Eaton Pizza & Subs
123 1st St, Eaton
(970) 454-1068
Customers' Favorites
Cinnamon Sticks
Italian Salad
Meatball Sub
Cheese Sticks
Cheese Pizza
BBQ Chicken
Italian Sub
Taco Pizza
Calzone
Sauce
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
DID YOU CHANGE THE COOKIE RECIPE?! ? still giving you 5 stars because it’s my fave pizza… but I’m like 99% sure yall changed the cookie recipe and it’s killing meeee please change it back ??
We have had take out pizza 3 or 4 times since moving to Eaton. Usually get pepperoni and cream cheese pizza is very tasty. Thin crust. The inside decor of the restaurant is dated and the seating area is small. There is a cool old Galaga arcade game. Breadsticks are decent. Salad is OK. Good ranch, seemed homemade.
You May Also Like
Venezia Italian Restaurant and Bar - 130 1st St
![]()
Italian, Wine Bar, Seafood
Route 85 Grill - 131 1st St
![]()
New American, Sports Bar, Pizza
Tradecraft Coffee - 108 Oak Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
The root-beer float was by FAR the best thing I’ve ever experienced in my 29 years of life. The ice cream is DEVINE!
The cheese bread made my husbands eyes cross the moment he took a bite.
I wish I could truly comment on the pizza but I can not because the bread, ice cream AND the cinnamon bread took over all empty compartments in my stomach.
We will be returning back, we will...