Muddy Buck Coffee House

28065 CO-74 #101, Evergreen
(303) 670-0433

Recent Reviews

Sort by
brittany bogard

Waited 53 minutes for a blt and egg sandwich at a order at counter coffee shop with small food menu. No warning of wait time from staff. No AC. High prices. Go anywhere else.

*Update: upon getting home and opening the togo box there was also a hair in the food.

Menahem Deitcher

Coolest place in Evergreen

Collin McCloskey

Had to work in the morning before an afternoon hike. Great place to stop and open up the laptop!

Tawnia W

We decided to grab a quick lunch here after spending time shopping.

The menu is not extensive but what we ate we were pleased with. We ordered their version of a BLT, served on a croissant. The highlights though were the pastries we had for dessert. AMAZING! Flaky and flavorful and so good we came back for two more to take home.

We didn't try coffee that day but we bought some to bring home for ourselves and friends. It's been received with positive comments.

We plan to return whenever we're in the area visiting family.

William Westfall

You can't go wrong here! The rustic charm, outdoor seating, handmade food, top coffee and I have never had a bad experience with ANY staff. Family, kid, dog, and people of all ages, friendly!

Ryan Manzoline

I took my mother who was visiting here on mother's day to this coffee shop- after walking into a less than half full store with no line, we were told they weren't serving food - at noon while half empty on mother's day ?? Don't come here- go anywhere else in evergreen

Ben Dreessen

Wonderful place. Great coffee that they roast on site!

M Murphy

We must have been here on the wrong day for cinnamon rolls. The rolls where dry and flavorless. I think the rolls where made early to prepare for Mother's day weekend, tasted stale and old. I appreciate the rolls did NOT have a glaze, I'm not a fan of sugar toppings. Service was ok, the roll was ready at the pickup counter but waited another 15 minutes to pick up breakfast burrito. Hard to eat breakfast together when food is available at different times. Would have ok to hold the roll till burrito was ready. Probably won't be back, I'll give another place a try before returning.

Steve Reiter

Some of the best chai in the state, great coffee, incredible atmosphere. If I lived in Evergreen, this would be my regular place to hole up for working.

Julie Shaw

I love everything about the place but have a hard time finding a seat. That's good news for you, yet it's bad news for those of us who would like to eat at your establishment. Too many people with computers who order one cup of coffee and sit there for 2+ hours. That should either be eliminated or implement some sort of timeframe. An hour maybe? I've watched too many people who would probably like to eat come in, look around and leave because of lack of seating.
Just a thought.

Recommended dishes: Biscuits and Gravy, Breakfast Burrito

Brian Andrews

Hosted a Christmas party and the staff were all amazing! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rod Morgan

Cappuccino was good. WiFi blocked web access to QuickBooks and Microsoft RDP. The lighting is really poor.

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 5

Greg Muller

We love returning here to enjoy their massive and delicious cinnamon buns.
Lovely cosy ambience which currently has a festive feel.
Tried the chocolate croissant for the first time. Luvly jubbly!
Now for a leisurely walk around the lake.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: That's a Cinnamon Roll

Libby Derenthal

Family friendly, cozy, comfortable and great service. It turns into a bar in the evening. We will be coming back!

Kid-friendliness: Had high chairs and low tables

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jake Waters

Great local coffee shop with a unique cozy interior.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Loading...