Mamma Silvia's Italian Kitchen

The food was amazing. I had the lasagna, which was absolutely perfect. My only complaint is that we were seated at a small table in a dark corner and could not read the menus in the dark. The lights in our corner were not working, so we had to request a flashlight in order to read the menus. I would highly recommend this restaurant.

Our table for 8 was in a quiet place IN THE BACK so we were very fortunate. The service was outstanding. Our server Kate was very attentive . My only comment was the calamari was too well cooked and small pieces...but taste was good. My chicken piccata was excellent and all the other entrees looked amazing.

This was a family dinner so server (Holly) was attentive. Kids enjoyed their mozzarella cheees fries immensely. The mushroom polenta app was delicious, as were two of the adult entrees, the penne rustica and the seafood entree were really tasty, although the eggplant was sparse on the rustica. The lower rating was because the lasagne was really disappointing: it was dried out, and the pasta felt chewy, tough... like it had been microwaved...

The food was delicious!! I had linguini with clams and my husband the chicken marsala. Generous portions and well-prepared. Great flavor. Red sauce was excellent! Service was prompt and friendly on a very busy night. Management made a mistake on our bill, but immediately fixed the problem. Great dining experience.

We've been coming to this restaurant every year for the last 8 years when we come to town for the polar express. Last year and this year we've left feeling overall disappointment in our experience. The place has become a bit shabby feeling and could do with a good deep cleaning. There was a groove between the two table we were sitting at that had caked up food and grime. My daughter was able to pick it with a knife. The special lobster thermidor was just ok, for $49, and the lobster was so fishy tasting. We had a similar experience last year but thought it was just a bad night. Our server and the bussers were great overall. But, we'll think twice before coming back next year since it is an expensive place to go ($200 + with the tip for 4 of us), to not feel great about the whole thing.

This was the first time that we were at this restaurant. It is a very small restaurant but the food was delicious. We were seated by the kitchen and were impressed with the kitchen. There were wonderful smells that came out of the kitchen. Plus the deserts were fabulous. We mentioned this to family members that live in Durango and they had never been there. They said that they will have to try it. We know that we will be back the next time we are visiting Durango.

For 28 dollars you can get an overcooked, underseasoned chicken parm, paired with no pasta. Instead you can get a tablespoon of overcooked veggies and 2 undercooked baby potatoes. Between the charred chicken and the rock hard potatoes I’m not sure which would break my tooth first. At least the water was good and the waitress was nice cause if not I would’ve had to fight the hostess for evening giving me a table. Mamma Silvia would be disappointed, and so am I.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

The barata salad was excellent! The pork entree however was tough, over cooked. The staff was very friendly, and atmosphere is very nice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Absolutely delicious! Had carpaccio, pistachio crusted sea bass and veal piccata. Holly was a terrific server and the bat tender really knew the menu and the chef was very energetic!

Excellent service from Holly.She was friendly and efficient. Food was hot and tasted fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

One of my all-time favorite restaurants in Durango.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was not good. Our pasta dishes were served cold. Lamb chops were not edible.water was not good. No ice. Waited over an hour from order time until food was served. Restaurant was not busy other than the bar. Save yourself some time and disappointment. This place has really gone downhill.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

The food was really good. The tables that we sat at, to the right of the bar, are super uncomfortable. And it is very difficult to get your feet in a comfortable spot because the legs of the tables are so wide that you have no place to put your feet.

Excellent meal! Food was fantastic from beginning to end!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food, service and ambiance. The sourround music was a little loud. Other than that, very very nice.