Mamma Silvia's Italian Kitchen

Absolutely flawless dining experience. Service, food, ambience, music. I can’t say enough.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

What a treat to find this gem on our recent trip to Durango Four different people all declaring it was the best ever; each enjoying a different dish From the garlic bread with marinara, sea bass, lobster, filet and a pasta dish, everything was a delicious delight And don’t miss the donuts for dessert Very happy diners Thank you!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Went on Valentine’s Day. Out of bread. Service was poor and server acted happy that they were near their shift. We have been a regular customer for years and things have gone downhill in last few months.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 3

We were there for the first time, but certainly not the last. The food was fantastic, plenty and very good quality.
The staff is very friendly, profesional. They're not constantly bugging but there when needed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went for our Valentines dinner & it was a great experience! We did forget VDay was coming up so we reserved for the last possible time. They were still so kind to us and provided full service. Didn't make us feel uncomfy for being last!
The food was delicious. We had the Caprese appetizer and oh my goodness?! Beautiful. Amazing. I had the pesto linguine (mwah, it was perfect). Onlyyyyy small tiny complaint (but not really because we were dead last) is that my boyfriends Lobster ravioli was not very hot. But he still enjoyed every bite!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Family night out and our server was awesome! She knows how to entertain kiddos, and she was a Rock Star Mom/ waitress. I highly recommend you ask for Jordan to go over the menu with you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

good looking crew with good attitude 😉

The food was amazing. I had the lasagna, which was absolutely perfect. My only complaint is that we were seated at a small table in a dark corner and could not read the menus in the dark. The lights in our corner were not working, so we had to request a flashlight in order to read the menus. I would highly recommend this restaurant.

Our table for 8 was in a quiet place IN THE BACK so we were very fortunate. The service was outstanding. Our server Kate was very attentive . My only comment was the calamari was too well cooked and small pieces...but taste was good. My chicken piccata was excellent and all the other entrees looked amazing.

Excellent food and generous portions. Very busy New Year's Eve. We will return next time we visit Durango.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

This was a family dinner so server (Holly) was attentive. Kids enjoyed their mozzarella cheees fries immensely. The mushroom polenta app was delicious, as were two of the adult entrees, the penne rustica and the seafood entree were really tasty, although the eggplant was sparse on the rustica. The lower rating was because the lasagne was really disappointing: it was dried out, and the pasta felt chewy, tough... like it had been microwaved...

Incredible dinner after Polar Express Experience. The best Italian restaurant I have eaten at in a long time. I had Maine lobster with rich, creamy linguine. My husband had Chicken Parmesan that was moist, incredible flavors and shared a bottle of wine!
Atmosphere is authentic, cozy Italian, service was great and prices were remarkable for the food and wine.
Will be back again next time we visit Durango.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best Italian food that I have had in years!!!

The food was delicious!! I had linguini with clams and my husband the chicken marsala. Generous portions and well-prepared. Great flavor. Red sauce was excellent! Service was prompt and friendly on a very busy night. Management made a mistake on our bill, but immediately fixed the problem. Great dining experience.

We've been coming to this restaurant every year for the last 8 years when we come to town for the polar express. Last year and this year we've left feeling overall disappointment in our experience. The place has become a bit shabby feeling and could do with a good deep cleaning. There was a groove between the two table we were sitting at that had caked up food and grime. My daughter was able to pick it with a knife. The special lobster thermidor was just ok, for $49, and the lobster was so fishy tasting. We had a similar experience last year but thought it was just a bad night. Our server and the bussers were great overall. But, we'll think twice before coming back next year since it is an expensive place to go ($200 + with the tip for 4 of us), to not feel great about the whole thing.