schmidt

Big fan of the pizza and the wings, and especially love the desserts, namely the cannoli's, Will definitely be coming back a lot in the future!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cannoli, Tiramisu, Wings, Biscotti, Pepperoni Pizza

Sean Kannegieter

Excellent, great pizza and lady was happy for business when I picked

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...