Cakes By Tiffanie

8300 Mummy Range Dr, Fort Collins
(970) 988-5594

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mira Roselles

She was quick to reply to my emails and easy to communicate with. I sent her some inspiration photos and she nailed it! Beautiful cupcakes and a small wedding cake. It was better than I could have imagined, they not only looked beautiful but tasted delicious! She was professional, arrived on time, had an easy payment portal, and helped my crazy day setting up for our reception go smooth. Amazing!

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Cupcake

Allison Kloepper

Made the dairy free cake for my wedding. It was great tasting and gorgeous! I drove down from cheyenne to get it and it was fine for the drive and me transporting it the day of.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Isabela Pimenta

Tiffanie made the most perfect cake for our wedding! All of our guests commented on how beautiful and absolutely delicious it was. The cake was tender and fluffy, perfectly designed, and full of flavors. We couldn’t be happier with our experience and highly recommend working with her!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kimberly Johnson

We ordered a cake with two themes for both of our kiddos since they share a birthday.
The design was spot on, you can see the love that goes into her cakes. The texture was so moist and fresh it was definitely the best cake we've ever had. So thankful.

Nicole Ruby

Thank you so much for an absolutely beautiful and delicious cake for our daughter's wedding!!

Akelah Hess

She is AMAZING. I don’t even like cake much, but our wedding cake was delicious and beautiful. She communicated so well and made the trip to deliver for us. Thank you so much Tiffanie.

Lashawn Alvarez

Absolutely love the cakes Tiffanie makes she is amazing at what she does and I am so thankful I found a baker who takes pride in their work. I am a returning customer of hers and I highly recommend. This is the 3rd year I've ordered birthday cakes from her and each one has exceeded my expectations!! thank you so much!!! I will be in touch for another cake soon. As my other childs bday is coming up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jody Anselmo

Dear Tiffanie,
Thank you so much for taking the time to meet with us through the cake tasting
process. We truly enjoyed sampling the almond, chocolate, and vanilla with raspberry
Filling—that we chose each one was absolutely delicious! It was impossible to choose just one,
So we’re thrilled to have all three flavors as part of our wedding cake.
We appreciate the time you took to discuss our vision for the wedding cake and groom’s cake.
Your expertise and kindness made the experience so enjoyable,
I wanted to take a moment to thank you for creating the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake! I absolutely loved it! It was exactly what I had imagined, from the flowers to the lights-–it was absolutely gorgeous. You truly brought my vision to life, I couldn’t have been happier.
Our guest really enjoyed having a choice of flavors, and every single slice was gone by the
End of the night! We took the topper home, planning to save it for our one- year anniversary…
but it didn’t last —we couldn’t resist eating it! It was just that good. Needless to say, we’ll definitely be ordering another on for next year!
Even the next day after the wedding, our neighbor asked if we had any cake left over because he wanted another slice of cake, he said it was the best cake he ever had. That speaks volumes about your amazing talent! I have already requested that all my birthday cakes be made by you. Thank you again for making our wedding day so special with your incredible cakes. We were married on February 14th and your beautiful creation was the perfect sweet touch to our celebration.
With gratitude,
Jody Zubia

Brittany Fiske

We ordered german chocolate cupcakes for my dad’s surprise birthday party and they were soo Amazing! Everyone loved them. We will for sure order from her in the future!

Anita Jean Musslewhite Harvey

Tiffanie has the best cake! beautiful and delicious...a rare find. our surprise party was delayed due to covid, but when we were able to reschedule she jumped right in. She is a talented baker and has a spectacular soul. love ya lady!

Charito Silvis Stafford

I asked for cake for my husband's birthday. His favorite cake is Watergate cake. Tiffanie was more than obliging to make it. It was perfect. So delicious 😋

Josey Geller

Tiffanie made the most perfect cake for our son’s birthday. I sent her a picture of the goofiest stuffed animal he has and she made a cake that resembles it perfectly. She brought the cake to me on time and I couldn’t be any happier I chose her to make my cake.

Shaun Franklin

She is the real deal quality baker. Very tasty and gorgeous creations.

Meghan Kilgrow

I’ve ordered cakes from Tiffanie on two separate occasions, and both times she’s delivered beautifully. The cakes are delicious and look exactly like the photos I’ve given her.

Lily Candocia

Tiffanie can bring your vision to life like no other. If you can dream it, she can do it

Loading...