Gib's New York Bagels
2531 S Shields St # 2E, Fort Collins
(970) 224-5946
Customers' Favorites
French Toast Bagel with Blueberry Maple Cream Cheese
Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese
Gib's Half Dozen Bagels
Breakfast Sandwich
Spinach Artichoke
Italian Soda
Snickerdoodle
Hot Pastrami
The Italian
Pizza
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Ever since the remodel all the Vibes are gone. Not only does the place no longer have the charm it used to but they are also slower. The bagels are still just as good but the remodel was a really bad idea. We don't go there nearly as often because it doesn't have the same feeling anymore. It feels like a corporate fast food chain.
Newly renovated to include both Spoons soups and Gibs Bagels with lots of space for seating. Great selection of food and drinks for breakfast, lunch and dinner for dine in or take out.
The customer appreciation wall with customer photos is still there, which is great.
Orders may take a while when things are busy, but the bagels and newly added selections are great. The smoothies are a treat as well, though only offered in larger sizes.
The customer appreciation wall with customer photos is still there, which is great.
Orders may take a while when things are busy, but the bagels and newly added selections are great. The smoothies are a treat as well, though only offered in larger sizes.
Staff were kind. Wait time was a little ridiculous. I spent 25 minutes of my 30 minute lunch waiting around. I got a Buffalo chicken wrap that was amazing and an egg and cheese bagel breakfast sandwich which was quite possibly the most bland thing I've ever tasted. I would not recommend getting anything with cheese in it. It's rubbery and kind of gross.
You May Also Like
Simply Thai - 2531 S Shields St #2M
![]()
Thai, Vegetarian
Simmer Fort Collins - 2519 S Shields St #1f
![]()
American, Cocktail Bar, Wine Bar, New American